City Council Meeting
October 24, 2023 at 12:00 PM
- 4 h 16 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: October 24, 2023
The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on October 24, 2023, to address a wide range of items including public hearings on housing and zoning, new ordinances for outdoor dining, and various contracts and budget amendments. The Council began by proclaiming October as “Sister Cities Month” and approving the combined minutes from the agenda briefing worksession held on October 5, 2023, and the formal meeting held on October 10, 2023.
Key Decisions and Votes The Council voted on numerous items, with most passing unanimously (7-0). These included:
- Contracts and Agreements: Authorization for a contract with CDM Smith Inc. for waterline replacement engineering; an agreement with Waste Reduction Partners for water conservation; a sole-source purchase of CNG station components from P.C. McKenzie; an interlocal agreement with Buncombe County for Code Purple shelter funding; a supplemental agreement with the N.C. Dept. of Transportation for Greenway Connector funds; an interlocal agreement with the Madison County Sheriff’s Office for radio access; an amendment to the Brightly Software contract; and a pre-construction services contract with Frank L. Blum Construction Company for McCormick Field.
- Budget and Finance: A $1.4 million budget amendment to the Harrah’s Cherokee Center - Asheville (HCCA) Capital Fund for Thomas Wolfe Auditorium repairs; a $356,800 budget amendment from the N.C. Dept. of Transportation for the Greenway Connector Project; and the sale of a surplus 2007 John Deere 624J Loader.
- Ordinances: An ordinance enacting speed limit changes (passed 6-1, with Sage Turner voting no); an ordinance amending Section 16-146 regarding outdoor dining; and an ordinance amending the Fees & Charges Manual for outdoor dining.
- Public Hearings: Adoption of the South Slope: A Southside Neighborhood Vision Plan (passed 7-0); conditional zoning for 30 Buchanan Place (McCormick Field) (passed 7-0); and an amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) to revise flag lot standards (passed 7-0).
- Appointments: A resolution appointing a member to the Planning & Zoning Commission (passed 7-0).
Two items were continued to a future date:
- Cottage Development Standards: The Council voted 6-1 (with Sage Turner voting no) to continue the UDO amendment for cottage development standards until January 23, 2024.
- HUD Consolidated Plan Amendments: The Council voted 6-1 (with Sage Turner voting no) to approve amendments to the 2020-2024 Consolidated Plan, which include allowing CDBG funds for HelpMate Inc. to be used outside city limits, reallocating $300,000 for accessibility improvements at 108 Patton Avenue, and expanding Homeward Bound’s HOME funds to include Rapid Rehousing.
Discussion Highlights Staff presented the First Quarter Fiscal Year 2024 Financial Report, noting that while revenues are expected to meet or exceed the budget, sales tax growth has slowed to 1% year-over-year. Taylor Floyd, Budget Manager, stated, "Sales tax revenues were up 1% over July a year ago... That seems like our sales tax revenue growth is slowing... We continue to see some economic uncertainty and some interest rates remaining high... will likely temper growth for the rest of this fiscal year."
Regarding the Disparity Study, Nikki Reid, Director of Community & Economic Development, and Dave Miller of Miller 3 Consulting presented findings showing statistically significant underutilization of minority- and women-owned businesses. Dave Miller stated, "It is our position that [the recent Supreme Court decision] does not usurp or turn over the disparity study industry... The courts in that case quoted Richmond v. Croson several times... and they really underscore that the Croson decision in conducting factual predicates is the model for enacting race conscious initiatives." The Council accepted the study and extended the race- and gender-conscious measures of the Asheville Business Inclusion Policy for five years.
On the McCormick Field conditional zoning, staff clarified that the parking lot is necessary for stadium operations. The City Attorney advised that conditions regarding the adjacent Mountainside Park should not be attached to this rezoning for legal reasons but suggested the Council direct the City Manager to coordinate with staff and the community on those separate issues.
For the Cottage Development standards, a Council member stated, "I really would like to see more research or discussion from an equity lens... I don't know that we've had time to hear from folks in legacy neighborhoods... it could be more housing for whom and who potentially is negatively affected." Another member asked about adding an affordability requirement, to which staff responded that state law limits inclusionary zoning.
Community Input During the public hearing on the HUD Consolidated Plan amendments, a public commenter spoke in support of the HelpMate amendment, emphasizing the need for safe housing for domestic violence survivors. Another public commenter, a restaurant owner, expressed concern about construction on 108 Patton Avenue during the holiday season and requested a delay. In response, Public Works Director Greg Schuler confirmed that the work would be phased in short sections to minimize disruption and that they would coordinate with business owners.
Regarding the McCormick Field zoning, a public commenter urged the Council to address parking and traffic issues at the adjacent Mountainside Park. Another public commenter requested a "road diet" on Biltmore Avenue to improve pedestrian safety.
In general public comment, a public commenter (a developer) expressed disappointment that the Council did not hold a public hearing for the "missing middle" housing amendments, noting that the standard UDO process was bypassed. Another public commenter addressed Mayor Antanette Mosley regarding her age and alleged election irregularities; no Council member directly addressed these specific accusations.
Follow-ups
- Greenway Connector: Staff agreed to host Council members for site tours before the item is heard in November.
- 108 Patton Avenue Project: Staff agreed to phase construction to minimize disruption, coordinate scheduling with business owners, and return to the Urban Forestry Commission in November with feedback on tree species and design changes.
- Cottage Development: Staff agreed to align the amendment with the "Missing Middle" housing study, with a draft available for community review in November/December and considerations to be pulled out by the January 23, 2024 meeting.
- Disparity Study: Staff stated that the Business Inclusion Manager will develop an implementation plan and provide regular updates to the Equity and Engagement Committee.
- Outdoor Dining: Staff stated that the application process will open on November 13, 2023.
- Meeting Schedule: The Chair informed the public that there would be one meeting in November, scheduled for the second part of the month.
Impact These decisions impact residents through improved infrastructure (waterlines, greenways, speed limits), expanded economic opportunities (outdoor dining, disparity study implementation), and housing initiatives (cottage developments, HUD fund reallocations). The continuation of the cottage development and flag lot standards to January 2024 allows for further community engagement and alignment with the "Missing Middle" housing study. The approval of the outdoor dining ordinances formalizes a program that supports local businesses and creates a more vibrant downtown. The Code Purple shelter agreement ensures emergency shelter capacity for those experiencing homelessness during extreme weather this winter.
Meeting Video & Transcript