Skip to main content
  • 5 h 8 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: July 14, 2020

The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on July 14, 2020, conducted via simultaneous communication due to the ongoing pandemic. The agenda addressed a range of issues, including public hearings on rezoning and federal funding, a review of the City Manager’s response to community demands regarding racial equity, and significant new business concerning police accountability and community reparations.

Key Decisions and Votes The Council approved the minutes from the June 23, 2020 meeting, unanimously (7-0). On the consent agenda, the Council authorized the City Manager to execute a contract with Patton Construction Group, Inc. for Fiscal Year 2020-21 Utility Cut Concrete Repair, passing 7-0. The Council also authorized an agreement with the Asheville Area Arts Council to create a Black Lives Matter mural around Pack Square Plaza, passing 7-0.

Regarding public hearings, the Council continued the hearing for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Investment Partnership Act funds Annual Action Plan for Fiscal Year 2020-21 to July 28, passing 7-0. Similarly, the public hearing to consider conditionally rezoning property at 61 Innovation Drive was continued to July 28, passing 7-0. The public hearing to consider rezoning property at 23 Courtland Avenue, 99999 Courtland Avenue, 99999 Woodside Place, and 99999 Gudger Street was recessed to July 28 to allow for a vote at that time, passing 7-0.

In unfinished business, the Council voted to amend the 2019-20 Annual Action Plan to allocate funds to help prevent, prepare for, and respond to COVID-19, passing 7-0. In new business, the Council tabled the resolution delegating authority to the City Attorney to enter into a contract with Hillard Heintze to evaluate the Asheville Police Department’s response to recent protests; this motion passed 6-1, with Councilman Vijay Kapoor voting no. Finally, the Council adopted a resolution supporting community reparations for Black Asheville, passing 7-0.

Discussion Highlights City Manager Debra Campbell presented the 30/60/90-Day Work Plan developed in response to the Black Asheville Demands Coalition. She reported that Confederate monuments have been removed or shrouded, staff is working with the African American Heritage Commission on street renaming, and a community engagement process to "reimagine policing" is being developed with a broader launch planned for early August. Campbell stated, "I want equity and inclusion within the City of Asheville local government to be a value and not something that we check off a box or we forward to another department."

Regarding the police evaluation, City Attorney Brad Branham proposed a contract with Hillard Heintze to evaluate the Asheville Police Department’s response to protests from May 30 to June 6. Branham stated, "I feel very strongly tonight that Hillard-Hines possesses the necessary competence, experience, expertise, and... independence to conduct a thorough, fair, and unbiased evaluation." However, Councilman Brian Haynes withdrew his support, stating, "I have gone from second guessing my decision to regretting my decision. I no longer want to go this route." Councilwoman Sheneika Smith moved to table the discussion, noting it would give the Council time to digest the presentation and interact with public reaction. Councilman Vijay Kapoor voted against tabling, expressing concern that the review should not be moved solely to the Public Safety Committee but rather remain with the full Council.

On the reparations resolution, Councilman Keith Young emphasized that the resolution was a "first step" to acknowledge historical wrongs, stating, "We require what I believe is to be institutional change to move forward." Councilwoman Smith added, "The first step towards rectifying any societal problem is to acknowledge that there is an actual problem in the first place." Councilwoman Julie Mayfield noted, "This is not just about the budget, but the budget is the big stick that we carry... We need to shift a lot of where we're spending to make it it the moral document that it needs to be."

Community Input Public comment was extensive, particularly regarding the police evaluation and reparations. On the police contract, numerous commenters expressed opposition to the $83,000 cost, arguing that video evidence of police misconduct already exists and that the firm is biased toward law enforcement. Commenters repeatedly called for the immediate defunding of the Asheville Police Department by 50%, the banning of tear gas, and the resignation of the Mayor and Police Chief. One public commenter argued that the report would likely find actions "technically legal" but not ethical, urging the Council to act on moral principles rather than waiting for bureaucratic reports. No members responded to these specific comments.

On the reparations resolution, public commenters called for the dismantling of the police rather than reform, stating, "We are seeking the defunding of the Asheville Police Department... We are not looking for police reform or for people to, or for endless delays in action." Another commenter criticized the city's "amnesia" and "lip service," stating, "That money not only needs to come from the state, it will come from defunding 50% of APD's budget." A white resident spoke from the perspective of personal responsibility, stating, "I’m speaking out today to save my own soul... I’m responsible for the beating of Johnny Rush... because I paid the man who did." Other commenters expressed disappointment, calling the resolution "boilerplate" or "divisive," while others demanded concrete financial actions such as direct payments and land restitution. No members responded to these comments.

Follow-ups Councilwoman Smith stated that the timeline for the mural installation would be announced after a meeting later that week. City Manager Campbell confirmed that staff members are working on the process for renaming parks, in addition to streets. Regarding the police evaluation, Councilman Haynes, Councilwoman Smith, and Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler agreed to return to the full Council with a recommendation on the process for the police conduct review. The adopted reparations resolution directs the City Manager to establish a process within the next year to develop recommendations and to seek to establish a new commission, with at least biannual updates to the Council.

Impact This meeting marked a significant shift in the City’s approach to racial equity and public safety. The adoption of the reparations resolution commits the City to a formal process for developing recommendations on creating generational wealth and addressing historical harms, including the potential establishment of a new Community Reparations Commission. The tabling of the police evaluation contract indicates that the Council will not proceed with the proposed third-party review at this time, instead directing the Public Safety Committee to provide a recommendation on the appropriate process for reviewing police conduct. The continuation of the CDBG/HOME Action Plan and the approval of COVID-19 funds demonstrate the City’s ongoing efforts to address housing instability and public health needs during the pandemic.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches