City Council Meeting
May 24, 2022 at 12:00 PM
- 5 h 10 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: May 24, 2022
The City of Asheville Council held a formal meeting on May 24, 2022, to review the proposed Fiscal Year 2022-23 budget, conduct public hearings on development projects, and vote on various administrative resolutions. The meeting included a presentation on the city’s financial outlook, public hearings for zoning changes and development fees, and discussions on transportation infrastructure and community parks.
Key Decisions and Votes
The Council voted on a series of resolutions and ordinances, most of which passed unanimously (7-0). These included authorizing debt financing for capital projects via interim Limited Obligation Bonds up to $42,000,000; renewing the public safety radio maintenance agreement with Motorola Inc.; accepting the Flood Mitigation Actions Report; and authorizing the City Manager to apply for Federal Transit Administration grants. The Council also unanimously approved a budget amendment of $470,000 for the Harrah’s Cherokee Center - Asheville, authorized a contract with Pepsi Cola Bottling Company of Hickory Inc., and approved alcohol permits for Grindfest, the Juneteenth Celebration, and the Asheville Half Marathon & 10K. Additionally, the Council unanimously adopted the Water Resources Department’s updated development fees analysis for FY 2022-23, which is expected to generate an estimated $1.7 million in additional annual revenue.
Three items passed with dissenting votes. The Council approved a land use incentive grant to Reed Creek Greenway Plaza LLC for the Reed Creek Mixed Use Development project by a vote of 6-1, with Councilwoman Gwen Wisler voting no. The Council approved the conditional zoning of multiple properties at 427 Broadway Street by a vote of 6-1, with Councilwoman Kim Roney voting no. Finally, the Council authorized the City Manager to enter into an agreement with the N.C. Dept. of Transportation for the 4-3 lane conversion of Merrimon Avenue by a vote of 6-1, with Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore voting no. The Council unanimously approved the conditional zoning for 1001 Patton Avenue and a resolution authorizing the City Manager to apply for grant funds from the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority.
Budget and Financial Discussion
Staff presented the Manager’s Proposed Budget for FY 2022-23, totaling $216.9 million, an 8% increase over the current year. The proposal includes no change to the property tax rate, a minimum salary of $35,360 for full-time employees, and a 5% raise for existing staff. Key investments include a "missing middle" housing study, homelessness strategy specialists, and an additional $365,000 to replenish the reparations fund to $2.1 million. During public comment, a resident expressed concern that the city was moving away from a $17.70/hour living wage policy. Mayor Esther Manheimer responded that she wants to see the move to $17.70 and expressed hope that strong revenue growth would allow the city to absorb the estimated $600,000 cost. Another commenter noted that "equity" was no longer explicitly named in the budget process summary; Mayor Manheimer acknowledged the diagram was difficult to follow and admitted equity may not have been captured correctly in the illustration.
Development and Zoning Hearings
The Council held public hearings on the Reed Creek Mixed Use Development at 427 Broadway Street. The developer presented a case for a $753,000 land use incentive grant, highlighting that the project includes 50% of units with housing choice vouchers and accepts one person from the homeless by-name list. Staff recommended approval of the conditional zoning but noted a significant issue regarding the Type B landscape buffer along the Reed Creek stream. Due to overlapping requirements for stormwater mitigation and tree canopy preservation, staff determined that planting the full required number of trees would be infeasible. The proposed modification reduces the requirement for evergreen trees by 24 and halves the requirement for deciduous trees. The City Attorney clarified that it is up to the Council to decide if this change warrants sending it back to the Planning and Zoning Commission for review.
For the Ingalls Grocery Store project at 1001 Patton Avenue, staff presented a proposal to rezone the former Kmart site from Highway Business to Commercial Expansion/Conditional Zone. The project includes a grocery store, four other retail spaces, a gas station, and 421 parking spaces. Staff recommended approval, noting the project improves sidewalks, bus shelters, and adds EV charging stations. A public commenter representing the Emma Neighborhood Council spoke in support, emphasizing the site’s proximity to a diverse neighborhood with naturally occurring affordable housing. They requested the opportunity to provide input on future retail tenants to ensure they meet community needs. A council member responded by acknowledging the community’s concerns about displacement and gentrification, noting that adding affordable housing in a lower-income neighborhood could be seen as gentrifying.
Merrimon Avenue Road Diet
The Council discussed an agreement with the N.C. Dept. of Transportation (NCDOT) to convert Merrimon Avenue from four lanes to three lanes between Midland Road and W.T. Weaver Boulevard as part of a resurfacing project. The city’s cost share is $275,000, with a potential $300,000 cost to revert the design if safety issues arise. Staff cited a public survey where 59% of respondents supported the conversion and noted that similar road diets in Charlotte, NC, reduced crashes by 59%. Public comment was divided. Several residents and business owners opposed the project, arguing that driver behavior, not lane configuration, is the primary safety issue and that the Charlotte Street comparison is flawed due to differences in traffic volume. One resident cited a 300% increase in right-turn accidents on Charlotte Street. Supporters, including the board chair of Asheville on Bikes, argued the road is "failing the city" and that users are 150% more likely to be involved in a collision on Merriman than on similar roads in NC. Before the vote, a council member stated: "I just would hate to be the person... to go to a mother, a father, or a family member to say that they were injured or killed on their bike on Merriman."
Other Items and Follow-ups
The Council discussed a proposal to take over the maintenance of Jones Park, a playground on Asheville City Schools property that was demolished in August 2021. The council informally agreed to direct staff to review the proposal, including discussions with donors, the county, and the school board, and to bring recommendations back to the council. No formal vote was taken on this item.
Staff agreed to provide the results of a survey on how other communities are funding urban forestry studies, following a public comment asking for the funding plan for the Urban Forestry Master Plan. Staff also agreed to provide more detail on how the transit management company is addressing driver staffing issues, which is preventing the expansion of transit service to 10 p.m. on all routes. Council members agreed to discuss a public request to freeze 10 vacancies in public safety departments at the next public safety committee meeting to allow for diversified responses such as violence interrupters and community paramedicine.
Meeting Video & Transcript