Multimodal Transportation Commission – September 27, 2023
September 27, 2023 at 3:27 PM
- 1 h 43 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On September 27, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Multimodal Transportation Commission convened to address several key transportation issues, including state safety assessments, proposed speed limit changes, and updates on local bike lane projects. The meeting focused on balancing infrastructure improvements with community safety and equity, culminating in a unanimous vote to support a downtown bike lane project and the scheduling of a 2024 strategic planning retreat.
Key Decisions
The Commission made two primary decisions during the meeting. First, the body voted unanimously to recommend that City Council approve the College Patent Complete Streets Project, which includes a downtown bike lane. Kenny Armstrong moved for the recommendation, noting its alignment with city goals for accessibility and safety, and Joseph Chesler seconded the motion. All voting members cast "Aye" votes. Second, the Commission agreed to hold a two-day in-person strategic planning retreat in 2024, with sessions scheduled for January 19, 2024, and February 3, 2024. The Chair confirmed the dates by noting that no objections were raised.
Discussion Highlights
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the College Patent Complete Streets Project, where members debated the equity and safety implications of the proposed bike lane. Councilwoman Ullman shared a perspective from a Black business owner who expressed feeling threatened by the bike lane due to historical policing in unsafe areas. Joseph Barker echoed these concerns, stating that residents in low-income neighborhoods of color might view the project as an imposition rather than a benefit. Elise Marder cautioned against approaching the community with the assumption that the project is inherently good, warning that this perspective could harm the relationships the Commission is trying to build.
The Commission also reviewed eight proposed speed limit reductions on city and state roads, including Sand Hill Road, Amboy Road, and streets in the Biltmore Park neighborhood. This item was informational, as the City Traffic Engineer clarified that the proposals will go to City Council for approval, estimated for the October 24 agenda. Randy Warren questioned the logic of NCDOT speed signs that remain green up to 49 mph on Hendersonville Road, suggesting it implies NCDOT accepts speeds above the limit. He also noted that the City Traffic Engineer had initiated the speed limit review process without a formal approval from the Commission.
Regarding the Merriman Avenue bike lane, members discussed issues with the recently installed design. Randy Armstrong criticized NCDOT’s approach, stating that the agency is challenging to deal with and should install meaningful bike lanes before conducting evaluations. Bill Loftis added that he would not trust NCDOT to correct the design on its own without proper guidance from the Commission.
Follow-ups
Several staff and members agreed to specific follow-up actions. The NCDOT presenter agreed to share the link to the pedestrian and bicycle dashboard in the meeting chat. The City Traffic Engineer, Chris Cairns, agreed to check with NCDOT regarding whether the speed limit change on Elkwood Avenue continues past Hickory Street into the Woodfin area and will report back. He also stated he will get the speed limit changes on the City Council agenda targeting October 24 and will follow up on previously approved changes that have not yet been signed. Staff member Anna Sexton agreed to incorporate member feedback regarding the number of meetings and the wording of standing committees into a final draft of the Rules of Procedure for the October meeting. Additionally, Randy Armstrong stated he may formalize a recommendation for the next meeting to ask NCDOT to create a Complete Streets committee for the Merriman Avenue project and to use NACTO/MU GCD best practices to redesign the bike lane. The Chair agreed to send an email to members to confirm the retreat dates and times.
Impact
These decisions and discussions highlight the Commission's role in shaping the city's transportation infrastructure, particularly regarding how new projects affect different communities. The unanimous support for the College Patent project signals a push to move the downtown bike lane forward to City Council, while the detailed debate on equity suggests that future implementation may require significant community engagement to address safety concerns. The review of speed limits indicates a potential shift in traffic management on several local roads, pending City Council approval. Furthermore, the Commission’s intent to guide NCDOT on the Merriman Avenue redesign reflects a desire to ensure that state-funded projects meet local safety standards.
Meeting Video & Transcript