Transit Committee – November 21, 2023
November 21, 2023 at 5:00 PM
- 2 h 11 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
The Transit Committee approved the minutes from the November 21, 2023 meeting and accepted the minutes from the August 15, 2023 meeting for approval. In both instances, a motion was made and seconded, followed by a vote in which Bill Loftus, Colin Kenton, and Brandon Oliver voted in favor. The committee also voted to accept the recommendation to move an applicant’s application forward to the Multimodal Transportation Commission (MMTC) for a final vote. No formal vote was taken to establish a working group; instead, the committee agreed to take the matter offline to clarify legal and procedural requirements with the Clerk’s office before any official formation.
Discussion Highlights
The primary portion of the meeting featured a staff presentation by Jessica Morris, Assistant Director of Transportation, covering two major projects: the pivot of the City-County Joint Transit Plan into a Comprehensive Operations Analysis and the development of the "ArtPlace" transit center. Morris explained that the shift in planning focus was driven by financial sustainability concerns, noting, "We had to use ARPA funds the last two years to balance the transit fund... using, having to tap into one-time stimulus dollars is not a good thing for future financial sustainability. So it's clear to me that we need to have different and new and dedicated revenue sources." Regarding the ArtPlace project, Morris clarified its priorities, stating, "To me, the primary purpose is a new, bigger transit center. And then the affordable housing layer, if you will, is also important, but it is secondary to the primary purpose of the project, which is transit center."
Chair Harvey Harrell provided context on the committee’s role, stating, "We do not set or change routes, control Asheville's transit budget, or have authority over staff, drivers, or the management company. We are a group of citizens like you who are here to ensure community concerns are taken into consideration when setting public transit policy." The committee also discussed the formation of a working group to prepare for the upcoming MMTC retreat. Member Bill Loftus stated, "The object, our immediate objective is to be able to present to the MMTC retreat in this winter about what's going on in transit and get them really engaged and up to speed on transit because, I mean, transit's complicated, y'all."
Operational updates included a discussion on a pedestrian accident, new bus deliveries, and rider experiences regarding app functionality and stop accessibility. Member Colin Kenton raised concerns about a specific bus stop on Route N1, noting, "I question if ridership isn't very high because it's almost an impossible stop to stand at because it's too steep. ADA is not a question here because it's... too steep for most people just to stand on." Additionally, Chair Harvey Harrell reported an incident involving a part-time driver who refused to pull up to a stop and cursed at a passenger. Harrell stated, "I informed LaShawn of those actions on his part... I tried to take his picture and he was one of our part-time drivers and he proceeded just like about to get up out of his seat and come at me. And he said I couldn't take his picture and he cursed me as well."
Follow-ups
Jessica Morris, Assistant Director of Transportation, agreed to send the presentation materials to committee members. She also agreed to check with Sarah Gross, Deputy Clerk, regarding the rules for forming a working group or subcommittee, including Bill Loftus in that communication. Additionally, Morris agreed to look up revenue trends comparing the current fiscal year to one year ago to answer questions about ridership and farebox recovery. Staff member LaShawn Abraham agreed to pass information regarding sidewalk ADA compliance issues to Jessica Morris. Member Bill Loftus stated he would proceed with the working group concept with three members—himself, Joe Chesler, and Elise Little—until further legal clarification is received, though he expressed concern about the timeline if formal approval is required.
Impact
These discussions highlight the City’s efforts to address long-term financial sustainability for public transit by seeking dedicated revenue sources rather than relying on one-time stimulus funds. The focus on the ArtPlace project underscores a priority to expand transit infrastructure, specifically a larger transit center, while also considering affordable housing. The committee’s attention to specific operational issues, such as the accessibility of steep bus stops and driver conduct, reflects an ongoing effort to improve the safety and usability of the transit system for residents.
Meeting Video & Transcript