Skip to main content
  • 5 hlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: June 9, 2020

The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on June 9, 2020, conducted via simultaneous communication due to the ongoing pandemic. The agenda addressed a wide range of topics, including the adoption of the FY 2020-21 interim budget, police reform, the removal of Confederate monuments, and various contract amendments and resolutions. The council also held public hearings on the annual operating budget and Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds, with several items continued to future meetings to allow for further community engagement.

Key Decisions and Votes

The council unanimously (7-0) approved the consent agenda, which included the minutes from the May 26, 2020 meeting and numerous resolutions. These resolutions authorized the City Manager to acquire property from the State of North Carolina for Federal Alley improvements, amend contracts for the Swannanoa River Greenway Phase II and Harrah’s Cherokee Center renovations, and extend agreements for hazardous materials response and firefighter physicals. The council also unanimously approved a resolution to apply for $8.6 million in Federal Transit Administration CARES Act funds, amending the transit budget by $4,936,000 to pass funds to subrecipients. Additionally, the council unanimously accepted an offer to sell air rights over Wall Street and waived construction permitting fees for the Asheville Art Museum.

Regarding development incentives, the council unanimously (7-0) voted to consider a land use incentive grant for the 2 Restaurant Court Rental Community. For the Tribute Development Collier Avenue Apartments, the vote to consider a land use incentive grant passed 6-1, with Councilman Brian Haynes voting "no."

In a significant move, the council unanimously (7-0) adopted a joint resolution with Buncombe County to remove Confederate monuments from public property. The resolution requests the United Daughters of the Confederacy to remove the 60th Regiment monument and the Robert E. Lee marker within 90 days or the cities will remove them. It also establishes a task force to determine the future of the Vance Monument, which is to be shrouded in the interim.

The council unanimously (7-0) voted to continue the public hearing on the FY 2020-21 Annual Operating Budget to August 25, 2020, with final budget adoption scheduled for September 8, 2020. The council also continued the public hearing for the CDBG/HOME Annual Action Plan to July 14, 2020, and the 2019-20 Annual Action Plan for COVID-19 funds to June 23, 2020. The public hearing for the True Hotel signage amendment was recessed unanimously (7-0) to take final action on June 23, 2020.

Discussion Highlights

A major portion of the meeting focused on police reform and the budget. City Manager Deborah Campbell presented an interim budget, stating, "We want you all to know that we have heard you... We are recommending adoption of an interim budget... We will spend the next 60 days engaging the community to develop the final budget." Police Chief David Zak presented a 30, 60, and 90-day action plan, noting, "APD cannot solve systemic racism alone. Our plan forward will require the participation of government and community partners."

Council members engaged in detailed discussion regarding the police reform plan. Council Member Keith Young emphasized the need for structural changes, stating, "Simply changing where money goes, does not stop the foundation of practice that affects the outcomes... I am willing to go the distance to seek whatever structural change is needed." Council Member Gwen Wisler read a statement supporting the "Black Asheville Demands," including a 50% reduction of the police budget, and requested an inventory of military-grade weapons in the police armory. Council Member Sheneika Smith, discussing the monument removal, stated, "I do believe that it will jumpstart healing from racial trauma... I think it's ceremonial in nature, inaugurating the demolition of a lot of the systems that affect blacks in society."

The council also received a presentation from the Aesthetics Committee on the I-26 Connector Project, which outlined design concepts for bridges and roads with cost estimates ranging from $6.2 million to $9.8 million for enhanced treatments. The council received the report for information, with staff noting that final recommendations and a funding plan would return to the council.

Community Input

Public comment was extensive, particularly regarding the police reform and monument removal. During the police reform segment, commenters expressed outrage over the destruction of a medic station during recent protests, with some calling for the immediate firing of the Police Chief and Mayor. Others demanded a 50% cut to the police budget or the abolition of the department. One public commenter expressed support for the police, stating, "I think it's absolutely ridiculous that you would even consider [defunding] the police... You need to stand by your man a little more." No council members responded directly to the demands for abolition or resignation during the open comment period.

Regarding the Confederate monuments, many commenters supported removal, arguing the monuments represent white supremacy and were erected to intimidate Black communities. One public commenter noted the disparity between the police budget ($29.6M) and the school budget ($12.6M). Councilman Keith Young responded to the "heritage" arguments, stating, "I don't want to be a part of that. And if anybody else wants to be a part of that, you show your true colors." Some commenters opposed removal, suggesting the addition of interpretive plaques instead, but no specific member countered these arguments directly in the transcript.

Follow-ups

City Manager Deborah Campbell stated that the APD line-item budgets would be made public later that evening and that all 1,379 voicemail messages and 1,642 written comments regarding the budget would be transcribed and posted to the virtual engagement hub. Council agreed to include questions raised by Council Member Mayfield regarding participatory budgeting, urban renewal maps, personnel policy, traffic stop reporting, and Racial Equity Institute training in the 30, 60, 90-day response list. Transportation Director Ken Putnam stated that staff would work out details for public feedback on the I-26 Aesthetics report in the next couple of days.

Impact

This meeting marked a significant shift in the city's approach to policing and equity, with the adoption of an interim budget to allow for 60 days of community engagement before the final budget is adopted. The removal of Confederate monuments and the establishment of a task force for the Vance Monument represent a formal municipal stance on racial history and healing. The approval of CARES Act funds ensures that transit services and safety measures, such as bus barriers, are supported during the pandemic. The deferral of the final budget and CDBG action plans indicates that the city intends to incorporate community feedback into its fiscal decisions for the coming year.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches