September Town Council Meeting 9/11/26 Part 2
September 10, 2026 at 6:00 PM
- 4 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The Town of Montreat Council held its regular meeting on September 10, 2026. The agenda included a public forum, a public hearing regarding a Planned Unit Development (PUD) application, and several administrative and financial items. The council adopted the agenda as amended, removing an item regarding board appointments due to missing materials and clarifying that the PUD request would be handled as a public hearing.
Key Decisions The council took the following actions during the meeting:
- Agenda Adoption: The motion to adopt the agenda as amended passed 4-0.
- MRA PUD Application: The council voted to defer the decision on the Mountain Retreat Association (MRA) PUD application for the 309 Collegiate Circle parcel to the October 8, 2026, regular meeting. The motion to defer passed 2-1, with Kitty Fouche voting against the deferral.
- Solid Waste Ordinance and Contract: The council approved the Solid Waste Disposal and Refuse Collection Ordinance Amendment, which replaces the hourly-rate-based cleanup fee with a flat $125 fee, by a vote of 3-0. The council also approved the Solid Waste Services Contract with Consolidated Waste Services, including amendments defining "active residential household" and requiring the re-latching of locked containers, by a vote of 3-0.
- Budget Amendment #3: The council approved Budget Amendment #3 to add donations to the budget for Fund 29 (Helene), Fund 40 (Stone Bridges), and Town Hall Landscaping Donations. The motion passed 4-0.
- Purchase Resolutions: The council approved Resolution #26-09-001 and Resolution #26-09-002 to approve all purchases on both resolutions that lacked pre-audit. The motion passed 4-0.
- Litigation Resolution: Following a closed session to consult with an attorney regarding the Hayner et al vs. MRA and Town of Montreat litigation, the council voted to allow the Town Manager to execute all documents necessary to resolve the matters. The motion passed 3-0.
Discussion Highlights The primary focus of the meeting was the MRA PUD application, which proposes rezoning 309 Collegiate Circle from Institutional Residential to a PUD Conditional Zoning District to build a 24-room lodge and two 8-bedroom cottages. During the public hearing, Commissioner Mason Blake expressed major concerns regarding pedestrian traffic impacts on Assembly Drive, noting that the lack of sidewalks and improvements for children crossing had not been "screwed down tight enough." He also requested more specificity regarding tree preservation than simply "following code." Commissioner Grant Dasher stated he was "uncomfortable voting tonight when only 60% of our elected officials are here" and moved to delay the vote to ensure a full quorum.
Regarding the purchase resolutions, staff noted that no town in North Carolina is fully compliant with pre-audit requirements. One member clarified that the current building’s existence relies on a pre-audit stamp, which was not completed in this instance. Another member acknowledged the sensitivity of discussing a "pre-audit not done" status.
Community Input During the public forum, residents discussed the MRA PUD, tax increases, and local parks. A public commenter expressed concern that a property in front of her home, designated as a permanent park, might be used for parking; she later returned during the regular meeting to provide a 1937 letter from the MRA president to her uncle confirming the land was donated as a "perpetual park." Another public commenter noted that Montreat’s 5-year tax increase (24.4%) was lower than Buncombe County’s (42.4%) and thanked the council for fiscal responsibility.
During the MRA PUD public hearing, a public commenter argued that the proposed 41 parking spaces were insufficient for 70 rooms and asked the council not to approve the PUD until parking was adequately addressed. Representatives of the "Montreat Stewards" stated they could not support the PUD in its current form and requested the council continue it to a future meeting to allow for further negotiation on issues like tree protection and building location changes. Other public commenters spoke in support of the MRA, citing the organization's historical role and the need for new lodging.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to work with the Town Attorney to define "active residential household" and add a provision for relatching trash cans before finalizing the solid waste contract. Staff also introduced the interim zoning administrator, who will serve until a full-time hire joins in November. A staff member was tasked with working on a policy to make P-card purchases less cumbersome for staff while maintaining statutory compliance.
Impact The deferral of the MRA PUD application means that the rezoning of 309 Collegiate Circle will not be finalized until the October 8, 2026, meeting, allowing for further review of parking and pedestrian safety concerns. The approval of the solid waste contract and ordinance amendments establishes new terms for waste collection services and cleanup fees for residents. The approval of the budget amendment incorporates recent donations into the town's financial planning for specific funds. Finally, the authorization for the Town Manager to execute documents regarding the Hayner et al litigation allows the town to proceed with resolving the ongoing legal matter.
Meeting Video & Transcript