Skip to main content

Noise Advisory Board – December 11, 2023

December 11, 2023 at 1:01 PM

  • 1 h 48 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Noise Advisory Board Meeting Recap: December 11, 2023

The City of Asheville’s Noise Advisory Board convened on December 11, 2023, to address ongoing noise concerns and review recent data. The primary agenda items included the approval of previous minutes, an update on noise data trends, a detailed discussion on vehicular noise in downtown Asheville, a review of recent decibel measurements, and planning for the board’s annual report and retreat.

The board’s only formal decision at this meeting was the approval of the minutes from the November board meeting. A motion to approve these minutes was made and seconded, and the vote was taken and approved. The meeting was subsequently adjourned without objection.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to discussing loud, modified vehicles in downtown Asheville. The Noise Administrator explained that the current "noise disturbance" standard is highly subjective, relying on officer discretion to determine if a vehicle is causing a disturbance. In response, a board member proposed reaching out to Asheville Police Department (APD) leadership to discuss the feasibility of targeted enforcement events, such as 90-minute operations on Friday and Saturday nights, and the use of signage for deterrence. Another board member suggested engaging the City Attorney to clarify the legal distinctions and fine structures between specific vehicle noise violations and general noise disturbances. Additionally, a board member offered to research ordinance language from other cities regarding modified mufflers and cruising limits to draft potential changes for the board’s review.

The board also reviewed recent sound level measurements taken at various locations, including the Asheville Beauty Academy and Rabbit Rabbit. The discussion focused on the technical differences between A-weighted (DBA) and C-weighted (DBC) decibel measurements. A board member explained that DBA attempts to capture the general human experience of sound, while DBC exaggerates low frequencies, often resulting in higher readings. This technical distinction sparked debate regarding how these metrics reflect actual stress on residents. One board member emphasized the need to understand the science behind DBC definitions to avoid internal disagreement, stating, "We have to come back with that science. Otherwise, we're just going to argue with each other." Another member argued that it is unreasonable to expect residents to purchase noise-canceling headphones to sleep, asserting that the sound source has a responsibility to mitigate noise levels.

No live public comments were received during the public comment period. However, staff noted that two emails regarding vehicular noise had been received and were referenced during the board’s discussion on that topic.

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. A board member agreed to research other cities' ordinances on vehicle noise to draft potential language. Another board member agreed to contact APD to discuss targeted enforcement and signage. Staff agreed to collate noise data from 2021–2023 into spreadsheets to provide a trend brief for the next session. Additionally, staff agreed to look into guidelines for holding a board retreat, and the chair stated they would send a scheduling poll to the board to find a date, ideally before the end of the year or in early January. A board member also requested access to the City’s response to a journalist’s inquiry about a gun range, and staff agreed to send those notes to the member.

This meeting highlights the board’s focus on balancing technical data with community impact, particularly regarding vehicle noise and the interpretation of decibel measurements. The discussions underscore the complexity of enforcing noise ordinances, where subjective standards and differing measurement methods create challenges for both enforcement and resident relief. The upcoming retreat and data analysis will likely shape the board’s approach to these issues in the coming year.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches