Planning & Economic Development – November 13, 2023
November 13, 2023 at 3:59 PM
- 1 h 26 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee of the City of Asheville held a virtual meeting on November 13, 2023. The agenda focused on three primary informational items: an annual update from the Multimodal Transportation Commission (MMTC), an overview of the Patton Avenue Corridor Study, and a compliance review of Short-Term Vacation Rentals (STVRs). The only formal decision taken during the session was the approval of the minutes from the previous meeting.
Key Decisions
The committee’s sole recorded vote was to approve the minutes from the October 9, 2023 meeting. Councilwoman Sage Turner, Councilwoman Maggie Oman, and Chair Sandra Kilgore all voted in favor, resulting in a unanimous approval. No other motions, votes, or formal directives were recorded during the meeting. The discussions regarding the MMTC, the Patton Avenue study, and STVR compliance were informational in nature and did not result in binding decisions or formal instructions to staff at this time.
Discussion Highlights
Multimodal Transportation Commission Update Jack Eichelman, Chair of the MMTC, presented an update on the commission’s activities, noting that the Active Transportation Committee would be adopting the MMTC’s rules of procedure at their next meeting. Eichelman emphasized the commission’s broad scope, which includes advocacy for pedestrians, cyclists, individuals with disabilities, and freight delivery. He expressed a desire for commission members to listen thoughtfully to the connection between equity and transportation. Councilwoman Maggie Oman asked how the commission’s plans connect to the city’s inevitable growth, noting that without related transportation strategies, traffic could worsen. Stephanie Monson Dahl, Director of Planning & Urban Design, responded by acknowledging the importance of connecting these dots and stated that more comprehensive conversations would be brought to the committee soon.
Patton Avenue Corridor Study Fadila Sobiska, Urban Planner III, outlined the scope of the feasibility study, which aims to develop a long-term transportation, land use, and urban design plan for the section of Patton Avenue between the bridge and the easternmost part of PAC Square. Sobiska noted that the study will likely use the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) plan as a base, though the exact integration is still being determined. Councilwoman Sage Turner expressed hope that the study’s output would include actionable items rather than requiring additional years of planning.
Short-Term Vacation Rental (STVR) Compliance Mark Matheny, Director of Development Services, presented data showing that homestay permit requests and complaints are trending lower this year compared to previous years. He noted that 98% of enforcement is complaint-based and that tracking firm numbers has become difficult due to changes in permitting requirements. Councilwoman Sage Turner questioned the discrepancy between the city’s count of 1,037 units and the over 2,000 listings visible on third-party platforms, asking how the city reconciles this gap. She also suggested discussing saturation with other cities. Councilwoman Maggie Oman raised the possibility of revisiting zoning scenarios for STVRs and expressed interest in disincentivizing opportunistic investment in the town. Janice Ashley, Assistant City Attorney, clarified that while the city retains the ability to apply zoning requirements to this land use, it no longer has the ability to require annual permit renewals, a change resulting from a court case rather than legislation.
Community Input
There were no public comments recorded during the meeting. The chair noted that no one was in the speaking queue when the public comment period was opened.
Follow-Ups
Several staff members explicitly agreed to provide further information or take specific actions:
- Transit Planning: Jessica, a staff member in Transportation, stated that staff will present to the Multimodal Commission and Transit Committee regarding next steps for transit planning funding set aside in the FY24 budget. She indicated this presentation will likely be brought to the Planning & Economic Development Committee in either December or January.
- Patton Avenue Outreach: Fadila Sobiska confirmed that the first public meeting for the Patton Avenue corridor study is scheduled for the end of the month. Staff are working to place flyers in transit buses and physical signs on Patton Avenue to announce the project.
- STVR Data: Mark Matheny stated that he will either return to the committee or provide additional information regarding recent conversations with Buncombe County, as that data was not included in the initial presentation.
Impact
This meeting provided residents with updated information on three significant urban development areas. The STVR discussion highlighted ongoing challenges in tracking and regulating short-term rentals, with staff acknowledging data discrepancies and enforcement limitations. The Patton Avenue study signals a long-term planning effort for a major commercial corridor, with public engagement beginning at the end of the month. Finally, the MMTC update underscored the city’s focus on integrating transportation planning with broader goals of equity and growth management.
Meeting Video & Transcript