Skip to main content

Public Art and Cultural Commission – September 21, 2023

September 21, 2023 at 4:01 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Jul 20 meetingNext: Nov 16 meeting
  • 1 h 33 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The Public Art and Culture Commission of the City of Asheville held a hybrid virtual and in-person meeting on September 21, 2023. The primary focus of the session was the revision of the commission’s governing ordinance to accommodate new permanent seats and expanded responsibilities, alongside updates on the PAC Square Plaza visioning project.

Key Decisions

The commission took two formal votes during the meeting. First, the body voted to approve the minutes from the previous meeting. The motion passed with ayes from Allie McGee, Katie Cornell, Pat Kappes, Pete Perez, and Joanna Hagarty; Andrew Fletcher and Shirley Whitesides were not present for this specific vote.

Second, after extensive discussion and live editing of the document, the commission voted to recommend the amended ordinance to City Council. The motion, which stated that the amended ordinance be recommended to City Council for amendment, passed with ayes from Allie McGee, Katie Cornell, Andrew Fletcher, Pat Kappes, and Joanna Hagarty. Shirley Whitesides was not present, and Pete Perez had left the meeting prior to this vote. The specific changes adopted in the draft include:

  • Maintaining the commission size at nine members, with three designated as permanent seats for Arts AVL, Explore Asheville, and a local higher education institution with a designated arts program.
  • Updating the definition of public art to include performance in public space and events or festivals.
  • Changing the term "cultural" to "culture" in the commission’s name.
  • Removing language regarding historic markers from the immediate scope of the ordinance.
  • Clarifying term limits to align with City Board and Commission policies, allowing for reappointment subject to standard two or three-year limits.

Discussion Highlights

During the debate on the ordinance, members discussed the implications of creating permanent seats for partner organizations. Pete Perez emphasized the importance of selecting the right individuals for these roles, stating, "I think for whoever we put on more permanent, we really need to ensure that we've got the right person because it's not just the institution, but somebody that's got the decision-making authority... and be my only thought."

Regarding the higher education seat, Andrew Fletcher suggested a broader approach to future-proof the ordinance, noting, "If we want to future proof the ordinance, we may not need to restrict it that much and just stick to, you know, higher ed... that way, you know, if there was a great public arts program to be developed at one of our other local higher education institutions... we'd be able to use that without having to rewrite the ordinance."

The inclusion of special events and festivals in the definition of public art was also debated. Katie Cornell supported the change, observing, "Arts is placemaking as much as it, as a mural or things like that. So it's a pretty natural understanding for me." Conversely, Chair Joanna Hagarty expressed concern about the commission's capacity to handle historic markers, stating, "I worry about adding something that is lost in the system and needs a lot of support like that right now... I would worry about adding too much to the ordinance... to give us that time to kind of coalesce."

Staff also presented updates on the PAC Square project, which is funded by a Mellon Grant. A proposal was made to conduct an inventory and audit of existing markers, memorials, and public art in the plaza before proceeding with the buildable master plan. Katie Cornell highlighted the significance of this step, saying, "We've been trying to do this for a long time and this is a great way to get a small portion of it done and maybe build a model for doing a full asset inventory of our whole public art collection, which I feel is really important to have."

Community Input

There were no public comments recorded in the transcript. The Chair noted that there was no one on the line for public comment, and the meeting was adjourned immediately following the staff presentation on the PAC Square project.

Follow-ups

Staff member Stephanie Monson Dahl agreed to send out an email update regarding the PAC Square Plaza visioning and request input from commission members via email rather than holding a live discussion. She also stated that staff will return to the commission at the next meeting, or via email if something happens before then, with a proposal on how to structure the group responsible for the PAC Square asset inventory and audit. Additionally, staff requested that any members interested in helping develop the proposal for the inventory group email Carly, the Assistant City Clerk, to provide additional input. Chair Joanna Hagarty agreed to look into the status of the application packets for the upcoming appointment cycle, noting she had received a few emails but would need to verify the details.

Impact

This meeting resulted in a recommended amendment to the Public Art and Culture Commission ordinance, which will now go to City Council for final action. The changes expand the commission's scope to include performance art and festivals, formalize permanent seats for key cultural partners, and clarify term limits. By removing historic markers from the immediate ordinance scope, the commission aims to manage its workload while it coalesces. The decision to conduct an inventory of the PAC Square Plaza assets before building a master plan provides a structured approach to understanding the existing public art landscape in that specific area.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches