Skip to main content
  • 1 h 57 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: July 25, 2023

The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on July 25, 2023, to address a wide range of municipal operations, infrastructure projects, and land use decisions. The agenda included the approval of routine contracts, public hearings on zoning and neighborhood plans, and a significant vote on a land use incentive grant for a new micro-apartment development. The Council also received updates on the I-26 Connector Project and recognized city employees for their service.

Key Decisions and Votes

The Council adopted the combined minutes from the June 22, 2023, worksession and the June 27, 2023, formal meeting. Most routine items on the Consent Agenda were approved unanimously, including contracts for custodial services, road resurfacing, landscaping, water treatment sludge removal, and various engineering and design projects. Notable contracts included a $3.7 million agreement with Ewing Cole Inc. for engineering and design services for McCormick Field, and a $147,000 budget amendment to fund the City’s Affordable Housing Plan consultant.

One item was removed from the Consent Agenda for individual discussion: an ordinance amending Section 12-53 of the Code of Ordinances. This amendment prohibits the storage of bicycles, carts, strollers, or other personal transportation on City property for longer than 168 hours (7 days). Council voted 7-0 to pass the ordinance, which establishes a civil penalty of $50 for violations rather than a criminal misdemeanor.

In public hearings, the Council voted 7-0 to approve an amendment to the conditional zoning of 509 Biltmore Avenue, allowing additional signage for Mission Hospital. The Council also voted 7-0 to approve an amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) that consolidates multiple separate tables of permitted uses into a single, unified table to improve clarity and administrative efficiency.

The most contentious decision of the evening involved the Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) application for Aston Flats LLC at 46 Aston Street. Staff recommended delaying the application until the LUIG policy is revised to address micro-apartments. A motion to delay the application failed, and the Council subsequently voted 5-2 to approve the grant. Council Members Antanette Mosley and Sheneika Smith voted against the approval. The grant provides $1,953,152 over 21 years for a development of 231 micro-units, 47 of which will be affordable to households earning at or below 80% of the Area Median Income.

Discussion Highlights

During the Manager’s Report, Transportation Director Ken Putnam presented an update on the I-26 Connector Project, specifically regarding Sections B and D. He noted that the design-build selection process is ongoing, with the contract award date moved to February 2024. Putnam highlighted that the Burton Street neighborhood is the only area in Asheville designated by the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) as an environmental justice population for this project. He stated, "The Burton Street community is the only neighborhood in Asheville to have received an environmental justice population designation from NCDOT for the project."

Regarding the Aston Flats project, Mayor Esther Manheimer expressed support for the development, stating, "I am supportive of moving this forward... I think this is a really interesting model for living where you are interacting with people and you are living in a shared space with some privacy." Council Member Sage Turner also supported the project, noting, "I can't imagine that that parcel will come about in a different way that can get us towards this goal... I think that's a really good time for public money to be at the table to test and say, 'All right, are we about to unlock something that could be useful?'"

In the discussion of the personal property storage ordinance, Council Member Kim Roney emphasized the importance of the penalty structure, stating, "My top priority right now is that if someone is retrieving their personal transportation equipment, like a bike parked in a bike rack, that they may not be subject to a criminal misdemeanor when they retrieve it."

Community Input

Public comment was received on several topics. Regarding the reparations audit, a public commenter expressed concern that the resolution included language regarding "gender-based disparities," arguing that reparations and gender equality are separate issues. A member of the reparations committee also spoke, stating that combining the two issues is "disturbing." In response, a council member explained that the language was likely included because the reparations committee leadership emphasized harms specific to Black women, and staff confirmed the intent was to be specific to Black females, which would be clarified in the scope of work.

For the Aston Flats project, the developer spoke in favor of an immediate vote, arguing that the project addresses affordable housing and climate change by allowing 231 people to live downtown. A resident and chair of the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) expressed frustration with the idea of a delay, stating that changing rules mid-process is "maddening" and urging the Council to vote on the project. Another resident stated she would not support a delay, noting that the city has invested in studies showing the need for one-bedroom units.

During general public comment, a speaker discussed the history of white supremacy in Asheville, referencing early 20th-century parades and the disenfranchisement of Black voters. Another commenter spoke about public safety, specifically expressing frustration with "ghost guns" and low bail amounts, stating, "Until our young people see they are being served and protected, the only option they see is to serve and protect themselves." A representative from the newly chartered not-for-profit Sustain AVL introduced the organization, which aims to diversify the local economy through climate-resilient development, stating, "We will not be successful unless the benefits of economic development have something for everyone." No specific member replies to the general public comment speakers were recorded.

Follow-ups

Transportation Director Ken Putnam agreed to furnish the Council with the reason why the Burton Street neighborhood does not meet the criteria for the federal Justice 40 disadvantaged community designation. Staff also agreed to look for and resend a letter dated February 15, 2023, regarding Aesthetics Committee recommendations to the DOT. Regarding the Aston Flats project, staff indicated that the LUIG policy review is part of the Affordable Housing Plan update, with a minimum timeline of five to six months. The Council requested that the group reviewing the policy come up with examples of how to fairly adjust incentives for smaller unit sizes and shared amenities. Additionally, staff noted that the Sports Commission task force will continue to meet to explore organizational changes, a process that is ongoing and will take additional months.

Impact

These decisions impact residents through improved infrastructure, clearer zoning regulations, and new housing options. The approval of the Aston Flats grant will result in the construction of 231 micro-units, adding to the city's housing stock, including 47 affordable units. The consolidation of the UDO use tables aims to make the zoning process more transparent and efficient for property owners and developers. The I-26 Connector updates provide residents in the Burton Street, Hillcrest, and Montford neighborhoods with details on upcoming mitigation strategies, including sidewalk improvements, a history mural, and traffic calming measures. The new ordinance regarding personal transportation storage aims to ensure that public bicycle racks remain accessible by preventing long-term abandonment of bikes and carts on City property.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches