City Council Meeting
May 10, 2022 at 12:00 PM
- 3 h 38 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: May 10, 2022
The City of Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on May 10, 2022, beginning with a worksession on the restructuring of City Council committees and boards, followed by the formal meeting. The session included the approval of routine consent items, public hearings on zoning and debt issuance, and significant new business regarding American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funding and affordable housing.
Key Decisions and Votes The Council unanimously approved the consent agenda, which included minutes from the April 25, 2022, ARPA worksession and the April 26, 2022, regular meeting. Several infrastructure and service contracts were also approved unanimously, including a resolution supporting the N.C. Dept. of Transportation for pedestrian improvements at the I-240/Charlotte Street interchange, a contract amendment with S&S Management Group (d/b/a GuardOne Security) for parking facility security, and contract amendments with Wooten Company and Patton Construction Group for the Wall Street and Rankin Avenue Garage Elevator Modernization Project. The Council also unanimously authorized contracts for the Magnolia Playground Construction Project with J. Bartholomew Construction, the Asheville Skatepark Project with Artisan Concrete Services Inc. (d/b/a Artisan Skateparks), and a budget amendment transferring $200,000 to the General Capital Projects Fund for the skatepark. Additional unanimous approvals included a contract with PBMares, LLP for the fiscal year audit, an amendment to the Passport Labs Inc. contract for parking enforcement tools, the sale of surplus equipment, and construction amendments with Weaver Cooke Construction for the City Hall Elevator Modernization Project.
In new business, the Council unanimously passed a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute agreements for ARPA funding recommendations and a budget amendment of $11,723,257 in the Special Revenue Fund to set up budgets for these awards. The Council also unanimously approved a conditional zoning change for 21 & 99999 Governor’s View Road (Redwood Commons) from River District to Residential Expansion/Conditional Zone, and a conditional zoning change for 275 Deaverview Road from RM-16 to Residential Expansion/Conditional Zone. A public hearing was held for the 2022 Interim Limited Obligation Bonds, but no vote was taken on the final resolution at this meeting.
The most contentious vote of the evening concerned the Housing Authority of the City of Asheville’s request for General Obligation Affordable Housing Bond funds for the Deaverview Apartment Project. The original motion for $1.2 million was amended to $1.465 million to cover a funding gap left by Buncombe County’s reduced contribution. This motion passed with a 5-2 vote, with Council Members Sage Turner and Gwen Wisler voting no.
Discussion Highlights A major portion of the meeting was dedicated to an update on homelessness initiatives. Emily Ball of Community and Economic Development presented the 2022 Point-in-Time Count, noting a 21% increase in homelessness since 2021, with the unsheltered population doubling to 232 people. Marcus Laws of Homeward Bound discussed the new operational model for the Asheville Homeless Outreach Project for Empowerment (AHOPE) day center, emphasizing restorative practices. Captain Mike Lamb of the Asheville Police Department reported a significant decrease in calls for service and crime incidents near the AHOPE facility. The City Manager stated that while the city is developing guidelines for food sharing in public spaces, it has no plans to enact an ordinance.
Regarding the ARPA funding, the ARPA Project Manager detailed the evaluation process for 18 projects totaling $11,723,257, noting the impact of changing U.S. Treasury rules and the commitment to results-based accountability monitoring. During the discussion on the Deaverview bond funds, a council member expressed frustration that the City is often asked to make up for community partners, specifically Buncombe County, who are not willing to share the financial burden equally.
In the worksession on boards and commissions, staff presented a proposal to restructure the advisory boards, noting the structure had not been reviewed in 16 years. Council instructed staff to slow down the advisory boards restructuring process to allow for more community feedback and to prepare talking points explaining how the new process will increase voices rather than limit them.
Community Input Public commenters raised several issues during the open comment period. Regarding the Jones Park playground, a public commenter representing the community stated that funds have been raised to rebuild the playground, which was demolished in August 2021, and that the school system is willing to lease the land to the City for $1/year in perpetuity if the City agrees to long-term maintenance. Another public commenter urged the Council to "take the gift" of the raised funds. In response, Mayor Esther Manheimer explained that the property is on school property, creating a procedural quandary, and asked for support to place the item on a future agenda to allow staff to evaluate the request. Another council member suggested that if the item is placed on the agenda, staff should also look into renaming the park to honor a local victim of violence who died there.
Multiple public commenters advocated for permanent, dedicated pickleball courts, citing mental health benefits and conflicts with tennis users. No specific member responded directly to these comments during the public comment period, though the Mayor later noted that Parks and Rec staff had committed to meeting with the pickleball group monthly. A public commenter expressed concern that the Council’s restructuring of boards and commissions was "top-down" and urged the Council to pause the process to conduct a proper survey of current board members. No specific member responded directly to this comment. Other public commenters criticized the City Manager’s Report for containing false data regarding police conduct and highlighted the banning of individuals from city parks, which they described as extrajudicial punishment. No specific member responded directly to these comments.
Follow-ups Staff and members agreed to several follow-up actions. Emily Ball agreed to consider conducting local point-in-time counts in warmer months. Captain Mike Lamb indicated he could provide comparative downtown crime data from previous years. The applicant for Redwood Commons will work with the Design Review Committee and NCDOT to improve building design and pedestrian crossings. The ARPA Project Manager stated the intention to publish the decision sheets and scoring documents used for the staff recommendation. The Mayor indicated that if the Jones Park item is placed on a future agenda, staff will be directed to evaluate the request, including maintenance costs and potential renaming. Staff noted that the City is working on a plan to allocate the remaining $6.2 million in affordable housing bond funds, which will be brought to Council in the summer.
Impact These decisions impact residents through the expansion of affordable housing, infrastructure improvements, and the allocation of federal recovery funds. The approval of the Redwood Commons and Deaverview zoning changes facilitates the construction of 152 new affordable housing units. The ARPA funding will support 18 projects, including domestic violence shelters, homeless services, and downtown restroom upgrades. The debt issuance hearing for the Interim Limited Obligation Bonds is a prerequisite for financing capital projects such as the Broadway Public Safety Station and greenways. The restructuring of boards and commissions aims to make advisory bodies more inclusive and aligned with the City’s Comprehensive Plan.
Meeting Video & Transcript