Skip to main content

City Council Meeting

June 13, 2023 at 12:00 PM

  • 3 h 32 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: June 13, 2023

The Asheville City Council held a formal meeting on June 13, 2023, to address the city’s Fiscal Year 2023-24 budget, review the findings of the Independent Review Committee (IRC) regarding the December 2022 water outage, and conduct public hearings on development regulations. The council also processed a consent agenda containing routine contracts and resolutions, and made appointments to various city boards and commissions.

Key Decisions and Votes The council adopted the Fiscal Year 2023-24 Annual Operating Budget, which totals approximately $240 million, by a vote of 6-0. Councilmember Sage Turner recused herself from the vote due to a conflict of interest regarding an appropriation to the Nashville Downtown Association. The budget includes a 5% salary increase for existing employees, a 6% increase for sworn police officers, and no change to the property tax rate. Two subsequent budget amendments were also adopted: a $100,000 contribution to the Economic Development Coalition passed 5-0 (with Mayor Esther Manheimer and Councilmember Turner recused), and a $45,000 contribution to the Sports Commission passed 6-0 (with Councilmember Turner recused).

The council unanimously adopted a technical budget amendment of $25,286,496 in the General Fund to account for the February 2023 refunding of the 2020 General Obligation Bond Anticipation Note. Additionally, the council passed a technical correction to the ordinance setting the rental fee for each additional 95-gallon trash cart at $17.00 per month.

On the consent agenda, the council unanimously approved several resolutions, including:

  • Acceptance of the Flood Mitigation Actions Report to maintain the city’s Class 8 status in the Community Rating System, which provides a 10% reduction in flood insurance premiums for residents.
  • Authorization of a three-year contract with Waste Management of Carolinas for bulk waste collection, with a five-year total cost not to exceed $560,000.
  • Authorization of an interlocal agreement with Buncombe County to grant the city exclusive zoning jurisdiction over the parcel at 1310 Fanning Bridge Road.
  • Authorization of a three-year contract with ESRI, Inc. for GIS software maintenance, totaling $187,125.
  • Authorization of an amendment to the agreement with Azteca Systems LLC for hosting the enterprise asset management system.
  • Authorization of an agreement with the Town of Black Mountain to provide $25,000 in funding support for Transit Route 170 for both Fiscal Year 2023 and 2024.
  • Authorization of the ratification and amendment of existing transit subrecipient agreements for Federal Transit Administration Section 5310 funds.
  • Authorization of a contract with Witt O’Brien’s LLC for administrative and training support for Federal Transit Administration grants, not to exceed $124,982.
  • A resolution reaffirming support for Asheville’s LGBTQIA+ community.

The council also held a public hearing on an amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) to revise neighborhood meeting requirements for Level 2 projects, major subdivisions, and conditional zonings. The amendment, which passed unanimously, increases the notification radius from 200 to 400 feet (outside the Central Business District), extends the notification period from 10 to 14 days, and requires developers to register meetings with the city using standard templates. The public hearing for the South Slope: A Southside Neighborhood Vision Plan was continued to July 25, 2023.

Discussion Highlights A major portion of the meeting was dedicated to the IRC’s after-action report on the December 2022 water outage. The committee presented findings in three areas: water system operations, communications, and emergency response. Regarding operations, the IRC concluded that the magnitude and duration of the outage were "largely avoidable and preventable" due to the city’s inability to supply enough water to meet demand. Key factors included a closed 24-inch valve in the River Arts District, a south control valve opened only to 10% to prevent downstream tank overflow, and the East Asheville Booster Pump Station being offline. Ted Tyree, the IRC Water Operations Chair, noted that the closed valve was a "significant restriction" and that the pump station had been unavailable for use since approximately 2010.

On communications, the IRC identified failures in crisis management, including a lack of early media engagement. Mike McGill, the IRC Communications Chair, stated that the mayor put "direct pressure" on staff to release unverified restoration timeframes, leading to a public message of a "24 to 48 hour" restoration goal that was later missed. McGill clarified that the City Manager acted appropriately by not serving as the primary spokesperson. Dennis Fagnance, the IRC Emergency Response Chair, reported that the Incident Command System (ICS) was not fully implemented and that there was a "complete lack of training" among staff and elected officials.

