City Council
December 2, 2024 at 5:30 PMCity Council Chambers
- 2 h 17 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: December 2, 2024
The Brevard City Council held its regular meeting on December 2, 2024, in the City Council Chambers. The agenda covered a range of topics, including the approval of previous minutes, proclamations for local achievements and holidays, a significant update on affordable housing development, and several public hearings regarding land use and emergency response. The council also addressed new business items related to public art, fee schedules, and the 2025 meeting schedule.
Key Decisions and Votes The council approved the minutes from the November 18, 2024, Regular Meeting by a vote of 6-0. The council unanimously approved the consent agenda, which included property tax releases for November 2024, personnel policy revisions, and committee minutes from the Housing and Parks, Trails, and Recreation committees.
In new business, the council approved a public art application for a mural at 360 Whitmire Street by a vote of 6-0. The council also adopted an amendment to the fee schedule to waive planning permit fees for emergency response and recovery activities, passing the motion 6-0. Additionally, the council approved a resolution requesting the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) to transfer ownership of West Main Street (from Caldwell Street to Oaklawn Avenue) to the City, with a vote of 6-0. The 2025 meeting schedule was approved 6-0, setting the Priority Setting Retreat for Friday, March 7, 2025. Finally, the council voted 6-0 to cancel the regular meeting scheduled for December 16, 2024.
Public Hearings and Ordinance Actions The council held three public hearings, all of which were opened and closed without public comment.
- Voluntary Contiguous Annexation: The council heard a petition for the annexation of four properties (4.640 acres) on Forest Hill Drive owned by Mills Ave Properties, LLC. No vote was taken on the annexation itself at this time; it was a hearing only.
- UDO Amendments for Emergency Response (Chapters 3 and 21): The council adopted amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) to establish a framework for development activities following a declared emergency. The motion was amended to limit the applicability of the new Emergency Response and Recovery chapter to states of emergency declared by the City Manager and/or the Mayor of the City of Brevard, specifically for natural disasters or public health events. The amended motion passed 6-0.
- UDO Legislative Changes (Chapters 2, 3, 5, 6, 9, 12, 13, 16, 17, and 19): The council adopted amendments to comply with recent state legislation updates regarding zoning and land use. The motion to adopt the amendments as written passed 6-0.
Discussion Highlights A major portion of the meeting was dedicated to a presentation by the Development Finance Initiative (DFI) regarding the affordable housing project on the Brevard Davidson River Presbyterian Church site. Geotechnical findings revealed significant soil stability issues, increasing the estimated development cost for a 50-unit project to approximately $19 million. This created a funding gap of $4.5 million if Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) equity is secured, or up to $17 million if not. City Manager Wilson Hooper summarized the situation by stating, "To summarize, it put us in a big hole." Councilman Aaron Baker expressed a desire to keep the site in consideration, stating, "I'm not ready to give up on this site for anything. I think it's just sort of an opportunity for us to continue to... think creatively." The council discussed keeping the lease with the church open for five years to allow for potential changes in interest rates or LIHTC rules, while shifting focus to other sites in the interim.
The council also recognized the Brevard High School Boys' Cross Country Team for winning the 2024 state championship. Mayor Maureen Copelof read a proclamation designating December 2, 2024, as "Blue Devils Boys Cross Country Team Day" and noted, "I have to say, you know, this should be our annual get-together. I expect you guys every year to be doing just this well and continuing with this tradition." The Mayor also read a proclamation for Kwanzaa Week (December 26, 2024 – January 1, 2025), honoring the late Crystal Carley, who helped initiate the tradition, stating, "Crystal was quite an amazing woman... We miss her."
Community Input During public comments, a resident expressed appreciation for the city’s response to previous concerns about school crossing guards, noting that the guard at Greenville High is now present at 7:25 AM. However, the commenter noted that the guard at Elm Bend has been shifted and is no longer present at 7:25 AM, affecting other parents. The commenter requested that if the city cannot provide a guard at that location, they should inform parents so they can adjust their plans. Members did not respond.
Another public commenter, residing in Penrose, apologized for previously using the word "corrupt" regarding the police department, preferring "misinformed." The commenter stated that the department has lost at least 14 employees in the last two years due to "terrible leadership," "bullying, harassment, and intimidation" from the captain, and that the captain was promoted over more qualified employees. The commenter urged the Council to conduct an outside review and follow up with former officers to get the truth. Members did not respond.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to work with the church and DFI to determine the best path forward for the Presbyterian Church site, including a conversation about keeping the lease open. Councilman Aaron Baker requested more information on the potential for easements for the multi-use path on the annexation property (Forest Hill Drive) before the next meeting when the annexation is voted on; staff agreed to work on this information. Regarding the discussion on waiving Temporary Access Point (TAP) fees for temporary emergency housing, staff agreed to put together a more solid proposal for Council approval at the next meeting. Planning Director Paul Ray agreed to mention to the public art applicant the suggestion to include an explanation/signage near the mural to help residents identify the local wildlife depicted.
Impact The adoption of the UDO amendments for emergency response and recovery provides a legal framework for temporary housing and services following declared emergencies, such as Tropical Storm Helene, allowing for the placement of RVs and temporary structures with specific duration limits. The waiver of permit fees for these activities aims to reduce costs for residents and organizations involved in recovery efforts. The transfer of West Main Street to city ownership is intended to facilitate the connection of the Ecusta Trail into downtown Brevard. The council’s decision to cancel the December 16 meeting and set the 2025 schedule provides clarity for upcoming governance activities.
Meeting Video & Transcript