City Council
March 18, 2024 at 5:30 PM95 W Main St, City Council Chambers, Brevard, NC, 28712
- 2 h 35 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: March 18, 2024
The City of Brevard Council held its regular meeting on March 18, 2024, focusing primarily on the proposed development of a trailhead and park facility on the Pisgah Health Foundation property off Allison Road. The council also conducted joint public hearings regarding the historic designation of the Bryant House and an amendment to overnight parking ordinances. Additionally, the body addressed the scope of the Acosta Trail Advisory Committee’s authority, the impact of the NCDOT project on Wilson Road, and the approval of a grant application for downtown streetscape improvements.
Key Decisions and Votes The council approved the agenda and the minutes from the February 19, 2024 regular meeting. The consent agenda, which included tax reports, audit contracts, annexation investigations, and committee minutes, was approved unanimously. The council voted to approve an amendment to Chapter 16 of the Unified Development Ordinance concerning the Planning Board’s role in zoning map amendments. Regarding the Downtown Development Overlay District (DDOD) second expansion, the council first voted to remove the proposal from the table, then voted to approve the DDOD second expansion district. A resolution supporting the application for a North Carolina Department of Commerce Rural Downtown Economic Development Grant, which would fund tree planting and silva cells along West Main Street, was approved unanimously.
Pisgah Health Property and Trailhead Proposal The central debate of the evening concerned the proposed Ecusta Trail trailhead and park at the Pisgah Health property. A motion to approve a resolution authorizing the City Manager to negotiate a short-term lease with Pisgah Health Foundation and seek outside funding for preliminary design failed to receive a second. Following this, Councilman Aaron Baker moved to refer the item to the Parks, Trails, and Recreation Committee for further review, a motion that was seconded and passed. Councilman Aaron Baker expressed significant frustration with the process, stating, "I think this might be the most disappointed I've been sitting in this chair... I felt like we were skipping many, many, many steps along the process." He argued that the Railroad Avenue Depot is already the trailhead and that the city needs a strategic planning session for the Acosta Trail before committing to new infrastructure. Councilman Gary Daniel noted that the Blue Zones Built Environment Committee had previously rejected the Pisgah Health property for a trailhead due to flooding and bridge requirements, stating, "The City of Brevard really doesn't have a plan... this council needs a special planning session to understand what is about to happen to our community." Councilwoman Pamela Holder expressed concern about the cost of the preliminary design ($85,000) and the lack of a completed plan for other parks, stating, "I would like to see... what it might look like if we looked at both locations... so that I could compare." Councilman Lauren Wise noted that the process felt rushed, stating, "I don't feel like there's a rush."
Community Input Public comment on the trailhead location was divided. A public commenter recommended designating the existing Railroad Avenue Depot Park as the primary multi-use hub, citing its existing infrastructure and location on the Estetot Trail. Another resident spoke in favor of developing a park behind the hospital apartments, emphasizing the importance of exercise. A resident of Allison Road expressed confusion about why that site was considered a trailhead, noting it is 2.5 miles from downtown, and shared a letter from their third-grade daughter concerning the wildlife in the field. A representative for the Transylvania-Pennsylvania County a public commenter Authority asked the Council to take its time before making a decision, arguing that a trailhead closer to the town center would have a greater economic impact. A transportation planner raised concerns about the Allison Road site being in a flood zone and a special spot for migratory birds, encouraging voting against the proposal. A representative for the Brevard Bike Alliance urged the Council to improve existing facilities along the Estetot Trail rather than investing in a new trailhead. An owner of a business near the Depot argued that the Allison Road project would not benefit local businesses and would develop at-risk floodplain land. A representative for Sharing House reported on the formation of the Brevard-Transylvania County Housing Coalition and a recent Faith and Housing Summit. An advisory board member for Freedom Park stated that the proposed playground would serve all ages and abilities. No specific council member replied directly to these comments during the public comment period.
Other Discussions and Follow-ups The council discussed the Acosta Trail Advisory Committee’s authority, specifically whether it can make decisions on city property outside the current Conserving Carolina lease. City Attorney Mack McKellar stated he would research whether the committee could be placed under the purview of the Parks and Trails Committee as a subcommittee. A council member stated, "I'll look at it again" regarding the committee's purview and decision-making authority. Councilman Aaron Baker requested an update on the Rosman Highway to Brevard High School section of the path and suggested the Council take back up the work on the Estetot Trail connection between Main Street and the Mary C. Jenkins Community Center. The City Manager agreed to include financial information on the cost of making President’s Day a holiday in an upcoming memo for council consideration during budget deliberations. The City Manager also stated that the state approved an extra $72,000 grant to extend the Norton Creek stringbank restoration into a neighbor's yard and that they will "get the wheels turning on constructing that project." The meeting concluded with a motion to enter a closed session regarding potential litigation; one member voted "Aye," and the chair stated the council was moving into closed session.
Meeting Video & Transcript