Housing and Community Development – November 27, 2023
November 27, 2023 at 1:30 PM
- 58 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Housing and Community Development Committee Recap: November 27, 2023
The Housing and Community Development Committee of the City of Asheville held a remote meeting on November 27, 2023, to review housing policies, funding requests, and grant applications. The committee addressed five agenda items, including the approval of previous minutes, updates to the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME application processes, revisions to the Housing Trust Fund (HTF) policy, a loan request for a specific development project, and a Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) application.
Key Decisions The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the October 17, 2023 meeting, with a vote of 3 Ayes and 0 Nays. The committee also voted unanimously (3 Ayes, 0 Nays) to recommend that the Asheville City Council approve the revised Housing Trust Fund policy. Additionally, the committee unanimously (3 Ayes, 0 Nays) recommended that City Council approve Commonwealth Development’s request for an additional $475,000 in HTF funding, bringing the total loan to $975,000 for the construction of 77 affordable apartments at the Fairhaven Summit project. Both the HTF policy revision and the Commonwealth Development loan are set to move to City Council for a final vote at their December meeting.
In contrast, the committee did not recommend approval for the Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) application submitted by Catalyst Capital Partners for a 281-unit apartment complex at 115 Fairview Road. The motion to recommend an 18-year grant totaling $4.56 million failed with a vote of 1 Aye and 2 Nays. This item will continue to City Council with a 2-1 "Nay" recommendation from the committee.
Discussion Highlights Staff provided an overview of the upcoming annual application cycle for CDBG and HOME programs, highlighting the implementation of new "Neighborly" software, relaxed audit requirements, and a shift to video presentations. Dennis Newbern, Community Development Manager, noted that the new software enhances transparency by allowing the community to see applications and understand the committee's role in evaluation.
Regarding the Fairhaven Summit project, Sean Brady of Commonwealth Development explained the financial pressures on the project, stating, "Every 0.1% in the 10 year treasury when it goes up is $100,000 less in loan proceeds." Chair Sage Turner asked staff to provide data on how much of the $15 million allocated to the HTF between 2001 and 2019 has actually returned to the city in interest or payback.
The debate on the Fairview Road LUIG application centered on affordability thresholds. Councilwoman Mosley voted "No," stating, "In light of [the presenter's] presentation regarding the 80% AMI and its discriminatory effects, it's very difficult for me to vote to use taxpayer dollars to further that policy." Councilwoman Smith also voted "No," explaining, "My children went to Oakley Elementary School and there is a great need for more deeply affordable housing in that area. So it's not fitting for that area at this percentage of affordability." The third member voted "Aye" but noted they were not in full agreement with the policy implications.
Community Input One resident, who is a government relations and grants manager for Asheville Area Habitat for Humanity, spoke during public comment. The commenter expressed support for policies that prevent source of income discrimination and increase rental assistance acceptance in government-funded projects. They cited a 2021 Western North Carolina Housing Needs Assessment stating that 965 housing vouchers in Buncombe County go unused each year, arguing that source of income discrimination compounds the housing crisis. No member or staff member responded to the specific content of the comment; the Chair thanked the caller and closed the public comment period.
Follow-ups Staff member Dennis Newbern stated he is available on demand prior to the opening of the CDBG application process on January 3 to answer questions from organizations. Staff member Sasha Vartunsky committed to including strengthened fair housing language in the HTF policy document when it goes to Council. Additionally, Sasha Vartunsky agreed to send the developer, Catalyst Capital Partners, the specific legal language regarding "set-aside" units with a time limit. The developer’s representative, Derek Allen, agreed to work with staff to incorporate this language before the item goes to Council.
Impact These decisions affect how the city allocates federal and local funds for affordable housing. The approval of the revised HTF policy and the additional loan for Fairhaven Summit will proceed to City Council for final approval, potentially impacting the availability of affordable units and the terms of future housing loans. The rejection of the LUIG for the Fairview Road project signals a committee preference for deeper affordability levels in specific neighborhoods, which will be weighed by City Council as they consider the application. The shift to new software for CDBG and HOME applications aims to increase transparency in how the city distributes community development funds.
Meeting Video & Transcript