City Council
May 5, 2025 at 5:30 PMCity Council Chambers
- 3 h 28 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Brevard City Council Meeting Recap: May 5, 2025
The Brevard City Council held its regular meeting on May 5, 2025, focusing primarily on the FY2026 budget, property revaluation, and several public hearings regarding development and housing. The council approved the minutes from the March 7, 2025 Priority Setting Retreat and set the date for the required public hearing on the FY 2025-2026 Budget for May 19, 2025. Additionally, the council adopted ordinances for a voluntary non-contiguous annexation and a concurrent rezoning request, and approved a loan to purchase property for a future low-to-moderate income housing project.
Key Decisions and Votes The council took the following actions, all of which passed with a vote of 6-0:
- Agenda and Minutes: The council approved the agenda and the minutes of the March 7, 2025 Priority Setting Retreat.
- Budget Hearing Date: The council set May 19, 2025, as the public hearing date for the FY 2025-2026 Budget.
- Azalea Avenue Property Purchase: The council adopted a resolution affirming the acceptance of a $925,000 loan from United Community Bank and instructing staff to execute the purchase of the Azalea Avenue property.
- UDO Amendment: The council approved an amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) to define "abandonment" and introduce a "Flea Market" retail land use. Council Member Daniel moved to amend the motion to allow Flea Markets via Special Use Permit in all mixed-use districts (excluding Institutional Campus and General Industrial), which was seconded and passed.
- Consent Agenda: The council approved the consent agenda, which included a resolution adopting Rotary Club Peace Poles as official government speech and minutes from various council committees and the ABC Board.
- Public Hearings: The council opened and closed public hearings for the annexation and rezoning of four parcels on Reservoir Road and Hampton Road, as well as the Azalea Avenue housing finance item. No speakers signed up for these specific hearings.
- Closed Session: The council entered closed session to discuss pending litigation, including NCDOT v. The Cottages at Brevard.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the presentation of the FY2026 Recommended Budget by City Manager Wilson Hooper. Staff highlighted that nearly $10 million, or two-thirds of the general fund, is dedicated to public safety and public works. The proposed budget includes a 2.75-cent increase in the property tax rate and a 4% increase in utility consumption fees, while the fixed monthly water and sewer fee remains flat at $27. Staff noted that the primary driver of increased tax bills is the recent property revaluation rather than the rate increase itself.
The council also heard a special presentation from Chris Owen, Reappraisal Manager for the Transylvania County Tax Office, regarding the 2025 property revaluation. Owen explained that the total tax value for the City of Brevard increased to just under $2 billion, approximately 50% higher than in 2024. In response to concerns about the revaluation system, Council Member Wise stated, "I think revaluation as a system is flawed, fatally flawed, it's not sustainable... we can work to make it a better system, and we can give tools to our public to help them make sure they are taxed fairly and assessed fairly." Council Member Baker suggested staff reach out to a firm called "Urban 3" in Asheville to help educate the city on how other municipalities have tackled tax equity.
Community Input Residents provided extensive public comment on several issues:
- Police Department: A resident expressed dissatisfaction with the police chief and city manager, citing a lawsuit for retaliatory firing of a sergeant and a "toxic work environment." No council member or staff member responded to this comment.
- Property Tax Revaluation: Multiple residents discussed significant increases in property values, noting disparities between the Rosenwald neighborhood and the East French Broad area. One resident stated, "Please don't move us out, give us a chance to live," expressing fear of displacement. Another resident provided data showing a 209% average tax increase in Rosenwald versus 169% in East French Broad over 10 years. No council members responded to these specific comments.
- Proposed Development: Several residents expressed concern about a proposed 68-home development on 11.5 acres, citing high density, potential flooding risks, and increased traffic. No council members responded to these comments.
- Wastewater Treatment: A resident from Pisgah Forest urged the council to prioritize eliminating hydrogen sulfide smells before expanding capacity. No council members responded.
- Budget Reductions: A resident suggested reducing the basic water charge and negotiating with the DOT regarding roundabout costs. No council members responded.
- Mills Avenue Culvert: A resident asked for an update on the timeline for reopening the road and requested that the city post physical updates near the area. A staff member explained that the city is pursuing a full replacement (approx. $1.5M) with FEMA funding rather than a repair, as the current culvert is undersized for a 100-year flood. The staff member estimated a 6-8 month timeline for design and replacement and stated, "I think we can find a way to do that... We'll have to figure out how to do it where it's a simple enough message to make sense" regarding posting updates.
- Flea Market Definition: A resident expressed support for flea markets in their neighborhood, noting that a weekly flea market has a "very positive impact." In response, Council Member Daniel proposed amending the motion to allow flea markets in all mixed-use districts, stating, "I would like to see it amended to allow any mixed use neighborhood or residential."
Follow-ups
- Revaluation Appeals: Chris Owen informed the council that the County Board of Equalization and Review will adjourn on May 27, 2025. Residents who wish to appeal their 2025 property valuations must submit applications to the board before this date.
- Rosenwald Advisory Committee: Council Member Pamela Holder stated that the Rosenwald Advisory Committee is a "perfect example" of a group that can work with the community to provide awareness and guidance on the revaluation process.
- Budget Questions: The City Manager agreed to receive questions from Council members during the meeting, work with staff to compile answers, and send them in a follow-up document in the days to come.
- COLA Calculation: Staff agreed to calculate the budget impact of a uniform 2.75% or 3% cost-of-living adjustment for all employees, rather than the proposed split of 3.5% for non-management and 2.8% for management.
- Mills Avenue Culvert: Staff agreed to find a way to post physical updates near the affected area to inform residents of the road closure and replacement timeline.
Impact The decisions made at this meeting directly affect residents' finances and the city's development trajectory. The approval of the $925,000 loan for the Azalea Avenue property moves the city forward with a future low-to-moderate income housing project, addressing the city's identified priority for affordable housing. The annexation and rezoning of the four parcels on Reservoir Road and Hampton Road expands the city's boundaries and allows for increased residential density in that area, aligning with the comprehensive land use plan. The UDO amendment for flea markets provides clearer zoning guidelines for periodic sales activities, allowing them in a broader range of mixed-use districts. The upcoming public hearing on May 19, 2025, will provide residents with another opportunity to provide input on the FY2026 budget, which includes significant tax and utility rate changes driven largely by the 2025 property revaluation.
Meeting Video & Transcript