Skip to main content
  • 4 h 9 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: December 14, 2021

The City of Asheville City Council held a regular meeting via simultaneous communication on December 14, 2021. The agenda included routine consent items, public hearings on zoning and transportation, and a significant decision regarding the future use of the Ramada Inn property for homeless services.

Key Decisions and Votes

The Council approved the minutes from the November 9, 2021 meeting and adopted the 2022-23 Budget Calendar and the 2022 City Council meeting schedule unanimously. Several grant applications and contracts were approved, including the 2022 BikeSafe grant, the Shuttered Venue Operators Grant for the Harrah’s Cherokee Center, and a lease amendment for The Grind, LLC at 8 River Arts Place. The Council also authorized the purchase of three new transit buses for the Asheville Rides system and the sale of two surplus Freightliner trucks.

In the public hearings, the Council passed an amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) regarding homestays by a vote of 6-1, with Council Member Sage Turner voting no. This amendment prohibits detached accessory structures from being used as homestays, requires non-resident owners with more than a 5% interest to be co-applicants, and allows full kitchens in homestays. The Council unanimously approved the voluntary annexation of 99999 Sweeten Creek Road and its zoning to the RS-2 district with a Future Land Use designation of Parks/Open Space. Additionally, the Council unanimously approved UDO amendments updating hotel development standards and adopted three corridor studies (Hendersonville Road, Tunnel Road, and Biltmore Avenue/McDowell Street) as amendments to the Asheville In Motion Mobility Plan. The public hearings for open space requirements and the conditional zoning amendment for 511 Brevard Road were continued to February 8, 2022, and March 22, 2022, respectively.

The most contentious item concerned the property at 148-150 River Ford Parkway (the Ramada). The Council voted 6-1 to assign the real estate contract to Shangri-La Industries, Inc. for the creation of permanent supportive housing, with Council Member Antanette Mosley voting no. The Council also voted 6-1 (Mosley voting no) to authorize an American Rescue Plan (ARPA) funded agreement with Step Up on Second Street, Inc. for $1.5 million to provide supportive services, and 6-1 (Mosley voting no) to extend contracts with Five P Mountain, LLC and Sunrise Community for Recovery & Wellness through March 31, 2022. A motion to fully fund the property as a high-access shelter failed for lack of a second.

Discussion Highlights

Council Member Kim Roney pulled several consent agenda items for individual votes, including the EPIC Recruiting contract, the Edward Byrne Justice Assistance Grant, and the Bulletproof Vest Grant, all of which passed 6-1 with Roney voting no. Roney stated she wanted to note her reasons for pulling these items, citing a desire to diversify public safety response and invest in root causes of crime rather than expanding "business as usual" policing funding.

Regarding the Ramada property, staff presented a proposal to pivot from an emergency shelter to permanent supportive housing (PSH), citing the unsustainability of the $24 million cost for a long-term emergency shelter. Council Member Kim Roney expressed deep concern that the city had "fumbled this emergency shelter funding program" and failed neighbors experiencing homelessness. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated she was "very disappointed" that the high-access shelter plan did not work out at that site but supported acquiring it with partners.

Community Input

Public comment was extensive, particularly regarding the homestay and Ramada items. During the homestay hearing, a public commenter argued that allowing kitchens effectively converts whole homes to short-term rentals, harming affordable housing, while another resident supported adding a reasonable size sink for sanitary reasons. A representative of the Asheville Homestay Network presented data arguing that the previous kitchen rule increased costs for hosts without slowing permit applications.

Regarding the Ramada property, a public commenter representing a local safety group expressed deep opposition to the plans, citing a rise in crime and harassment in the area since the shelter opened. Another resident stated that regardless of the vote, the city is obligated to clean up the area and provide housing and services for current Ramada residents. At the end of the meeting, a public commenter cited a 2020 article alleging that Step Up and Shangri-La were a "sinkhole for public money" in Los Angeles and requested that the city allow people to camp out and provide hygiene facilities. Another public commenter requested that the City Manager release the Request for Proposals (RFP) responses for the original emergency shelter plan.

Follow-ups

Staff agreed to identify alternative funding sources, such as opioid settlement funds or Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds, for the second and third years of the Step Up supportive services grant, rather than using all $1.5 million from ARPA funds. Council Member Sage Turner stated she would reach out to the coalition of nonprofits that coordinate "Code Purple" (cold weather sheltering) to discuss stopgap solutions for the winter. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated she would consult with the Buncombe County Chair regarding the mask mandate and Omicron case numbers to determine if the January 11, 2022, meeting will be held in person or virtually.

Impact

These decisions significantly alter the city's approach to homelessness and urban development. The shift of the Ramada property to permanent supportive housing with a 50-year deed restriction aims to create a long-term asset for 100+ individuals, leveraging private capital for renovation while using public funds for services. The homestay and hotel ordinance updates clarify regulations for short-term lodging and large hotels, respectively, which may impact the local housing stock and downtown development. The adoption of the corridor studies provides a framework for future transportation improvements along major roads, prioritizing safety and multimodal connectivity without immediate financial commitment.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches