City Council Meeting
August 23, 2022 at 12:00 PM
- 3 h 1 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: August 23, 2022
The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on August 23, 2022. The agenda included the adoption of a consent agenda, the review of three public hearings, new business items regarding affordable housing and board appointments, and a series of resolutions for contracts, budget amendments, and facility updates.
Key Decisions and Votes
The Council adopted the consent agenda unanimously, with the exception of Item I, which was removed for individual discussion. The consent items included authorizing a contract with TP Howard’s Plumbing Company Inc. for the Carter-Ann Stormwater Improvement Project, a sidewalk maintenance agreement with the N.C. Dept. of Transportation (NCDOT) for Tunnel Road, a change order for three Gillig diesel buses, an amendment to the IPS Group Inc. parking meter contract, a contract with Green Built Alliance for the Blue Horizons Project, the sale of a surplus 2011 Autocar Xpeditor Garbage Truck, a $150,000 budget amendment for North Fork Water Treatment Plant repairs, a one-year contract extension with Daikin Applied Americas Inc. for chiller maintenance, a licensing agreement with Commonwealth Golf Partners II - Asheville, LLC. for the Asheville Municipal Golf Course, a five-year renewal of the CAYLA scholarship fund contract with the Asheville City Schools Foundation, and a schedule amendment to reschedule the November 8, 2022, meeting to November 15, 2022.
The Council voted 5-2 to adopt a budget amendment of $419,214.47 to establish a budget for the Asheville Police Department’s State and Federal Forfeiture funds. Vice Mayor Sheneika Smith and Council Member Kim Roney voted no. The funds are intended for a new DNA Analyzer system, a replacement bomb robot, and advanced forensic training.
Regarding public hearings, the Council voted unanimously to continue three items to future dates: the rezoning of 645 Brevard Road and 651 Brevard Road were continued until September 13, 2022, and the adoption of the South Slope: A Southside Neighborhood Vision Plan was continued until October 11, 2022.
In new business, the Council voted unanimously to approve a Purchase and Sales Agreement with Laurel Street Residential LLC for the development of mixed-income and affordable housing at 319 Biltmore Road. Additionally, the Council voted unanimously to grant an $850,000 Housing Trust Fund loan to Mountain Housing Opportunities for the purchase of property at 16 Restaurant Court.
The Council also voted on 19 appointments to various boards and commissions. Most appointments passed unanimously, including reappointments to the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, Buncombe County Tourist Development Authority, Design Review Committee, Historic Resources Commission, Noise Advisory Board, and Board of Adjustment. The appointment of Rick Freeman to the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee (HIAC) passed with one member voting no. For the Human Relations Commission, the Council recommended re-advertising the seat rather than making an appointment.
Discussion Highlights
Discussion on the Police Forfeiture Funds (Item I) focused on the use of the $419,214.47 in funds. Mayor Esther Manheimer clarified that federal law prevents the Council from directing how these funds are spent; they must receive a recommendation from the department. Vice Mayor Sheneika Smith initially moved to delay the item for more information but withdrew the motion after hearing that the Public Safety Committee had already held an exhaustive discussion. Council Member Antanette Mosley raised concerns about the principle of asset forfeiture, citing the ACLU’s warnings against "policing for profit" and the historical context of the War on Drugs.
The Manager’s Report included an update on the Comprehensive Facilities Study. Council Member Sage Turner asked about the inclusion of an equity lens in the study, noting that while growth and maintenance are covered, equity is a key priority for the council. Council Member Kim Roney questioned the process of hiring consultants for the study, asking why the city cannot manage its own maintenance list. Staff responded that the scale of the city's facilities and the need for objective, long-term planning expertise necessitate outside help. Council Member Sandra Kilgore asked about potential collaboration with the Preservation Society if costs become prohibitive.
Regarding the 319 Biltmore Road project, Council Member Antanette Mosley highlighted that this is the first time the City of Asheville has partnered with a majority Black development firm. Mayor Esther Manheimer asked about the flexibility in the project if the developer wanted to pivot to tax credit financing or add childcare. Staff and the developer explained that the current model is designed to keep the city’s subsidy limited to the land, and adding complex elements would likely require additional city subsidy or a restart of the process.
