Neighborhood Advisory Committee – October 23, 2023
October 23, 2023 at 6:00 PM
- 1 h 38 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Neighborhood Advisory Committee Meeting Recap: October 23, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Neighborhood Advisory Committee (NAC) met on October 23, 2023, to review two proposed amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) submitted by citizen petitioner Barry Bialik. The proposals concerned "Cottage Clusters" and "Flag Lots." The Cottage Cluster amendment sought to reduce the minimum number of dwelling units from five to two, remove the 200-foot buffer between clusters, and eliminate the requirement for orientation toward the primary street. The Flag Lot amendment proposed modifications to regulations for parcels with no street frontage. The committee also approved the minutes from the previous September meeting by unanimous vote.
City staff, represented by Stephanie Monson Dahl, Director of Planning & Urban Design, presented technical details for both proposals. Staff generally supported the Cottage Cluster amendment for its potential to increase housing supply but noted they had not yet analyzed community-wide impacts in the context of the upcoming "Missing Middle Housing" report. Regarding the Flag Lot proposal, staff acknowledged potential negative impacts on lower-wealth communities due to the cost of subdivision. Petitioner Barry Bialik, a developer and former chair of the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, argued that current zoning rules are too restrictive, making it difficult to build affordable workforce housing. He stated that reducing the minimum units for cottage clusters to two simplifies the process and reduces infrastructure costs, emphasizing his goal to create tools for homeowners to build for family or sale.
The committee engaged in significant public comment periods, both initially and after the presentations. During the initial period, a public commenter representing the Shiloh Community Association expressed concern that flag lots would lead to larger, more expensive homes, hurting affordability. Another public commenter, representing the same association, read a letter stating the association does not support zoning changes for Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) or backyard housing, feeling their neighborhood is targeted for development. A public commenter who is the President of the Coalition of Actual Neighborhoods (CAN) urged the NAC to take a comprehensive look at the UDO changes and recommended delaying the Cottage Cluster amendments to avoid piecemeal changes. A public commenter who is the Interim Vice President for Government Relations for CAN reiterated the organization’s position to delay action on both amendments until the Missing Middle Housing report is issued, arguing that reducing minimum units could eliminate up to 13 units of potential affordable housing per project.
In the reopened public comment period, a public commenter from the Shiloh Community Association stated that the neighborhood is already zoned RS-8 and agreed with the suggestion that it should be rezoned to RS-4 to protect its character. In response, a member asked why the commenter did not propose this to City Council directly; the commenter replied that she was proposing it now and insisted the neighborhood should be RS-4. Other public commenters raised concerns about the $5,000 cost of surveying lots for flag lots, traffic and infrastructure capacity in narrow roads, and the targeting of legacy neighborhoods for land acquisition. One public commenter expressed frustration that the city is targeting neighborhoods where land is cheaper, comparing the situation to past issues in other areas, and stated that the current proposals feel like a repeat of history where majority Black communities are targeted for development.
The committee voted on a motion to recommend that the City Council postpone the Cottage Cluster amendment. A member proposed an amendment to the motion, stating that the recommendation should be to incorporate both the Cottage Cluster and Flag Lot proposals into the Missing Middle Housing Study to allow for comprehensive public input and analysis. Another member clarified that their intent was to align the Cottage Cluster vote with the Flag Lot delay date to allow for neighborhood engagement. The motion to recommend postponing the Cottage Cluster amendment passed unanimously. The Flag Lot item had already been continued by City Council until January 23, 2024.
Staff provided responses to questions during the Q&A. When asked how the proposals ensure affordability, the Planning Director stated that neither proposal requires a certain percentage of affordable units, explaining that creating smaller homes may reduce costs through supply, but it is an indirect method. Regarding short-term rentals, the Planning Director noted that state laws limit local regulation, currently requiring a minimum 30-day rental period. Patrick Gilbert, Chair of the Urban Forestry Commission, stated that the Commission voted unanimously to urge the City Council to postpone action on the Flag Lot text amendments due to unknown effects on the urban tree canopy. He noted that the tree canopy preservation ordinance does not apply to flag lot construction.
Several follow-ups were committed to by staff and members. Stephanie Monson Dahl stated that staff would send a follow-up memo to NAC members regarding short-term rental regulations. She also stated that staff would share the highlights of the public comments from this meeting with City Council and that staff has requested to meet with the Legacy Neighborhood Coalition before January. A member stated that the NAC would continue to collaborate with the city on these issues and would recommend to City Council that the Cottage Cluster amendment be postponed, consistent with the vote taken.
This meeting highlights the ongoing tension between increasing housing supply and preserving neighborhood character, particularly in legacy and lower-wealth communities. The decision to recommend postponing the Cottage Cluster amendment to align with the Flag Lot timeline allows for further study and engagement through the Missing Middle Housing process. For residents, this means that immediate changes to these specific zoning rules are on hold, pending the broader analysis and public input that the committee and staff have agreed to facilitate.
Meeting Video & Transcript