Historic Resources Commission
December 10, 2025 at 4:00 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 2 h 9 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: December 10, 2025
The Historic Resources Commission of Asheville and Buncombe County held an in-person meeting on December 10, 2025, to review proposed changes to properties within the city’s historic districts. The agenda included routine administrative business, the approval of previous minutes, and public hearings for several Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) requests in the Biltmore Village and Montford Historic Districts. The meeting also featured a demonstration of a new broadcasting system designed to improve camera quality and public viewing access.
Key Decisions The Commission took the following actions on the agenda items:
- Administrative: The motion to approve the administrative items passed by a vote of 5-0.
- Minutes: The Commission approved the minutes from the November 12, 2025 meeting, along with the associated Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law.
- 5-9 Kitchin Place: The Commission passed the request to replace the front entry door, install new awnings and signage, and apply opaque film to rear windows. The recorded vote was 5-0.
- 15 Pearson Dr: The Commission passed the request to modify two existing windows on a side elevation and partially enclose the porch on the rear elevation. The recorded vote was 5-0.
- 123 West Chestnut Street: The Commission passed the request to construct a new one-and-a-half story, 1,000-square-foot accessory structure. The recorded vote was 5-0.
- 52 Cumberland Circle: The hearing for the replacement of screening on the rear porch with windows was continued to the January 14, 2026 meeting.
- 71 Starnes Ave: The Commission approved the request to remove a rear addition and deck and construct a new rear addition and covered porch.
Discussion Highlights Chair Will Hornaday reviewed the Commission’s quasi-judicial role, emphasizing adherence to North Carolina General Statutes and Asheville ordinances, and outlined procedures for public comment and witness testimony. During the review of 15 Pearson Dr, staff raised concerns regarding the scale of the proposed accessory dwelling unit (ADU) in relation to the main house. This prompted a discussion on how "scale" is defined within historic district guidelines. The Commission noted that the city’s definition excludes unconditioned spaces, such as garages, from square footage calculations. For 5-9 Kitchin Place, the Commission confirmed that the proposed changes were consistent with historic district guidelines, specifically noting the compatibility of the new door design.
Community Input A landlord representative spoke in favor of the 5-9 Kitchin Place proposal, emphasizing the project’s contribution to revitalizing Biltmore Village. A resident spoke regarding the 15 Pearson Dr proposal, clarifying that the city’s regulations exclude unconditioned spaces from square footage calculations and emphasizing the project's adherence to historic district guidelines.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to review an arborist report and documentation regarding the proposed retaining wall for the 15 Pearson Dr project. The city will verify the address for the ADU at 15 Pearson Dr to ensure proper emergency response capabilities. Additionally, the hearing for 52 Cumberland Circle will continue at the January 14, 2026 meeting.
Impact These decisions allow property owners in the Biltmore Village and Montford Historic Districts to proceed with specific renovations, including storefront updates, porch enclosures, and accessory structures, provided they meet the conditions set by the Commission. The approval of these projects reflects the Commission's role in balancing property improvements with the preservation of the historic character of these neighborhoods.
Meeting Video & Transcript