City Council Meeting
January 28, 2020 at 12:00 PM
- 1 h 40 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: January 28, 2020
The City of Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on January 28, 2020. The agenda included routine administrative items, a report on city facilities and water services, and new business regarding energy policy and climate action. All recorded votes on the agenda items passed with a tally of 6-0.
Key Decisions The council adopted a resolution dissolving the Energy Innovation Task Force (EITF) and anticipating the establishment of the Blue Horizons Community Council to achieve community-wide renewable energy goals. This resolution passed 6-0 after a "friendly amendment" was accepted to change the language from "creating" to "anticipate the establishment" of the council. The council also passed a resolution (6-0) authorizing the City Manager to enter into an interlocal agreement with Buncombe County to issue a joint Request for Proposals (RFP) for a nonprofit to implement the Blue Horizons Project.
In a significant policy move, the council passed a resolution (6-0) endorsing the declaration of a climate emergency and an emergency mobilization effort to restore a safe climate. The resolution commits the city to ending citywide greenhouse gas emissions as quickly as possible and no later than 2030, provided it receives necessary financial and regulatory assistance from state and federal authorities.
Several routine items were also approved with 6-0 votes. These included:
- An ordinance amending the 2019-20 Fees & Charges Manual to adjust rates and booking policy for 8 River Arts Place.
- An ordinance amending the 2019-20 Fees & Charges Manual to adjust rates and booking policy for the Harrah’s Cherokee Center.
- A resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with Bryant Land and Development Industries, Inc. for the Enhancements to State Street project.
- A resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a lease agreement with First Baptist Church for City employee parking at 5 Oak Street.
- A budget amendment in the amount of $332,174 from Federal Transit Administration Section 5310 funds to fund pass-through grants and a portion of the City's existing paratransit and administrative costs.
- A resolution authorizing the City Manager to sign Addendum #3 to the 2003 Intergovernmental Agreement with Buncombe County regarding the distribution of State 9-1-1 funds.
- A resolution supporting the French Broad Metropolitan Planning Organization’s development of a Regional Transit Feasibility Study.
- A resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into an inspection agreement with the N.C. Dept. of Transportation for the addition of pedestrian phasing at the intersection of Overlook Road and Pinchot Drive.
Discussion Highlights During the Manager’s Report, City Manager Debra Campbell provided a six-month update on the city’s financial resilience, focusing on General Obligation bond projects and the Water Department’s capital improvement plan. She noted that the city is tracking projects, spending, and construction phases, which are available on the city’s website. David Melton from the Water Department discussed the department’s strategic use of GIS technology to track areas of vulnerability and make informed investment decisions. He highlighted the completion of the North Fork Transmission Line Bypass and the ongoing North Fork Dam improvements, and explained the protocols for Boil Water Advisories.
Regarding the Blue Horizons Project, a presenter noted that the partnership between local governments and the utility was a unique victory in avoiding a peaker plant. Amber Weaver from the Office of Sustainability explained that transitioning the EITF into a nonprofit structure would reduce bureaucratic processes.
During the discussion of the Climate Emergency Resolution, Council Member Brian Haynes stated, "I would like to commend the Sunrise Movement and its members for encouraging Council to pass a climate emergency resolution. Without the persistent efforts of this vitally important youth-led movement, this resolution does not happen."
A motion was made to add an item to the agenda to direct the City Manager regarding evening bus service hours. However, Council Member Vijay Kapoor raised procedural concerns regarding the lack of prior notice and documentation, stating, "I would respectfully request whatever we're talking about, let us read it. Is there any documentation so that we know what we're actually doing? I don't know what we're doing right now." Due to these concerns, the motion to add the item was withdrawn, and no vote was taken on directing the City Manager regarding bus service at this meeting.
Community Input Public comment was received on the climate resolution, the Blue Horizons project, and bus service. Several public commenters, including members of the Sunrise Movement, urged the council to pass the climate resolution, citing the urgency of climate change and the disproportionate impact on poor communities and communities of color. One commenter noted that while the resolution is a solid start, it is limited by state restrictions and Duke Energy regulations, and urged the council to join other municipalities in pushing back on these restrictions.
A significant number of comments focused on the need for extended evening bus service hours. Public commenters described the difficulty of service workers commuting home after late shifts, often having to spend a significant portion of their wages on rideshare or walking in the dark. One commenter, the Director of Just Economics, provided statistics showing that 40% of council meetings in 2019 ended after the last bus left for the South French Broad neighborhood. Another commenter, a resident of West Asheville, stated that without a car, she had zero upward mobility and argued that transit must be a priority to reduce car dependency. No specific council member replied to the public comments regarding bus service or the climate resolution, with the exception of Council Member Brian Haynes’s acknowledgment of the Sunrise Movement mentioned in the Discussion Highlights.
Follow-ups The Mayor stated that the council would discuss the topic of evening bus service hours and potentially place it on the next agenda in the formal agenda-setting process. Additionally, the City and Buncombe County will work together to issue a Request for Proposal (RFP) to solicit proposals from area nonprofits interested in housing the Blue Horizons project.
Impact These decisions establish a new framework for the city’s approach to climate change and energy. The declaration of a climate emergency commits the city to specific emissions reduction goals and the development of a Climate Justice Plan by December 2020. The transition of the Energy Innovation Task Force to the Blue Horizons Community Council shifts the focus from preventing a specific power plant to a broader, community-led effort to achieve 100% renewable energy by 2042. The adjustments to fees for the Harrah’s Cherokee Center and 8 River Arts Place aim to make event operations financially sustainable, while the State Street project and pedestrian phasing improvements will enhance safety and accessibility in key areas of the city.
Meeting Video & Transcript