Board of Adjustment – October 23, 2023
October 23, 2023 at 2:00 PM
- 22 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Board of Adjustment Meeting Recap: October 23, 2023
The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment held a regular meeting on October 23, 2023. The primary agenda item was an evidentiary hearing regarding a request for a variance to the Aquatic Buffer Standards of the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO). Additionally, the Board addressed the review of minutes from its previous regular meeting.
Key Decisions The Board voted to approve the variance request for the proposed senior living project at 157 New Leicester Highway. The vote was unanimous among the members who voted, with Suzanne Vernon Godsey, Elliott Smith, Annette Wise, Kristina White, and Chair Paul Wilczynski all voting in favor. Separately, the review and adoption of the minutes from the September 25, 2023, meeting were postponed to the next meeting because they had not yet been posted.
Discussion Highlights Chair Paul Wilczynski opened the hearing by explaining that the Board is a quasi-judicial body governed by North Carolina General Statutes and the City’s UDO, noting that decisions must be based on competent material and substantial evidence. Rick Ledford, Senior Plans Reviewer, presented the technical details of the case, stating, "In the city of Asheville, our streams, we want a riparian buffer... It is measured 30 feet from the top of the bank on either side of the stream." He explained that because the project involves piping a stream, a 30-foot undisturbed buffer is required on either side. The petitioner proposed a "two-to-one" mitigation swap, providing twice the area of buffer protection in a different location along the stream to offset the impact, which Ledford confirmed is a requirement found in the UDO for variances.
Warren Sugg, P.E., representing Cohen Esri Development Group, presented the site design and clarified that the variance was necessary because the permanent impervious surface, including parking and sidewalks, fell within the buffer zone due to the stream piping and the need for ADA compliance. Sugg noted that the site’s steep topography prevented ADA access to the highway, requiring an "area of safe dispersal" for emergency evacuations to be located within the property, which conflicted with the buffer requirements. He stated, "I really would appreciate you guys' leniency on this. I think we've met well with staff and worked through this to the maximum extent practical." Sugg added that if the variance were denied, he would likely be out of compliance with the previously approved Conditional Zoning parking requirements, as further reducing parking would violate those conditions.
A board member, identified in the transcript context as likely Elliott Smith, commented on the design, saying, "I feel like they have tried really hard to get out of the stream buffer. It looks like they realigned a lot of their parking in order to get it out of the buffer and get the wall out of the buffer... So I think 572 square feet of impervious surface is probably as good as it's going to get."
Community Input There were no public comments. The Chair asked if anyone from the public would like to comment, and no one responded.
Follow-ups The Chair stated that the minutes from the September 25, 2023, meeting would be reviewed and adopted at the next meeting.
Impact This decision allows the proposed senior living project at 157 New Leicester Highway to proceed with a design that includes 144 parking spaces for 141 units and an ADA-compliant pedestrian connection. The approval permits a specific amount of impervious surface within the aquatic buffer zone, offset by a mitigation swap that provides additional buffer protection elsewhere along the stream. This variance resolves a conflict between the project's need for emergency evacuation space and accessibility compliance and the standard requirements for protecting the local stream.
Meeting Video & Transcript