Planning & Economic Development – September 11, 2023
September 11, 2023 at 4:00 PM
- 1 h 2 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On September 11, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee held a remote meeting to address two primary agenda items: an update to the outdoor dining ordinance and a final review of the Fiscal Year 2024 work plan. The committee focused on establishing new standards for the use of public spaces, including sidewalks and on-street parking spaces referred to as "streeteries," as well as outlining upcoming policy priorities for the coming fiscal year.
Key Decisions
The committee voted unanimously to recommend that the full City Council adopt proposed text amendments to the outdoor dining ordinance, including updated fee structures and new program standards. Councilwoman Maggie Ullman made the motion, which was seconded by Councilwoman Sage Turner and passed with ayes from Councilwoman Ullman, Councilwoman Turner, and Chair Sandra Kilgore. No formal vote was taken on the FY2024 work plan, as it is considered a fluid document for internal planning; however, the committee discussed and agreed on the inclusion of specific upcoming topics, such as Short-Term Rental (STR) regulations and the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Chapter 7 update.
Discussion Highlights
During the discussion on the outdoor dining program, staff presented proposed changes that include charging fees per square foot. Chris Collins, Land Development Division Manager, explained that this fee structure encourages businesses to consider the amount of space they utilize, noting that businesses with small outdoor areas may pay less than those with very large areas. Dana Frankel, Downtown Project Manager, stated that while they do not anticipate a flood of businesses wanting to utilize parking spaces, the first year will be a time of learning for all parties. Chair Sandra Kilgore remarked that the program could "change the complexion of what Asheville really is" and grow into something special. Councilwoman Maggie Ullman emphasized that the downtown is designed for people rather than cars, and allowing businesses to convert parking spaces to dining areas lets them signal their needs to run healthy businesses.
Regarding the FY2024 work plan, the committee discussed the sequencing of various projects. Councilwoman Sage Turner suggested that housing-related items should come to both the Housing and Community Development committee and the Planning, Economic Development and Environment committee, as they will have a significant impact on planning. Councilwoman Ullman requested that the work plan explicitly distinguish between operational updates and strategic goal-setting discussions. In response to a question from Assistant City Manager Ben Woody regarding the preferred format for sharing work plan information, Councilwoman Turner suggested using a spreadsheet format similar to the Housing and Community Development committee’s, which includes timelines, involved committees, and outcome goals. Ben Woody noted that work plans are fluid documents and that adjustments may be made as the fiscal year progresses.
Follow-ups
Staff, including Dana Frankel and Chris Collins, stated they will present the proposed fee updates and new ordinance to the Policy, Finance, and HR Committee in October. Staff will also present the items to the full City Council on October 24, 2023. The application process for the new permits is scheduled to open on November 1, 2023, with a new permit period beginning in January 2024. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody committed to bringing an update on the Short-Term Rental regulatory environment to the committee in the next meeting or two, noting he would coordinate with Councilman Brad before finalizing the agenda item. Ben Woody also agreed that a strategy conversation regarding priorities for updating UDO Chapter 7 could be initiated in Q1 of the fiscal year (January–March) to allow time for scoping and budget requests. Additionally, staff will work to schedule annual updates from council-appointed advisory boards, including the French Broad River NPO.
Impact
This meeting establishes the next steps for the city’s outdoor dining program, which will transition to a new permit system starting in January 2024. The shift to a per-square-foot fee structure aims to align costs with the actual amount of public space businesses utilize. Furthermore, the committee has outlined its strategic priorities for the upcoming fiscal year, including the development of Short-Term Rental regulations and updates to the Unified Development Ordinance, which will shape future land use and housing policies in Asheville.
Meeting Video & Transcript