Skip to main content

City Council Meeting

May 9, 2023 at 12:00 PM

  • 3 h 34 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: May 9, 2023

The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on May 9, 2023, addressing a wide range of infrastructure projects, budgetary matters, and community development plans. The session included the approval of routine consent agenda items, detailed presentations on the proposed Fiscal Year 2024 operating budget and the structure of the regional sports commission, and public hearings on federal grant submissions and zoning code amendments.

Key Decisions

The Council voted to adopt the consent agenda, which included several major contracts and agreements. Unanimous votes (7-0) were recorded for the following actions:

  • Engineering Services: Authorization for a $1,510,550 contract with Hazen and Sawyer for the South Buncombe Pump Station and Concord Water Service Area Improvements Project.
  • Food Scraps Program: An Interlocal Agreement with Buncombe County for the co-management of the City of Asheville Food Scraps Drop-Off Program.
  • Homeland Security Grants: Authorization to receive $20,000 in grant funds from the State of North Carolina Homeland Security Grant Program, along with a corresponding $20,000 budget amendment, to replace an antenna on a field communications vehicle.
  • Software Contract: Renewal of a five-year contract with RecTrac LLC (d/b/a Vermont Systems) for Parks and Recreation software, with a first-year cost of $33,683 and a total five-year cost of $170,939.43.
  • Construction: A $4,095,500 contract with Patton Construction Group of Asheville for the Memorial Stadium and Mountainside Park Phase 2 Improvements Project.
  • Design: A $127,418 design contract with ADC Engineering Inc. for the Nature Center Gateway Project.
  • Flood Mitigation: A professional services contract not to exceed $150,000 with Kimley Horn for the Swannanoa River Road Flood Mitigation and Damage Reduction Feasibility Study.
  • Greenway Study: A $50,000 contract with McAdams for the Reed Creek Greenway Extension Feasibility Study.
  • Traffic Signals: A review and inspection agreement with the N.C. Dept. of Transportation for revisions to the traffic signal at the intersection of NC 81 (Swannanoa River Road) and Bleachery Boulevard.
  • Legal Settlement: Confirmation of a $75,000 settlement agreement in the case Matthew Rous v. City of Asheville and Brett L. Foust.

Following public hearings, the Council also voted on two specific resolutions:

  • 2023-2024 Annual Action Plan: The Council passed a resolution (7-0) authorizing the submission of the plan for Community Development Block Grants (CDBG) and the HOME Investment Partnerships Program to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
  • Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Amendment: The Council passed a resolution (6-1) to amend Section 7-11-4 of the UDO to update open space standards. Councilwoman Kim Roney voted against the amendment.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the presentation of the proposed Fiscal Year 2024 Annual Operating Budget, which totals $239.7 million. Staff noted that while revenue growth continues, identified needs exceed available funding capacity, requiring an unconventional use of $7.9 million in fund balance to balance the budget without a property tax increase. Council members and staff engaged in a detailed discussion regarding public safety compensation and the City’s "Just Economics" living wage pledge. One Council member expressed concern that relying on overtime to fill positions leads to staff burnout and requested a long-term projection of the cost to close the gap to the living wage rate. The Assistant City Manager acknowledged the desire to fund employees more but noted that additional pay increases would require cuts or tax increases, emphasizing the balancing act between employee needs and resident tax burdens.

The Council also heard a presentation on a consultant study regarding the Asheville-Buncombe Regional Sports Commission (ABRSC). The study recommended that ABRSC staff be absorbed into the Tourism Development Authority (TDA/Explore Asheville), while the nonprofit entity remains. Council members raised concerns about the loss of control over event risk and the potential impact on volunteer recruitment. The presenter clarified that the nonprofit status remains and that there is no scheduled vote by the founding members at this time.

Community Input

During the public comment period, residents addressed several topics:

  • Memorial Stadium: A public commenter expressed concern regarding the $875,000 annual cost for Memorial Stadium over 20 years, asking the Council to ensure funds are not diverted from local needs like sidewalks. A Council member noted they had been told sidewalks were excluded from the project but did not see that exclusion in the documents. The Capital Projects Director clarified that the project includes pedestrian accessibility improvements around the stadium and park but does not include off-site sidewalks.
  • Merriman Avenue Road Diet: A public commenter representing small business owners and residents submitted petitions opposing the traffic reconfiguration, citing increased congestion and safety concerns. They requested the City publish specific data on traffic counts, accidents, and speeds. A Council member asked the commenter to email or submit their specific measurement requests.
  • Sports Commission: Multiple public commenters urged the Council to maintain the Sports Commission as an independent entity rather than merging it into the TDA, citing the potential loss of grassroots community engagement. One commenter requested that the Council "put the brakes" on a potential June vote to allow for more review. Members did not respond.
  • Police Compensation: Several public commenters expressed concern that the proposed 6% salary increase for police officers was insufficient to retain staff given Asheville’s high cost of living. Members did not respond.
  • Police Accountability: A public commenter called for a directly elected all-civilian council with final authority over police policy and budget. A Council member stated, "As is my practice, if there is misinformation stated during a public comment period, I will flag it. And there was some misinformation that you stated... I think some of the references to the trials that you mentioned are not correct."
  • Affordable Housing: A public commenter expressed frustration that the City relies on federal funds for rental assistance while spending millions on other projects, questioning why the City does not use its own funds to prevent homelessness. Members did not respond.
  • Public Transit: A public commenter asked for clarity on the status of a $4.4 million Federal Transportation Administration grant for buses and batteries. Members did not respond.

Follow-ups

  • Budget Public Hearing: Staff confirmed the public hearing on the budget will take place at the meeting two weeks from today.
  • Transit Fuel Costs: Staff agreed to provide a memo detailing the impact of fuel costs on the transit budget.
  • Living Wage Projection: Staff agreed to look into providing a projection of the cost to meet the Just Economics living wage rate, including inflation.
  • Sports Commission MOU: The Council requested to see a draft of the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) and the five-year plan for the Sports Commission. The presenter confirmed that listening sessions are scheduled for May 17 and 18 to gather community input.
  • Merriman Avenue Data: A Council member asked the public commenter to submit their specific data requests via email.

Impact

These decisions impact residents through the allocation of funds for critical infrastructure, public safety, and community services. The approval of the Memorial Stadium and Mountainside Park Phase 2 Improvements will result in a new synthetic track, updated restrooms, and playground improvements, with construction anticipated to begin in summer 2023. The update to the Unified Development Ordinance’s open space standards aims to reduce administrative barriers for infill development and adaptive reuse, supporting the City’s goals for housing supply and neighborhood identity. The submission of the 2023-2024 Annual Action Plan to HUD will direct federal funds toward affordable housing, domestic violence services, and economic development projects across the region. Finally, the detailed discussion on the FY 2024 budget and the Sports Commission’s future structure highlights ongoing debates regarding the balance between public safety staffing, cost of living, and the organization of regional tourism and sports entities.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches