Skip to main content
  • 4 h 2 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: September 26, 2023

The Asheville City Council held a formal meeting on September 26, 2023, following a worksession. The agenda included the approval of routine consent items, public hearings on three zoning requests, the adoption of the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan, and a review of the City Manager’s report. The council also addressed a previously submitted resolution regarding Medicare for All and received public comment on historical reputational harm.

Key Decisions and Votes

The council unanimously approved the consent agenda, which included the combined minutes from the September 7 and September 12, 2023, meetings. Routine resolutions were adopted unanimously, authorizing the City Manager to execute or amend contracts for the Water Resources Department (Paymentus), North Fork Dam repairs (Schnabel Engineering South P.C.), water treatment plant filters (Black & Veatch International Company), temporary staffing at Harrah’s Cherokee Center - Asheville (Labor Finders), and the Swannanoa River Greenway Project (Baker Grading and Landscaping Inc.). The council also unanimously authorized the City Attorney’s Office to condemn easements for the Swannanoa River Greenway Project and the New Haw Creek Road Sidewalk Project, and approved an ordinance amending Section 19-213 regarding wheel lock fees. Additionally, the council unanimously authorized the donation of surplus police radios to the Woodfin Police Department and the submission of grant applications to the U.S. Housing & Urban Development.

In public hearings, the council unanimously approved the conditional zoning for 4 Grandview Place, 2 Grandview Place, and 1177 Tunnel Road to create a dedicated parking lot for the adjacent East Village Grill. The public hearing for 115 Fairview Road was continued until December 12, 2023. The council voted 5-2 to approve the conditional zoning for 1 Oak Street (Project Aspire); Council Members Antanette Mosley and Kim Roney voted against the measure. Finally, the council adopted the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan by a vote of 5-2, with Council Members Antanette Mosley and Kim Roney voting against adoption.

Discussion Highlights

During the City Manager’s report, staff provided an update on the "Cease the Harm Audit," an independent assessment of harms to African Americans in Asheville and Buncombe County. The selected vendor is Carter Development Group, with whom Buncombe County led the contracting process. The council also recognized Brenda Mills, Director of Equity and Inclusion, for her 18 years with the city and her receipt of the Western Carolina University Master of Public Affairs Alumni of the Year Award.

The most significant debate centered on Project Aspire at 1 Oak Street, a mixed-use development including a 20-story hotel, residential units, and a new YMCA. Council Member Antanette Mosley expressed concern for the quality of life in the East End Valley community, stating she could not vote in favor without considering the impact on neighbors. Council Member Kim Roney stated she intended to support the project but wanted to ensure nearby residents did not feel ignored. Council Member Sheneika Smith voted against the project, stating, "I don't think we are at a place where saying, 'I hear you,' is enough. We're in a position to do something about it."

Regarding the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan, Mayor Esther Manheimer noted that the legal case regarding the Vance Monument is pending in the North Carolina Supreme Court, with oral arguments scheduled for November 1. She emphasized that the city has secured $3 million in private philanthropy to begin implementing parts of the vision plan.

Community Input

Public comment on Project Aspire was divided. Supporters, including representatives from the YMCA and First Baptist Church, argued that the project would provide necessary affordable housing, expand community programs, and revitalize the East End gateway. Opponents, including long-time residents of the East End, raised concerns about the 20-story hotel height, potential displacement, and the car-centric nature of the 1,800 proposed parking spaces. In response to questions from Council Members Antanette Mosley and Kim Roney regarding height reduction, the developer’s representative explained that reducing the hotel height would reduce revenue, potentially impacting YMCA programming, but stated the team was open to exploring options.

A representative for Medicare for All Western North Carolina spoke regarding a previously submitted resolution, linking support for Medicare for All to the Council’s past stances on reparations and homelessness prevention. No Council member or staff member responded to the request to pass the resolution. Another public commenter discussed the history of white supremacy in Asheville, referencing 1900 newspaper advertisements and the "literacy test" campaign in the North Carolina Constitution, and called for the removal of these historical remnants. No Council member or staff member responded to this comment.

Follow-ups

Staff confirmed that data matrix requests for the Cease the Harm Audit were provided to Carter Development Group, with an interim update to the Community Reparations Commission scheduled for December and audit completion in February 2024. Regarding Project Aspire, the developer’s team committed to maintaining ongoing dialogue with the East End neighborhood and will return to the City Council for additional approvals. Council Member Kim Roney stated she would ask staff to look into a comment regarding the reduction of South Charlotte Street from five lanes to three lanes. Mayor Manheimer stated she would attend the oral argument for the Vance Monument case in Raleigh on November 1.

Impact

These decisions impact residents through the expansion of the Swannanoa River Greenway and New Haw Creek Road sidewalks, which will improve pedestrian and bicycle safety in areas that previously lacked such facilities. The approval of Project Aspire will result in significant infill development in the Central Business District, adding housing and commercial space while requiring a minimum of 20% of residential units to be affordable. The adoption of the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan provides a framework for transforming the city’s central square into a more inclusive public space, subject to the pending legal ruling on the Vance Monument.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches