City Council Meeting
June 22, 2021 at 12:00 PM
- 2 h 55 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: June 22, 2021
The Asheville City Council held its regular meeting on June 22, 2021, at the Harrah’s Cherokee Center. The council took action on a wide range of items, including the adoption of the Fiscal Year 2021-22 Annual Operating Budget, updates to housing and land use policies, and various administrative contracts. The meeting also featured presentations on public safety, water quality, and the city’s reparations process.
Key Decisions
The council adopted the Fiscal Year 2021-22 Annual Operating Budget with a vote of 6-1. The budget includes a General Fund total of $145,233,553 and an ad valorem tax rate of 40.30 cents per $100 of assessed value. The only recorded vote against the budget was from Council Member Kim Roney.
All other recorded votes passed unanimously (7-0). These decisions include:
- Land Use Incentive Grant Policy: Updated the policy to allow existing market-rate units to convert to affordable housing, with points awarded for affordability duration and income restrictions.
- Homeward Bound Support: Supported Homeward Bound in its purchase of the Days Inn at 201 Tunnel Road for a permanent supportive housing project. The city committed to providing $2,000,000 in grant funds for the acquisition.
- US Cellular License: Authorized a 10-year license agreement for a telecommunications tower at 57 Crestwood Drive, with an annual rent of $42,300.
- Air Products Contract: Authorized a five-year contract for liquid oxygen at the Mills River Water Treatment Plant, totaling $322,674.
- FEMA Grant: Authorized the application for a $130,910 Assistance to Firefighters Grant.
- Flood Mitigation: Accepted the annual Flood Mitigation Actions report and supported re-certification in the Community Rating System Program.
- I-26 Connector Project: Authorized a $7,000 contract amendment with Sam Schwartz Consulting LLC, bringing the total contract value to $207,000.
- Median Maintenance: Authorized a one-year contract extension with Rivertop Contracting.
- Carbon Tracking: Authorized a contract renewal with Dude Solutions for the city’s carbon tracking system.
- Ethics Policy: Adopted a new Ethics Policy for advisory boards and commissions.
- Budget Amendment: Adopted a technical budget amendment of $35,403,247 in the General Fund to account for the refunding of debt.
- Easement: Authorized a permanent easement for an existing loading dock at 99 Riverside Drive, with the city receiving $5,000 for the 312 square feet of right-of-way.
- Police Alarms: Revised the police alarm ordinance and amended the Fees & Charges Manual, introducing new permit and appeal fees.
- Land Donation: Authorized the acceptance of a 0.12-acre land donation at Old Haywood Road and Eastview Circle for Fire Department use.
- Meeting Schedule: Amended the 2021 schedule to include a worksession on the American Rescue Plan Act summary plan on July 27, 2021.
The council also continued the public hearing to conditionally rezone property at 70 Mills Gap Road to the Residential Expansion/Conditional Zone, scheduling the hearing for September 14, 2021.
Discussion Highlights
Budget and Equity During the budget adoption, Council Member Kim Roney voted no, citing the need for $1 million for intergenerational Black leadership and divestment from policing. She presented data on the disproportionate impact of property taxes on low-income neighborhoods and proposed amendments to freeze 15 open police positions and commit to finding funds to mitigate property tax impacts. Mayor Esther Manheimer noted that Roney’s motions failed for lack of a second. Council Member Antanette Mosley raised concerns about the safety of Black women if police numbers were reduced, noting that Black females, who make up 6% of the population, account for 16% of violent crime victims.
Reparations and Public Safety City Manager Debra Campbell reported that Phase 1 of the community reparations process (Information Sharing/Truth Telling) is underway, with a speaker series held in June. Staff will compile information for the upcoming Reparations Commission. Chief David Zack of the Asheville Police Department presented crime statistics, noting a 45% increase in overall crime from 2011 to 2020, but a decrease in gun violence and traffic stops in 2021. He discussed staffing challenges, including recent attrition, and the implementation of the TIP411 anonymous tip line.
Noise Ordinance Assistant City Manager Ben Woody presented an update on the noise ordinance revision. Due to community feedback and the pandemic, the effective date will be delayed by at least six months, with the ordinance returning to council for a vote in September 2021. Staff are currently tracking data as if the new ordinance were in effect to test its impact.
Lead and Copper Rule Brenna Cook, Compliance Manager for Water Resources, presented the EPA’s revised Lead and Copper Rule. The city has never exceeded the 90th percentile action levels for lead and copper. The new rules require a public inventory of service lines by 2024 and full replacement if action levels are exceeded.
Follow-ups
- Noise Ordinance: Ben Woody agreed to provide heat maps showing the location and number of sound exceedance permits. Staff agreed to continue collecting data and tracking noise complaints as if the new ordinance were in effect during the interim period.
- Reparations: Debra Campbell stated staff will compile information from the speaker series to share with the Reparations Commission and will develop a Request for Proposals for a project manager to support the commission.
- Property Tax: Mayor Esther Manheimer stated that Joe Minicozzi had agreed to present to council at a future date regarding the disproportionate impact of property tax assessments.
- Housing Policy: City Attorney Brad Branham agreed to look into a "ban the box" question regarding housing access for individuals reentering society and provide specific information to Council Member Kim Roney.
Impact
This meeting established the city’s financial framework for the coming year through the adoption of the operating budget, which includes staff raises and specific allocations for public safety and infrastructure. The update to the Land Use Incentive Grant Policy aims to increase the stock of affordable housing by incentivizing the conversion of market-rate units. The support for the Days Inn acquisition represents a significant step toward addressing the city’s shortage of permanent supportive housing. Additionally, the revisions to the police alarm ordinance and the noise ordinance update reflect the council’s ongoing efforts to balance public safety, quality of life, and administrative efficiency.
Meeting Video & Transcript