The council also discussed appointments to various boards and commissions. The council approved appointments and reappointments for the African American Heritage Commission, Airport Authority, Civic Center Commission, Historic Resources Commission, Human Relations Commission, Multimodal Transportation Commission, Neighborhood Advisory Committee, Public Arts and Cultural Commission, and the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority. For the Planning and Zoning Commission, the council voted to continue advertising through the July cycle, interview all applicants at the August 22nd Boards and Commission Meeting, and consider appointments at the August 22nd Council Meeting.

Community Input During public comment on the LGBTQIA+ resolution, one commenter expressed gratitude for the affirmation of queer and trans existence but argued the resolution was insufficient regarding the dangers faced by trans youth, recommending a committee to establish inclusive spaces in schools. A second commenter offered congratulations to a local trans cyclist, made sarcastic remarks regarding sports inclusion and gender-affirming care, and requested the inclusion of tampons in men’s restrooms in the next budget. Members did not respond to these comments.

Regarding the water outage report, a former Water Resources Director and resident provided technical clarification, citing a Hazen & Sawyer report indicating that if the East Asheville booster pump station had been operational and the 24-inch valve open, a total system outage would not have occurred. They urged the council to ensure the pump station is brought back online. A retired professional engineer expressed anger, stating the outage was caused solely by the Water Department’s failure to perform basic maintenance. Council members acknowledged the information, and one member noted the City Manager’s office had offered to meet with staff from other affected communities to discuss communications and emergency response.

For the UDO amendment, a resident of Pinecroft Road described a recent pre-development meeting as "perfunctory" and poorly managed online due to software issues. A student shared a similar experience on Beaver Dam Road, noting that only 15 of 124 registered attendees could speak due to muting issues, and that elderly residents without internet access were excluded. A resident/business owner shared an anecdote from 2018 where notifying only property owners resulted in low attendance, whereas notifying residents significantly increased participation. A member of the Charlotte Street Neighborhood Association Board supported the changes, emphasizing that residents, not just owners, are most impacted by development. The Vice President for Government Relations for the Coalition of Asheville Neighborhoods urged approval, highlighting that the amendments represent three years of collaboration. Council members expressed strong support; one member suggested follow-up meetings for substantial project changes, and staff noted the ordinance already requires this, though "substantial" is not defined by a fixed percentage. Another member asked about sending city staff to virtual meetings; staff noted resource constraints and the desire to keep dialogue direct between developers and neighbors.

During budget public comment, a councilmember expressed support for the budget, highlighting funding for transit studies, urban forestry, reparations, and community responder programs. They raised concerns about the lack of full living wage compliance and the need for more funding for climate crisis response and youth programming, asking the City Manager to look into amendments later in the year. The Mayor suggested directing the City Manager to investigate these areas for potential budget amendments.

In general public comment, one commenter thanked the council for the Memorial Day service, advocated for peace, and requested assistance in authenticating their grandmother’s will and identifying their father’s military records.

Follow-ups The Mayor confirmed the council’s intent to implement the IRC recommendations. The Water Resources Director agreed to provide a response regarding the historical reasons for the East Asheville Booster Pump Station being taken offline and the current status of the recommendation to study its refurbishment. The Assistant City Manager acknowledged feedback regarding the City Manager’s role in crisis communications. The City Manager was directed to look into potential budget amendments later in the year regarding living wage compliance, climate crisis response, and youth programming.

Impact The adoption of the Fiscal Year 2023-24 budget ensures the city can continue funding core services while maintaining the property tax rate. The UDO amendments aim to improve consistency and transparency in development by ensuring broader and earlier notification to neighbors. The IRC findings highlight significant gaps in the city’s water infrastructure and emergency response protocols, with the council’s commitment to implement recommendations intended to prevent future outages. The flood mitigation resolution maintains the city’s eligibility for a 10% discount on flood insurance premiums for residents.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches