City Council Agenda Briefing – April 18, 2024
April 18, 2024 at 10:50 AM
- 2 h 16 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Agenda Briefing Recap: April 18, 2024
The City of Asheville City Council held an agenda briefing work session on April 18, 2024. This session was dedicated to reviewing upcoming agenda items, providing updates on the city’s budget and transit systems, and discussing recent survey data. No formal votes were taken during this meeting, as it served as a preparatory session for future council actions.
Upcoming Agenda and Consent Items Staff reviewed the agenda for the April 23, 2024, regular council meeting, which includes three proclamations for April and May, including Less Plastic Asheville Month and National Police Week. The consent agenda for that date includes authorization to demolish an unsafe single-family dwelling at 158 South French Broad, where the owner has been unresponsive for over a year. Additional consent items involve police department grants, facility contract amendments reflecting better-than-expected sales, a change order for the Nasty Branch Greenway design, a lease to move Fire Department administrative functions to the Jackson Building, and a change order for the Vance Monument demolition contract. New business for April 23 includes the allocation of just over $4.6 million from the Housing Trust Fund to five projects producing 197 affordable units, and a resolution for strategic partnership grants focused on low-to-moderate income youth. Public hearings are scheduled for two zoning amendment petitions, which staff recommended denying due to misalignment with the "Missing Middle Housing Study," and for the downtown Business Improvement District (BID), where no vote is expected until May 14 and June 11.
Budget and Community Survey Updates The council received an update on the budget process, noting that compensation and benefits comprise over 60% of the total budget. Council members debated the balance between equitable pay across all departments and the specific retention challenges in public safety. Mayor Esther Manheimer noted that the Fire Department’s pay proposal might trigger a review of compensation across other departments, while Councilwoman Maggie Ullman encouraged the body to avoid pitting public safety against other departments. Councilwoman Kim Roney referenced a recommendation from Just Economics that provided a "missing middle" for compensation. Staff confirmed that a memo responding to council questions from the April 9 work session would be sent by Monday, with council feedback requested by the following Friday to finalize the City Manager’s proposed budget for May 14.
Director of Communications & Public Engagement Dawa Hitch presented findings from the fifth National Community Survey. The data indicated that while residents report high quality of life in education, arts, and culture, affordability, housing, safety, and transportation remain top concerns. Specifically, 87% of residents rated affordable housing development as essential or important. The city ranks 54th out of 60 tourism-based economies in equitable, affordable housing and stability. Staff agreed to include the link to the full report in the follow-up report to council.
Transit System Financial Sustainability A significant portion of the meeting focused on the financial status of American River Transit (ART). Staff reported that while ridership is up 15% year-over-year, the system operates at a deficit and relies on ARPA funds to break even, with federal formula funds covering only 15–20% of costs. Council members discussed the need for diverse, long-term revenue sources, with Councilwoman Kim Roney using a "leaky boat" analogy to describe the current reliance on the parking fund. Councilwoman Sage Turner expressed concern that without a broader assessment, the city might face dramatic service cuts.
Staff recommended repurposing $300,000 previously budgeted for a regional master plan—which the county declined to fund—to conduct a city-specific Comprehensive Operations and Financial Assessment (COA). Assistant City Manager Rachel Wood clarified that these funds are intended for an operational assessment to evaluate post-COVID ridership patterns and route efficiency, and are not to be used for route extensions such as the S3 or S6. Councilwoman Maggie Ullman stated that the city needs to articulate its goals for the assessment as soon as possible to make the process more expeditious. Staff confirmed they would draft solicitations for the transit operations contract, the COA, and ArtPlace tasks, all of which will require City Council approval.
Follow-ups and Next Steps Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the session. Staff from Finance will provide a memo responding to council questions from the April 9 budget work session by the close of business on Monday and will finalize the City Manager’s proposed budget numbers by May 3. Staff member Deborah Campbell agreed to make outreach to the Asheville Fire Department regarding their budget proposal. Staff from Communications will include the link to the National Community Survey report in the follow-up report. Assistant City Manager Rachel Wood will work with the contractor to refine the COA scope and return to Council with more prescriptive goals in preparation for the May 9 agenda briefing. Staff from Transit will provide additional information on the triennial review of federal fund spending by sub-recipients. Councilwoman Sage Turner expressed willingness to facilitate another meeting between the developer and neighborhood representatives for the Newhall Creek Road project before the June 11 hearing and stated she is meeting with the Chamber of Commerce regarding the BID proposal.
The council agreed to revisit the transit topic, specifically facility needs and ArtPlace project updates, at the May 9 meeting. The May 14 meeting will feature the first reading of the downtown BID ordinance and the presentation of the City Manager’s proposed budget. The June 11 meeting is scheduled for the second reading of the BID ordinance, budget adoption, and a continued hearing for the Newhall Creek Road conditional zoning. No public comment was taken during this agenda briefing work session.
Meeting Video & Transcript