Skip to main content
  • 2 h 36 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: September 27, 2022

The Asheville City Council held its regular meeting on September 27, 2022, presided over by Mayor Esther Manheimer. The agenda included the approval of the consent agenda, public hearings on housing and zoning, and discussions regarding infrastructure, county bond referendums, and the city’s noise ordinance. All recorded votes on the agenda items passed with a 7-0 tally.

Key Decisions The Council unanimously adopted the consent agenda, which included the approval of minutes from the September 13, 2022 meeting. Among the consent items, the Council authorized a three-year contract with Environmental Testing Solutions for $125,000 to provide free lead testing for water customers. They also approved a budget amendment appropriating $264,000 for multimodal transportation planning for the East Patton Corridor and authorized an interlocal agreement with Buncombe County to study the feasibility of installing solar on North Fork Reservoir and Lake Julian. Additionally, the Council approved resolutions for alcohol permits for the Asheville Veganfest (moved to October 16 due to Hurricane Ian) and the Surreal Sirkus Arts Festival, as well as a contract with Appalachian Paving and Concrete Inc. for the Fiscal Year 2023 Utility Cut Concrete Repair Project.

In new business and public hearings, the Council approved the Water Resource Department’s 10-Year Capital Improvement schedule. They also granted a $1.5 million Housing Trust Fund loan to Volunteers of America for the construction of 54 new apartment units and the rehabilitation of 50 existing affordable units for seniors at 650 Caribou Road. Concurrently, the Council approved the conditional zoning of 650 Caribou Road from the RM-8 Residential Multi-Family Medium Density District to the Residential Expansion/Conditional Zone. The Council also approved an interlocal agreement with the Asheville City Board of Education for the maintenance of donated playground equipment at Jones Park, which included a motion to rename the park in memory of Candace Pickens. Finally, the Council approved in principle the issuance by the Housing Authority of the City of Asheville of up to $20,000,000 in multifamily housing revenue bonds for the acquisition and rehabilitation of Battery Park Apartments.

Discussion Highlights A representative from the Buncombe County Commission presented information on two upcoming November bond referendums: a $30 million conservation bond and a $40 million affordable housing bond. During the discussion, a council member noted that 4,000 units in the county are used for short-term rentals, which competes with the goal of creating 2,750 affordable units. The County Commissioner responded that the feasibility study did not address short-term rentals but acknowledged the issue affects the housing market.

Staff provided an annual update on the noise ordinance, noting a shift in enforcement from the Asheville Police Department to the Development Services Department. Staff reported that venues have been cooperative in adjusting to decibel requirements. Regarding the Jones Park playground, Mayor Esther Manheimer highlighted the logistical challenge of the interlocal agreement, noting it was a "peculiar" situation involving property owned by the school system, maintained by the city, and constructed by the county. She stated that the process "paved the way for future partnerships." Council Member Antanette Mosley shared a story about Candace Pickens, who was killed in Jones Park in 2016, and expressed frustration at previous pushback against renaming the park, stating, "I’m offended... People came to me and said, 'What was she doing there? It wasn't her park. We don't want to rename it after her because it will lower our property values.'"

Regarding the Housing Authority bonds for Battery Park, City Attorney Brad Branham clarified that the vote was "more of a procedural vote than a substantive one" and that "the city takes on absolutely no financial responsibility for that." Housing Authority Executive Director David Nash added, "The Housing Authority is not acquiring Battery Park Apartments... neither the city nor the Housing Authority is liable for those bonds."

Community Input During the public hearing for the 650 Caribou Road project, a public commenter from the Shiloh neighborhood expressed concern that the project might open the door to more multi-family development in their single-family neighborhood and requested that the 2025 plan maintain the area’s single-family designation. Another public commenter, the liaison for the Shiloh Community Association, raised concerns about traffic on narrow streets and infrastructure capacity. In response, the Chair clarified that "multi-family" refers to apartment buildings, not multiple families per unit, and the developer confirmed the project is deed-restricted for seniors (55+) in perpetuity.

Regarding the Jones Park playground, a public commenter from North Asheville expressed concern that the current playground at Weaver Park is insufficient for infants and toddlers. Another public commenter from Graceland Road urged the council to "accept the gift" of the $250,000 raised by the community to rebuild the park. A public commenter expressed opposition to the use of city funds for a playground on school property, calling it a "special privilege," but stated they would support the project if intended to honor the Pickens family. The mother of Candace Pickens and grandmother of Zacchaeus Waters spoke in support of renaming the park, stating that keeping the park in their memory would be an honor.

During informal public comment, a representative for Citizens for Responsible Land Use (CRLU) presented concerns about the "Robin Hood Residential" development in Woodfin, noting that the proposed density and impervious area exceed current standards by 250-500%. The Mayor stated that she had sent the presentation to the city administration. Several residents spoke in favor of expanding pickleball courts, with one sharing a personal story about her autistic children finding community in the sport. Another resident requested the conversion of three tennis courts at Murphy Oakley Park to eight dedicated pickleball courts. The Mayor acknowledged the enthusiasm of the pickleball community but reminded them that clapping is not allowed in the chamber. A public commenter also discussed election integrity concerns regarding district judges and voter registration data in Buncombe County.

Follow-ups Staff stated they will continue to assess the effectiveness of the noise ordinance, continue education and outreach, and work with the Noise Advisory Board to develop recommended changes to current standards to bring back to the council in the future. The Water Director stated that the city will apply for another $15 million in NC DEQ funding this fall for the Mills River Phase II project. The County Commissioner stated that a community oversight committee will be appointed if the bonds pass, and a webpage will be created to track spending in real-time.

Impact These decisions impact residents through the expansion of affordable senior housing in the Shiloh neighborhood, the preservation of historic affordable housing in downtown Asheville via the Battery Park bonds, and the restoration of a neighborhood park in memory of a local tragedy. The approval of the 10-year capital improvement plan for water resources aims to improve competitiveness for state grants, potentially reducing the burden on ratepayers. The consent agenda items address public health through lead testing, transportation planning for the East Patton Corridor, and the correction of body camera licensing fees.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches