City Council Meeting
August 22, 2023 at 12:00 PM
- 5 h 1 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: August 22, 2023
The City of Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on August 22, 2023, which included a work session on the Independent Review Committee (IRC) water outage report and a formal session for public hearings and new business. The meeting addressed a wide range of topics, including infrastructure updates, housing developments, public safety ordinances, and emergency preparedness.
Key Decisions and Votes The Council approved the consent agenda, which included authorizing a contract with McAdams for the Downtown Patton Avenue Corridor and Feasibility Study, along with a $44,000 budget amendment. The Council also authorized a contract with B.H. Graning Landscapes LLC for the Bent Tree and Crestwood Roads Slide Repairs Project and approved the standardization purchase of Labrie OEM parts for Sanitation vehicles. A Bond Resolution was adopted for General Obligation Public Improvement Bonds Series 2023B (up to $9,925,000) and Taxable General Obligation Housing Bonds Series 2023C (up to $16,895,000), completing the debt issuance for the November 2016 Bond Referendum within the statutory deadline.
In the public hearings, the Council voted 7-0 to pass the conditional zoning for 1 Oak Street, though the hearing was continued to September 12, 2023, at the applicant’s request. The Council voted 7-0 to pass the conditional zoning amendment for the Haywood Street property and 7-0 to approve the revised affordability levels for the associated Housing Trust Fund loan. The Council unanimously passed resolutions to discontinue the Strategic Event Partnership Program, authorize a three-year agreement with the Asheville Area Arts Council, and authorize an Agricultural Development Agreement with the Appalachian Sustainable Agriculture Project.
Regarding public safety and grants, the Council passed resolutions 7-0 to authorize applications for the 2024 BikeSafe Grant and the 2024 High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas (HIDTA) Grant. However, the resolution to authorize the 2023 HIDTA Grant and its associated budget amendment passed 6-1, with Council Member Kim Roney voting no. The Council also passed 7-0 resolutions to authorize a statewide mutual aid agreement with the N.C. Division of Emergency Management, amend a contract with Responder Support Services, LLC, and deny General Electric Company’s requested tangible personal property tax refund.
Two ordinances were adopted during the meeting. An ordinance amending sections 11-5 and 11-14 of the Code of Ordinances related to solicitation passed 6-1, with Council Member Kim Roney voting no. An ordinance amending sections of the City Code regulating noise passed 7-0. Additionally, the Council appointed Kimberly Levi and Susan Bean to the Planning and Zoning Commission, deciding to leave two other seats open for a future re-advertisement.
Discussion Highlights Mayor Esther Manheimer opened the meeting by addressing recent incidents of harassment and violence against public officials, including vandalism at a Council Member’s home and the arson of police vehicles. She shared personal experiences of threats, stating, "I have not publicly shared the incidents that have happened to me... I have had people come to my house at Passover... I have had sexually violent communications to my email accounts... I still think it's worth it."
Capital Projects Director Jade Dundas reported that the city has spent over $150 million on approximately 56 projects since 2016. She noted that while the majority of projects are complete or under construction, industry challenges such as limited bidder turnout have caused delays, stating, "Patton Avenue is our challenging project... This project literally bid twice and had zero bidders. I've never experienced that before."
The College and Patton Avenue Bike Lanes project generated significant debate. Council Member Sage Turner highlighted the city’s high rate of bicycle and pedestrian accidents, emphasizing the need to "unclog our arteries." Council Member Antanette Mosley shared an anecdote about a Black cyclist who felt downtown was "not for us," highlighting the disconnect between project intent and lived experience. City Manager DK Wesley responded, "We're looking at downtown holistically the same way we're looking at the entire community holistically... We don't single out a street because of the racial demographics and say, 'We're not going to do a complete street in that neighborhood.'" The Council declined to approve the bid release for this project, agreeing instead to schedule a work session for further discussion.
Regarding the solicitation ordinance amendments, City Attorney Brad Branham clarified that the changes are technical and necessary for legal compliance, stating, "We believe that these technical amendments are not just prudent, but we believe that they're necessary... These changes... do not expand the existing regulations... They do not add new or increase any of the penalties." Council Member Kim Roney expressed concern that the eight-foot rule is an expansion rather than a technical change, while Mayor Manheimer countered that defining "close proximity" narrows ambiguity.
Community Input Public commenters expressed divided views on the solicitation ordinance amendments. Some argued for stricter enforcement to protect public safety and businesses from aggressive panhandling and violence. Others, including a civil rights attorney and a reverend, argued that the amendments criminalize poverty, violate First Amendment rights, and distract from addressing root causes such as housing and addiction. In response to the bike lane proposal, a resident/business owner argued that removing parking spaces would hurt local businesses and increase traffic congestion, while a property owner expressed dismay at the lack of response to previous emails and cited emergency response times.
Other public comments included a Vietnam veteran expressing frustration over inconsistent parking enforcement on Annandale Avenue and a retired physician asking the Council to pass a resolution supporting single-payer healthcare. A commenter presented a petition regarding ADA violations at the Civic Center parking garage, and another requested that the city allow harassment charges to be filed against individuals who threaten passengers on city buses.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to provide a demographic breakdown of accident data and further analysis of survey results for the College and Patton Avenue Bike Lanes project within a day or two, with the Council agreeing to schedule a work session to continue the discussion. Staff indicated that a facilities study is nearing completion and results will be presented to the Council in the fall. The City Attorney’s office will continue to review data and legal aspects to propose substantive amendments to the solicitation ordinances, planned for presentation to a Council Committee on September 26, with a potential first full Council reading on October 10. Staff also agreed to communicate the appointment process to Planning and Zoning Commission applicants, with a target for new appointments in October.
Impact These decisions impact residents through continued infrastructure development, the completion of the 2016 bond projects, and the expansion of affordable housing through the Haywood Street and Vanderbilt Apartments projects. The adoption of the noise and solicitation ordinances aims to ensure legal compliance and clarify enforcement standards in public spaces. The approval of the mutual aid agreement and the update to the Emergency Operations Plan enhance the city’s preparedness for natural and human-caused emergencies. The shift in event support from the Strategic Event Partnership Program to a grant model administered by the Asheville Area Arts Council changes how local arts and cultural events receive city funding.
Meeting Video & Transcript