Skip to main content

Neighborhood Advisory Committee – November 27, 2023

November 27, 2023 at 6:01 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Earlier meetingNext: Mar 25, 2024 meeting
  • 2 h 7 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Neighborhood Advisory Committee Meeting Recap: November 27, 2023

The City of Asheville’s Neighborhood Advisory Committee (NAC) met on November 27, 2023, to review the draft 2023 Annual Report, receive updates on homelessness and housing, and discuss transit planning. The meeting included presentations from staff regarding the Continuum of Care restructuring, the newly released Missing Middle Housing Study, and changes to the city’s transit funding strategy.

Key Decisions The committee approved the minutes from the October 21, 2023 meeting. A motion was made and seconded, and the minutes were passed. The committee also voted to appoint Jaik Smith as the non-voting NAC liaison to the Metropolitan Mobility Task Force (MMTC). The motion was nominated, seconded, and passed. Additionally, staff confirmed that the committee will switch to an every-other-month meeting schedule starting in January, with working groups meeting in the off months. No formal vote was taken on the annual report, as it is scheduled for approval in January; however, the committee agreed on the general direction for the document.

Discussion Highlights Staff from the Homeless Strategy Division presented data on the point-in-time count and the restructuring of the Continuum of Care. The presenter emphasized that housing cost is the primary indicator of homelessness rates and clarified that the city’s role as a lead agency is to build collective solutions rather than hold unilateral power.

The Planning and Urban Development department presented the Missing Middle Housing Study, noting that two-thirds of current housing disallows missing middle housing types, such as fourplexes and eightplexes. The presenter stated that simply allowing more single-family homes will not address the housing shortage and that increased supply generally helps lower prices. When discussing the rollout of these zoning changes, Chair Bobbette Kilgore Mays noted that there are still areas requiring further discussion before the board will give a unanimous vote on related amendments.

Regarding transit, staff reported that the city is pivoting its $300,000 joint city-county transit plan funding because the county did not match the funds. Instead of a new master plan, the city will focus on tweaking the implementation of the existing 2018 Transit Master Plan to set a more realistic rollout schedule, as costs have changed significantly since 2018.

Community Input During the staff presentations, public commenters raised several concerns regarding the Missing Middle Housing Study. One public commenter asked if there is a requirement that units be sold to individual families rather than bought by investors for rental; the presenter responded that the city has no ability to set ownership requirements. Another public commenter asked about strategies to mitigate gentrification in vulnerable neighborhoods like Shiloh and whether those areas could be carved out of missing middle housing zones. The presenter stated that the community can collectively decide how to roll out zoning changes and that choosing to remain single-family is a housing strategy that may not be in the best financial interest of the community. A third public commenter suggested targeting already walkable neighborhoods, such as Bonford, for initial implementation, to which the presenter agreed, noting that the report identifies ideal locations that are already walkable.

Follow-ups Staff member Dawa Hitch agreed to include the 28 vendors (10 neighborhood organizations and 12 city departments) in the annual report’s description of the Festival of Neighborhoods. Hitch also agreed to include the neighborhood matching grants event in the annual report under the goal of strengthening neighborhood organizational development. Additionally, Hitch agreed to draft language for the annual report stating that the committee prioritized other goals in 2023 but is aware of the housing voucher opportunity and plans to share information in 2024. Hitch agreed to reach out to Thrive Asheville and the Reparations Office to see if they can be added to the NAC agenda for a future presentation. Furthermore, Hitch agreed to include the committee’s concerns about unintended consequences, such as fire service access and crime, in the annual report’s equity lens section, and to include the request for NAC participation in the holiday parade in the working group’s list of engagement ideas. Staff from the Homeless Strategy Division offered to support the committee in reading the missing middle housing study and displacement risk analysis.

Impact These discussions highlight the city’s ongoing efforts to address housing affordability and homelessness through data-driven strategies and community engagement. The shift in the NAC’s meeting schedule to every other month, with working groups meeting in the interim, aims to maintain consistent engagement while managing the committee’s workload. The upcoming presentation of the Missing Middle Housing Study to the Planning and Economic Development (PED) Subcommittee of Council in two weeks, and to the full Council on January 9, indicates that these housing policies are moving toward formal legislative consideration.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches