B. Jackson & Co., LLC, represented by Allen Stahl & Kilbourne, PLLC, seeks appeal of a Unified Development Ordinance determination made by Planning and Urban Design Director Stephanie Dahl, Dated November 17, 2025.
Board of Adjustment (In-Person) (Feb 23, 2026) · February 23, 2026 at 8:45 AM
L. B. Jackson & Co., LLC, represented by Allen Stahl & Kilbourne, PLLC, seeks appeal of a Unified Development Ordinance determination made by Planning and Urban Design Director Stephanie Dahl, Dated November 17, 2025.
What was said
Sam Starbaum, Urban Planner 3, will be presenting this morning. Sam Starbaum: Yes. Thank you, Madam Chair, and congratulations to our new Vice Chair. I am Sam Starbaum. I am a Planner 3. I work for the Planning and Urban Design Department. And this will seem familiar to you. You have done quite a few of these presentations already and in quite a few flood variances. I've kept this same format. I would ask for your patience and understanding. I think it is important not just for the Board to know this but for the community to see this every time about how we did our math to get here, what this is, and why we're doing this the way we are. So this is -- even though you are well-versed experts at this point, I think it is still important to start from the first step in our journey. So again, what is a flood variance and when is it required? It is required when the over 50 percent of the building was damaged in a flood, right? And what would it cost to repair it to the day prior to the storm? We're not talking about a new Costco, we're not talking about some other greater improvement, is what did it look like the night before the storm in September, in Olene in this case. So when it is 50% damage and above, it is then substantially damaged, and then they are required to come into compliance with FEMA standards. Obviously in doing that it raises some concerns in historic districts because it impacts the historic character. So you are allowed to seek a variance, a flood variance in this case, to meet those FEMA standards to the extent practicable, not exactly, but to your best ability to meet those flood proofing standards without impacting that historic character. And that is what we have before us today with 30 Lodge Street. So here's some simple math for you. What we do have is that bottom number is the building value according to the assessor's report. It is entirely possible that the wayside bar and grill is worth way more than that in a private appraisal. But what we are using here is Buncombe County figures. And what Chris Reno, the applicant, has determined is that it would cost $179,000 to repair that building to what it was just before the storm. That's 78.7%. That's of course greater than 50. So this is substantially damaged. they now have to comply with these standards.