Skip to main content

African American Heritage Commission – December 14, 2023

December 14, 2023 at 4:30 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Jul 13 meetingNext: Apr 11, 2024 meeting
  • 1 h 13 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

African American Heritage Commission Meeting Recap: December 14, 2023

The African American Heritage Commission of the City of Asheville convened on December 14, 2023, to address the future structure and sustainability of the body. The primary focus of the meeting was a proposal to transition the Commission from a City-County advisory body to an advisory committee under the YMI Cultural Center (also referred to as the Weimar Cultural Center). In addition to this central discussion, the Commission reviewed staff updates, discussed the upcoming annual report, and addressed support for the Community Reparations Commission.

The only formal vote taken at the meeting was the approval of the minutes from the July 13, 2023 meeting. A motion to approve these minutes was made by Tiffany DeBello and seconded by Michael Hayes. A roll call vote was conducted, and the motion passed unanimously, with all voting members voting "Aye." No other decisions or votes were recorded during the session.

The most significant discussion centered on the proposed transition to the YMI Cultural Center. Brenda Mills, Director of Equity and Inclusion, presented the rationale for the change, noting that the Equity and Inclusion Department lacks the capacity to support the Commission’s specific mission regarding African American history, arts, and culture. She explained that the YMI is currently undergoing a $6.4 million restoration and is seeking an executive director. Mills stated that the transition would allow the Commission to access broader funding opportunities and community partnerships while retaining staff representation from the City and County. She emphasized, "The commission’s mission and purpose would greatly benefit from collaboration with like-minded entities that would assist in projects, programs, and initiatives to support the recognition of African American history, culture, and arts."

Commission members provided varied feedback on the proposal, weighing its potential benefits against concerns about governance and independence. Chair Aaron Griffin expressed a desire for progress, stating, "I was really hoping that we could accomplish a lot... but, you know, it seemed like it's been a lot of a lot of obstacles... I just want to see progress. This is home." Vice Chair Michael Hayes viewed the transition positively, noting, "The one thing that I believe we have been... lacking is... real presence in the community... I just feel that an opportunity to still work with the city and the county, but not be under the city and the county... I think it's a grand idea." However, Member Tiffany DeBello raised concerns about potential conflicts of interest, asking, "My first reaction was, no... My concern is that as a YMI board member, would that have a conflict of interest for me to sit as an advisory and then still hold my position as secretary for the board?" She also expressed concern about the City stepping back from equity efforts but remained "optimistic and hopeful." Member Diamond Couch questioned the specific outcomes of the new structure, asking, "If not an advising body, what would the structure be? Whose outcomes are we advancing and is it capacity building? Is that events and outreach? What exactly are the outcomes that we're aiming for and measuring for our community?"

No vote was taken on the transition to the YMI Cultural Center, as the Chair and Staff clarified that the item was for discussion to gauge interest and gather feedback. Staff proposed that the Commission vote in January to approve or reject the transition, contingent on further discussions, a site tour of the YMI, and the development of a sustainable plan. Mills addressed the structural changes, stating, "You can name yourself whatever you want. You're now not a public board anymore... You could be African American Advisory Committee to the YMI and with certain rights and functions." She also assured members regarding support, saying, "We’ll get you all the training you need. That is not a problem."

Regarding the annual report, which is due on January 19, 2024, staff requested that members contribute content regarding their community engagement and meetings attended during the year. Mills noted the year's efforts, stating, "We didn’t move the world this year, but we did some really cool things and made some really cool decisions." The Commission also discussed the importance of supporting the Community Reparations Commission, which is seeking an extension of time from governing bodies to complete its work. Staff mentioned that a ribbon-cutting for the Black Cultural Heritage Trail was scheduled for the following day, December 15, in the River Arts District.

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Staff agreed to send an email by Monday with links to previous minutes and a "shell" of the annual report for members to populate. Members agreed to provide feedback on the annual report before the next meeting. Staff also agreed to schedule a tour of the YMI Cultural Center for the Chair and board members to see the restoration progress and hear the YMI’s vision. Additionally, staff agreed to compile a document answering members' questions regarding the transition, including details on funding, Memorandums of Understanding (MOUs), and training. The Commission agreed to meet virtually on the second Thursday in January to finalize the annual report and continue the discussion on the YMI transition.

There were no public comments from residents or members of the public during this meeting. The discussion consisted entirely of remarks by Commission members and staff. This meeting is significant for residents as it addresses the long-term viability and operational structure of the body dedicated to recognizing African American history, culture, and arts in Asheville. The potential transition to the YMI Cultural Center could alter how the Commission interacts with City and County governance and accesses resources for community initiatives.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches