Skip to main content
  • 4 h 2 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: February 23, 2021

The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on February 23, 2021, conducted via simultaneous communication. The agenda included routine consent items, public hearings regarding property annexation and right-of-way closures, and significant votes on new hotel development regulations and the city’s legislative priorities for the state legislature. The meeting also featured a detailed presentation on the city’s community reparations process and public comment regarding a large development project in the Richmond Hill neighborhood.

Key Decisions and Votes

The Council unanimously (7-0) approved the consent agenda, which included the minutes from the February 9, 2021, meeting. Routine resolutions were also adopted unanimously, authorizing the City Manager to sign a one-year lease extension with Balsam Gardens, LLC, to use sole-source procurement for equipment at the Broadway Public Safety Station and Dr. Wesley Grant Sr. Southside Center, and to execute a contract amendment with Western Carolina Rescue Ministries, Inc. to extend Code Purple emergency shelter services. A budget amendment of $50,000 was approved to fund the shelter extension. The Council also unanimously adopted initial resolutions for the 2021 Limited Obligation and Special Obligation Refunding Bonds, which will be used to refinance $34.9 million of existing debt.

In a 6-1 vote, with Councilwoman Kim Roney voting no, the Council amended the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) to adopt new standards regulating hotels. This included increasing required public benefit points and prioritizing affordable housing and reparations. In a separate 6-1 vote, also with Councilwoman Roney voting no, the Council applied a new Hotel Overlay District to specific properties, removing the Grey Eagle Music Hall property and areas overlapping with urban renewal zones from the district. Regarding the Asheville City Board of Education, the Council voted 6-1 (Roney voting no) to request essays and interviews from three current board members and four other applicants, narrowing the candidate pool. Finally, the Council unanimously (7-0) adopted the 2021 City Council Legislative Agenda.

Public Hearings and Recessions

The Council held public hearings on four items but voted unanimously (7-0) to recess each until March 9, 2021, to allow for additional written comments as required by recent state legislation regarding remote meetings. These items included the permanent closure of unopened right-of-way east of Bellevue Road and west of Edgewood Road; the closure of unopened right-of-way connecting to Biltmore Avenue south of White Fawn Drive; the voluntary annexation of 0.47 acres off Oak Hill Circle and Moorecrest Road; and the initial zoning of that same property to RM-16 (Residential Multi-Family High Density). No final votes were taken on these items at this meeting.

Discussion Highlights: Reparations and Hotel Regulations

City Manager Deborah Campbell presented a three-phase plan to implement Resolution 20-128, which supports community reparations for Black Asheville. The plan outlines a timeline running until April 2023, beginning with a speaker series for truth-telling, followed by the formation of a joint City-County Community Reparations Commission, and concluding with a final report of recommendations. Council members offered mixed feedback; Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore called it a "great first start," while Councilwoman Kim Roney expressed concern that the plan did not yet address how the city would stop perpetuating harm. Councilwoman Sage Turner suggested the timeline might need to move quicker to allow more time for community input.

Regarding hotel regulations, Councilwoman Kim Roney initially moved to double the required points in the Public Benefits Table, but this motion failed with a vote of 2-5. The Council then voted to approve the staff-recommended amendments, which included a 30-40% increase in points. City Attorney Brad Branham noted that while North Carolina law does not specify an end date for moratoriums, indefinite moratoriums are effectively bans, which the city cannot impose. Staff confirmed they are tentatively scheduled to return to Council in six months to review the new standards.

Community Input

Public comment was heard on several items. Regarding the annexation and zoning of the Oak Hill/Moorecrest property, a public commenter from West Asheville expressed concern about traffic safety, noting that Oak Hill Drive has narrow roads and dangerous intersections, and that adding 12 new lots would increase traffic in a neighborhood of working families. No council member or staff member responded directly to this comment.

On the School Board appointments, multiple public commenters expressed frustration with the decision to narrow the candidate field before receiving endorsements from the Asheville City Association of Educators (ACAE). One retired principal emphasized the need for advocates for Black students. In response, Councilmember Sage Turner stated she was struggling with the process and asked the City Attorney if the pool could be expanded later; the City Attorney confirmed Council has the leeway to change the process before the final appointment vote. The Mayor noted that a joint meeting with the County School Board is being tentatively scheduled for April.

Regarding the 2021 Legislative Agenda, a public commenter suggested developing agendas more openly to allow for public comment. Another commenter requested a specific allocation for the occupancy tax and argued for removing lodging association requirements from the Tourism Development Authority board. The Mayor explained that an elected school board item was excluded because the legislative delegation requires unanimous Council support, and Council was divided on the issue.

The most extensive public comment occurred regarding the "Bluffs at River Bend" development (1,545 units) in the Richmond Hill neighborhood. Numerous residents spoke, expressing deep concern about traffic on narrow, unmarked streets, environmental impacts on the French Broad River, and equity issues, noting that Woodfin receives tax revenue while Asheville bears the infrastructure burden. Residents urged Council to seek standing in the Woodfin Planning and Zoning Commission hearing to ensure a bridge is built. Mayor Esther Manheimer clarified that the City is not seeking standing in that hearing but noted that the City will likely need to issue permits for access through the Richmond Hill neighborhood if the project proceeds. No other Council members responded directly to the requests for standing.

Follow-ups

City Manager Deborah Campbell stated that staff will identify partners, funding, speakers, and a project manager for the reparations process. Staff agreed to provide a "demo" presentation before the six-month review of hotel regulations to show how an application would move through the new process. Councilmember Sage Turner stated she had submitted an email to the City Attorney regarding the Bluffs development and explicitly agreed to provide general information to the Council ahead of the Planning Board meeting the following week, specifically regarding the idea that the Metropolitan Sewerage District and the City of Asheville would be requested to provide water and sewer services. The next regular meeting is scheduled for March 9, 2021.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches