City Council
May 20, 2024 at 5:30 PM95 W Main St, City Council Chambers, Brevard, NC, 28712
- 3 h 23 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Brevard City Council Meeting Recap: May 20, 2024
The Brevard City Council held a regular meeting on May 20, 2024, to address the proposed fiscal year 2024-2025 budget, public development requests, and several new business items. The council began by approving the agenda and the minutes from the February 29, 2024 Strategic Planning Retreat and the May 6, 2024 Regular Meeting, both of which passed with a 6-0 vote. The meeting included public hearings on the budget, a voluntary annexation request, and amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO), followed by votes on supplemental spending, public art, and affordable housing initiatives.
Key Decisions and Votes The council took the following actions during the meeting:
- UDO Chapter 15 Amendment: The council passed a motion to adopt the amendment to Chapter 15 of the UDO, which updates board roles, with a 6-0 vote.
- FY24 Supplemental Spending Plan: The council approved the Supplemental Spending Plan and related budget/project amendments, including funding for the Norton Creek renovation and an Estetote Trail study, with a 6-0 vote.
- Public Art Resolution: The council approved a resolution granting permission to commission a mural of Loretta “Moms” Mabley in Clemson Plaza, with a 6-0 vote.
- Affordable Housing Ground Lease: The council approved a resolution adopting a ground lease with Brevard Davidson River Presbyterian Church to facilitate workforce affordable housing development, with a 6-0 vote.
- Consent Agenda: The council approved the consent agenda, which included the April 2024 Tax Settlement Report, the closeout of the Main Street Water and Sewer Improvements project, and minutes from the Parks, Trails, & Recreation and Downtown Master Plan committees, with a 6-0 vote.
- Budget and Annexation: No votes were taken on the full FY 2024-2025 Budget or the Pisgah Hospitality annexation request; these items were held for further discussion or future action.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on the FY 2024-2025 budget, which proposes a 2% property tax increase, higher sanitation and utility fees, and funding for three new full-time firefighters. Council members debated the trade-offs between various projects. Councilman Gary Daniel proposed funding the Estetote Trail and the downtown master fund at $100,000 each while reducing police vehicle replacements to one, stating that the police chief indicated this would be acceptable. Councilman Aaron Baker expressed opposition to the 2% tax increase, citing the complexity of the fire department partnership with the county. Councilman Lauren Wise stated he could not support the tax increase for firefighters, arguing that other necessary increases were already included in the budget.
Regarding the public art mural, Councilman Mac Morrow expressed concern that the original concept for Clemson Plaza was for "evolving art," noting he was "totally shocked" by the shift to a permanent piece, though he stated he was "not against it." He also suggested the city restore the name of the Frank D. Clement Building to honor its history. Councilwoman Pamela Holder shared a personal connection to the artist, noting her father had met Moms Mabley in New York.
On the affordable housing lease, Mayor Maureen Copelof emphasized that "the city cannot do these projects alone" and recognized the partnership with the church. Councilman Aaron Baker called it "remarkable" that the city’s first major affordable housing project is a partnership. City Manager Wilson Hooper strongly discouraged using the city’s fund balance to balance the budget, warning that maintaining a healthy fund balance is crucial for a "soft landing" should the economy enter a recession.
Community Input During public comment and the budget hearing, residents raised several concerns. Multiple residents, including seniors and a pastor, expressed strong opposition to the proposed property tax and utility fee increases, citing the financial strain on fixed incomes and asking the council to find alternative funding sources. One resident argued that reducing the police vehicle budget to fund the Estetote Trail was a safety issue. Other residents raised concerns about downtown streetscape changes, specifically the loss of parking and the safety of roundabouts, and requested that accident data be made available online. A representative from the Brevard Transylvania Housing Coalition spoke in support of the affordable housing partnership, citing statistics on cost-burdened households. Two residents supported proposed traffic calming measures on Probart Street. One resident expressed concern about the mural's subject and location, suggesting the city consider the broader history of music in the community. Members did not respond directly to these comments during the public session.
Follow-ups City Manager Wilson Hooper agreed to calculate trade-offs for alternative funding scenarios regarding police vehicles, the Estetote Trail, and fire department costs, and to include the option of using the fund balance in an addendum document for the next meeting. Staff indicated that actual budget amendments for the first three projects in the supplemental spending plan would be placed on the agenda for approval next month. The ground lease with the church will be voted on by the congregation on June 9, with the city hoping to sign the lease on June 10. Staff will then conduct geotechnical fieldwork and produce a report, and architectural plans are expected by the end of the summer or early fall.
Impact These decisions set the stage for the city’s financial and development priorities for the coming year. The approval of the supplemental spending plan directs funds toward specific infrastructure and community projects, while the ground lease initiates the process for a new workforce housing development. The budget remains under consideration, with the council planning to review additional funding options before a final vote. The annexation request for a vacation rental development and the UDO amendments for group developments will also proceed through the public hearing process, potentially affecting land use and development standards in the area.
Meeting Video & Transcript