For the 16 Restaurant Court project, Jeffrey Barton of Mountain Housing Opportunities stated that the project includes 20% of units set aside for young adults aging out of foster care. He noted that in recognition of the city's early funding commitment, the organization offered an extended 40-year affordability period.
On the Biltmore Avenue Bike Lane, the City Manager stated, "Please hear me clearly multimodal transportation options is a key city policy complete streets for all users... We're not giving up on a bike lane... the city will come back and make this project a part of their capital improvement program and will reserve the funding in order to add bike lanes not only to this street in downtown, but a number of other streets."
Community Input
Public commenters expressed strong support for the plastic bag and styrofoam ban, which was delayed from the current agenda. One commenter representing the Southern Environmental Law Center urged the Council to be "first movers" on the issue. Another commenter from a church’s Earth Care Committee cited statistics on plastic production emissions. A third commenter shared a personal story of using canvas bags to eliminate plastic bag use. A representative from Plastic Free WNC presented findings from a survey of organizations serving unhoused populations, requesting that free, waterproof, foldable reusable bags be provided to those individuals, as a 10-cent fee is a significant cost for them. A representative from the French Broad River Keeper highlighted the health and environmental impacts of microplastics. No specific Council member responded directly to these comments in the transcript segment.
Regarding the 319 Biltmore Road project, public commenters expressed support for the project’s walkability, the developer’s background, and the significance of partnering with a Black-owned business. One commenter, identifying as a dual citizen of the Cherokee Nation and the US, requested that the city continue to engage small businesses on smaller projects. No specific Council member responded directly to these comments.
A public commenter speaking as a member of the Boards and Commissions Realignment Working Group reported that the group is developing a survey to understand recruitment and retention challenges and asked the Council to allow the working group to continue its process into the fall. No specific Council member responded directly to this comment.
A public commenter expressed concern about the boundaries of the "South Slope" area defined in a visioning document, noting it includes areas from neighboring neighborhoods. No specific Council member responded directly to this comment.
A public commenter representing citizens advocating for dedicated pickleball courts proposed a series program at city rec centers to bring youth into the sport. No specific Council member responded directly to this comment.
A public commenter raised concerns about the lack of grocery stores in the River Arts District (RAD) area despite new apartment developments. A staff member responded, noting that the RAD Lofts project includes a grocery store tenant.
Follow-ups
Staff stated that results from the growth and maintenance lens of the Comprehensive Facilities Study are expected in the spring of 2023, with the final presentation scheduled for June 2023. Staff stated that the construction award for Memorial Stadium & Mountainside Park is targeted for March 2023, with construction beginning in May 2023. Staff stated that if the 319 Biltmore Road agreement is approved, the developer will transition into the rezoning process and return to Council for conditional rezoning approval. Staff stated that if the 16 Restaurant Court loan is approved, the developer may return at a later time for an additional $661,000 request. Staff confirmed that the plastic pollution reduction ordinance will be considered by the Governance Committee on September 13, 2022. The Boards and Commissions Realignment Working Group will continue its process into the fall, including sending out a survey. The City will conduct further analysis on the Biltmore Avenue Bike Lane and bring the project back to the Capital Improvement Program with reserved funding. Staff noted that the Housing and Community Development department is reviewing policies related to affordable housing, with potential revisions expected by the end of the calendar year.
Impact
These decisions impact residents through the allocation of public funds for public safety, infrastructure, and housing. The approval of the police forfeiture funds budget allows for the purchase of forensic equipment and training. The stormwater project and sidewalk agreement address flooding and pedestrian safety in specific neighborhoods. The approval of the two affordable housing projects (319 Biltmore Road and 16 Restaurant Court) adds new housing stock, with specific units reserved for low-income households and youth aging out of foster care. The golf course agreement establishes a new management structure for the Asheville Municipal Golf Course, including a new facility management fee for non-annual passholders to fund capital projects. The rescheduling of the November meeting ensures the Council meets on a date that avoids a holiday.
Meeting Video & Transcript