Skip to main content
  • 4 h 55 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: April 25, 2023

The Asheville City Council held its regular meeting on April 25, 2023, focusing on significant updates to water rates, the allocation of housing funds, and several zoning decisions for affordable housing and commercial development. The council also reviewed the aftermath of the December 2022 water outage and the strategic priorities developed during the March council retreat.

Key Decisions and Votes The council adopted the consent agenda unanimously, which included authorizing a multi-year agreement with the Mills River Partnership for water quality projects, applying for a $2 million lead service line replacement grant, and executing a $2.43 million construction contract with NHM Constructors, LLC for the New Leicester Highway Sidewalk Project. The council also unanimously approved a resolution conveying city-owned property at Hunt Hill Place to the non-profit KL Training Solutions for $1 to house youth development programs.

In zoning matters, the council passed a conditional zoning request for 16 Restaurant Court (7-0) to allow a 100% affordable multifamily development. They approved a rezoning request for 35 Long Shoals Road from residential to highway business (6-1, with Council Member Kim Roney voting no). Additionally, the council unanimously approved an amendment to the conditional zoning for Fairhaven Summit Apartments (7-0) and an amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance to allow “cat cafes” in more commercial districts (7-0).

Regarding water rates, the council passed an ordinance establishing Fiscal Year 2023-24 fees for the Water Resources Department by a vote of 5-2, with Council Members Kim Roney and Sage Turner voting no. The council also unanimously passed a motion directing the City Manager to bring a proposal back to the council upon the completion of a water rate study to consider updating the rate structure for a January 1, 2024 adoption.

The council unanimously approved a resolution allocating Housing Trust Funds to four affordable housing projects, totaling $4,383,000 to assist in the construction of approximately 239 units. The projects include Redwood Commons, Reimagining Deaverview, Fairhaven Summit, and Stewart Street Cottages. The council also unanimously approved a resolution for the Strategic Partnership Grant Program, awarding $356,209 to six agencies supporting low-to-moderate income youth.

Discussion Highlights A major portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Water Resources Department fee increase, which results in an average annual increase of $42.78 for residential customers. Council members debated the current rate structure, with one member stating, “I’m fundamentally opposed to continuing the bulk discount at this level, which is why I can’t support it.” Another member expressed concern about a $500,000 contingency fund, noting, “I’m just a little concerned because I’m... residential costs, right? And if there’s all this influx... I would support looking at that.”

Staff presented the After-Action Report regarding the December 2022 water outage. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody apologized for releasing the report to the media via public records request before providing it to the Council, stating, “In this instance, those protocols were not followed. So I just want to apologize to the members of the council for that oversight.”

On strategic priorities, staff presented a consolidation of 70 draft goals from the March retreat into 30 proposed goals for the FY24 budget. Council Member Sage Turner expressed concern about the process, stating, “I'm worried about the consensus about up here on the policymaking piece of it... I don't want staff to be distilling it down and us saying, eh, that's not how we would [prioritize it].”

Community Input During public comment, a resident presented a detailed analysis of the water rate structure, arguing the system is “broken” and inequitable, noting that residents use 54% of the water but contribute 60-69% of the revenue. Another resident expressed frustration that the council voted to increase water rates before the Independent Rate Council report was back, calling it a “waste of money.”

Regarding the Strategic Partnership Grant Program, a representative for the non-profit “My Daddy Taught Me That” expressed disappointment that no funding was provided for the restoration of a building gifted to them, while another representative called the building gift a “beacon” for the community. A representative from the YWCA asked the council to review the distribution of grant funds to ensure they reach other qualified youth-serving nonprofits.

Other public comments included a resident discussing the urgent need for more transit buses due to breakdowns, a resident asking for clarity on the terms of the city’s relationship with McCormick Field, and a resident requesting a referendum on the city’s election system to address historical disenfranchisement.

Follow-ups Staff and Council agreed to hold a future work session to review and finalize the 30 consolidated strategic priority goals. Staff agreed to provide information on the impact of the $500,000 contingency fund on monthly rates following the meeting. The council directed the City Manager to bring a proposal back to Council upon the completion of the water rate study (expected fall 2023). Staff indicated they would return to the Equity and Engagement Committee in early September with an updated number for the remainder of Fiscal Year 2024 regarding Strategic Partnership Funds. Finally, staff were directed to continue negotiations with the developer of Oak Hill Cottages and conduct community engagement on potential development options for that site.

Impact These decisions directly affect utility costs for residents, as the water fee increase takes effect July 1, 2023. The approval of the Housing Trust Fund allocations will move four affordable housing projects forward, adding 239 units to the city’s housing stock. The zoning changes at 16 Restaurant Court and Fairhaven Summit will allow for the construction of 100% affordable housing developments, while the rezoning at 35 Long Shoals Road opens the door for commercial development in a previously residential area. The expansion of “cat cafes” to more commercial districts aims to support small businesses in corridors like Haywood Road.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches