Boards & Commissions Committee – November 14, 2023
November 14, 2023 at 12:59 PM
- 1 hlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The City of Asheville’s Boards and Commissions Committee held a remote meeting on November 14, 2023. The agenda focused on routine administrative approvals, proposed amendments to the Public Art and Cultural Commission ordinance, and a presentation of survey findings regarding the realignment of city boards and commissions.
Key Decisions
The committee unanimously approved the minutes from the previous month’s meeting, with a recorded vote of 3 ayes and 0 nays. The committee also voted to recommend the adoption of revisions to the ordinance governing the Public Art and Cultural Commission. This motion passed with a split vote of 2 ayes and 1 nay. The amendments, which include renaming the body to the "Culture Commission" and altering its membership composition, will now move to the full City Council for a final vote. Additionally, the committee unanimously voted (3 ayes, 0 nays) to recommend that the Realignment Working Group’s presentation and survey findings be shared with the full City Council.
Discussion Highlights
Staff from Planning and Urban Design presented proposed changes to the Public Art and Cultural Commission ordinance. Key modifications include renaming the body to the "Culture Commission," shifting staff support from Parks and Recreation to Planning and Urban Design, and expanding the definition of public art to include festivals and performances. Carly Stevenson, Urban Designer and Public Art Coordinator, explained that these changes are intended to "stitch together a group with diverse perspectives and expertise" and to tap into regional resources. A point of debate involved a designated seat for Explore Asheville. Staff member Steph noted that the commission aims to focus on publicly accessible events, distinguishing Explore Asheville from organizations with primarily ticketed events, such as the Symphony. Councilwoman Kim Rooney voted against the specific composition, expressing concern that appointing a specific organization could create conflicts of interest or exclude other significant arts groups, though she supported moving the item to the full Council.
The citizen-led Realignment Working Group presented survey results from over 350 board and commission members. Elise Marder, a member of the Working Group, highlighted a major theme of "powerlessness" among board members, citing a respondent who stated, "Serving on the board was a complete waste of time... We were reported to by staff, but had zero power to make recommendations or change anything." The survey data indicated a preference for in-person meetings among approximately 40% of respondents. When asked about the findings, Sarah Gross, Deputy City Clerk, confirmed that hybrid meeting infrastructure is "very much in the works," with the communications department purchasing equipment and working on staffing. The Vice Mayor (Chair) commended staff members Sarah Gross, Jerry Goldberg, and Marcus for conducting successful orientation sessions for new board members.
Follow-ups
Ben Woodley, Assistant City Manager, explicitly agreed to carry forward the committee’s recommendation regarding the Realignment Working Group presentation to the City Manager for her consideration. The Realignment Working Group stated they are developing a staff liaison survey, aiming to conclude it by the end of the year and report findings in late January or early February. They plan to return to the committee with integrated recommendations in March or April of next year. The Clerk’s Office notified the committee that the December meeting is canceled and the next meeting will be in January. They also announced they are contracting with new board management software to improve transparency regarding board membership and vacancies.
Impact
These decisions impact how the City of Asheville manages its cultural resources and its network of advisory bodies. The proposed ordinance amendments, if adopted by the full City Council, would restructure the Culture Commission to include designated seats for arts organizations and broaden its scope to include performances and festivals. The realignment survey findings provide the City Council with data on board member demographics, meeting format preferences, and perceptions of influence, which will inform future decisions on how city boards operate and interact with council.
Meeting Video & Transcript