City Council Meeting
May 25, 2021 at 12:00 PM
- 2 h 23 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: May 25, 2021
The City of Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on May 25, 2021, conducted via simultaneous communication. The agenda included the approval of routine consent items, a presentation of the proposed Fiscal Year 2021-22 Annual Operating Budget, four public hearings regarding zoning and development regulations, and the final approval of the purchase of the Talbert Lot at 50 Asheland Avenue.
Key Decisions and Votes
The Council unanimously (7-0) approved the consent agenda, which included the minutes from the May 11, 2021, meeting. Routine actions taken during the consent agenda included:
- Recycling Contract: Authorization to amend the contract with Curbside Management Inc. for a five-year extension. The residential recycling fee will increase from $3.15 to $3.80 per month, though the total solid waste fee remains $14 per month.
- Security Cameras: Authorization to contract with Brooks Network Services, LLC, for $99,975.27 to replace 55 existing cameras and add 8 new ones at the Asheville Police Department.
- Bus Stop Improvements: Acceptance of a $16,000 donation ($14,000 from the Rotary Clubs of Asheville-Biltmore and Arden, and $2,000 from the Montford Neighborhood Association) for bus shelter improvements at three locations.
- Homeless Shelter: Ratification of contracts with three local hotels to provide emergency non-congregate shelter, funded by a $438,000 budget amendment from American Rescue Plan funds.
- Fire Station #13: Authorization of a $7,500 agreement with the N.C. Dept. of Transportation for traffic review and inspection of fire preemption phasing.
- Audit: Authorization for the Mayor to execute a contract with PBMares, LLP for the fiscal year 2021 audit, with a maximum fee of $125,800.
- Housing Trust Fund: Approval of the rescission of a $1,100,000 loan previously awarded to The Juna Group, returning the funds to the Housing Trust Fund balance.
Regarding public hearings, the Council voted to continue the hearing on Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) open space requirements until September 14, 2021 (7-0). The hearing on UDO homestay amendments was continued until September 28, 2021 (7-0). The hearing to rezone 99999 Glendale Avenue from Residential Multi-Family High Density to Commercial Industrial was recessed until June 8, 2021 (7-0). The hearing on UDO amendments related to decision-making bodies (Articles III, V, VI, and VII) was recessed until June 8, 2021, with a vote of 6-1; Councilwoman Kim Roney voted "No."
In New Business, the Council voted to recuse Mayor Esther Manheimer from the 50 Asheland Avenue items due to a conflict of interest (7-0), with Vice Mayor Sheneika Smith assuming the chair. With the Mayor recused, the Council voted 6-0 to authorize the purchase of the 0.89-acre Talbert Lot at 50 Asheland Avenue for $2.5 million and to ratify a grant agreement with the Dogwood Health Trust for $1.25 million. The Council also voted 6-0 to adopt a budget amendment in the General Capital Projects Fund for $1.25 million to account for the Dogwood grant funds.
Discussion Highlights
City Manager Deborah Campbell and Finance Director Tony McDowell presented the proposed FY 2021-22 budget, totaling $201.7 million, a 9.2% increase over the current year. The proposal includes a property tax rate of 41.30 cents per $100 of assessed value, which is 3 cents above the revenue-neutral rate. Key investments include $1.2 million from fund balance for reparations, $7.9 million for the Archer Compensation Study, and $583,000 to hire 15 additional firefighters for the new Broadway Public Safety Station.
During the budget discussion, Mayor Manheimer expressed concern about the clarity of the numbers, stating, "I’m having a little kind of challenge with the numbers because the proposed property tax increases 3 cents... I’m kind of wondering if we need to pull that out so that we have a flow here that looks at recurring expenses and recurring revenue not mixed together with one-time revenue allocations and one-time revenue expenditures." Councilwoman Sage Turner encouraged the body to separate ongoing and one-time expenses to see if the tax increase could be reduced to two cents. Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore suggested treating the $1 million reparations allocation as a recurring expense. Councilwoman Antanette Mosley asked for clarification on whether pulling from fund balance would result in a tax increase for reparations. Councilwoman Kim Roney suggested voting on the reparations funding at the June 8 meeting to pass it before Juneteenth or looking at offsets to reduce the property tax increase. City Manager Campbell noted that staff must decide whether to commit to the $1 million reparations fund now or wait for a commission to make recommendations.
For the 50 Asheland Avenue purchase, Interim Community and Economic Development Director Nikki Reed presented the acquisition, noting the site was historically "red-lined." Councilwoman Gwen Wisler stated, "I think this transaction makes a lot of sense on paper with the funds we've set aside and really just as a big jump in planning... We have to get people out of cars. We have to build more housing. This does both." Councilwoman Roney highlighted the regional transit implications of connecting the site with adjacent county transit systems. Staff clarified that the budget amendment only accounts for the $1.25 million Dogwood grant, as the remaining city funds are already in the General Capital Projects Fund via land banking dollars.
Community Input
Six individuals spoke via advanced live call-ins. One commenter expressed hope for a return to in-person meetings to improve accessibility and urged the council to move quickly on reparations and public safety initiatives. Another commenter asked for clarification on whether all fire department employees would receive a living wage of $17/hour, noted the absence of an urban forester position in the budget, and expressed concern about the tax hike for renters and lower-income owners. A third commenter thanked the council for the vote to remove the Vance Monument and provided historical context regarding Asheville’s Jim Crow era policies. Multiple commenters, including a Latinx homeowner in West Asheville, argued that the proposed tax hike would devastate working-class BIPOC families, describing it as "second urban renewal" that would displace Black and brown communities. These commenters urged the council to lower tax rates, defund the police, and create a separate financial structure for the reparations fund. Members did not respond to these comments.
Follow-ups
Finance Director Tony McDowell agreed to provide a breakdown of the budget separating one-time expenses/revenue from recurring expenses/revenue. City Manager Deborah Campbell agreed to provide a list of current vacancies across all departments, including the most recent wage/salary for each position, to Councilwoman Roney. Staff from Development Services agreed to look into sending updates to existing homestay permit holders regarding the status of the homestay ordinance amendments. Staff member Shannon Tuck stated that staff is working with the Development Services Department on ways for neighborhood groups to sign up for notifications for Board of Adjustment and Historic Resource Commission hearings.
Impact
The approval of the 50 Asheland Avenue purchase allows the City to close on the property in June 2021, securing a site adjacent to the transit center for future affordable housing and transit expansion. The budget presentation sets the stage for a public hearing on June 8, 2021, and final adoption on June 22, 2021. The deferral of the UDO amendments and the Glendale Avenue rezoning to June 8, 2021, allows for additional review and public comment before final decisions are made on those development regulations.
Meeting Video & Transcript