Historic Resources Commission
February 11, 2026 at 4:00 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 2 h 31 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: February 11, 2026
The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) held an in-person meeting on February 11, 2026, to review requests for alterations, new construction, and repairs within historic districts and landmarks. As a quasi-judicial body, the commission evaluated these applications against established state and city ordinances to ensure proposed changes maintain the historic character of the properties. The meeting focused primarily on public hearings for Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) and Preliminary Subdivision Approval requests, with a significant portion of the agenda dedicated to projects in the Montford and Biltmore Village Historic Districts, many of which involved repairs stemming from Tropical Storm Helene.
The commission began by approving the minutes from the previous meeting, dated January 14, 2026, along with the associated Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law. This item passed unanimously with a vote of 16-0. Following the approval of the minutes, the commission reviewed the public hearing rules and proceeded to the main agenda items.
Two hearings were continued to a future meeting in March 2026 to allow for further review. The first was for 53 Birch Street, which involves the replacement of a partially collapsed stone retaining wall; this continuation passed with a vote of 16-0. The second was for 345 Montford Avenue, also involving the replacement of a partially collapsed stone retaining wall; this continuation also passed with a vote of 16-0. Staff noted that applicants for both properties need to provide more detailed information regarding veneer materials and clarify the need for concrete versus rebuilding with existing stone before the hearings resume.
The commission voted to approve the application for 1 Woodlawn Avenue, which passed with a vote of 16-0. The project involves modifications to the rear elevation, including the removal of existing windows, the installation of new French doors, and the construction of a deck. The approval was conditional on the applicant submitting revised handrail drawings and door specifications for staff review and approval. The commission specifically requested picket railings instead of the originally proposed design to better align with historic standards.
Several other applications were reviewed and approved unanimously, though specific vote tallies were not recorded in the provided summaries. For 5 All Souls Crescent in Biltmore Village, the commission approved the replacement of existing vinyl double-hung windows with new wood double-hung true divided light (TDL) windows. The approval stipulated that the windows must be true divided lights rather than simulated ones to maintain the historic character of the district. The applicant is required to submit revised TDL window specifications for staff review. For 52 Cumberland Circle, the commission approved the replacement of rear porch screening with wood windows and a single-lite wood door, finding the proposal consistent with the Montford Historic District Design Review Standards.
The commission also reviewed applications for 265 Cumberland Avenue and 101 Santee Street, both of which were continued to March 2026. For 265 Cumberland Avenue, the commission expressed concerns about the proposal to widen a driveway and relocate a retaining wall, citing potential impacts on the historic streetscape. The hearing was continued to request a revised drawing with scaled dimensions that addresses these concerns. For 101 Santee Street, the commission continued the hearing to request a grading plan showing site impacts and clarification on the proposed railing design for a porch enclosure and deck. The commission also noted that the proposed trash enclosure must comply with regulations and be appropriately screened.
Staff members were tasked with researching previous driveway approvals, particularly regarding the Cumberland Avenue property, to assist in the review process. The commission emphasized the importance of adhering to historic preservation standards, particularly regarding the configuration and materials of driveways and the preservation of character-defining features such as porches and windows. No public comments from members of the public were recorded in the transcript summary for this meeting.
Meeting Video & Transcript