City Council Agenda Briefing – September 7, 2023
September 7, 2023 at 10:49 AM
- 1 h 28 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Agenda Briefing Recap: September 7, 2023
The City Council of Asheville held a virtual work session on September 7, 2023, to review the agenda for the upcoming business meeting scheduled for Tuesday, September 12, 2023. As is standard for agenda briefings, no public comment was taken during this informational session. The primary purpose of the meeting was to prepare council members for the decisions and presentations on the upcoming agenda, with no formal votes cast on any items.
Key Decisions and Procedural Adjustments While no formal votes were taken, the Council made two procedural clarifications regarding the September 12 agenda. First, the Council agreed to edit the language for Item B to explicitly specify that the after-hours phone answering contract is for the Water Department, ensuring 24/7 coverage for issues such as main breaks. Second, the Council noted a discrepancy in the agenda packet regarding the Policy, Finance, and Human Resources committee meeting time; they clarified that the meeting is scheduled for 10:00 AM, correcting the packet’s listing of 11:00 AM.
Pack Square Visioning Concept Plan Staff provided an overview of the completed planning process for the former Vance Monument site, known as the Pack Square Visioning Concept Plan. The plan focuses on accessibility, new amenities, addressing past harms, and connecting the plaza to the surrounding block. Staff reported that the Planning and Economic Development (PED) Committee and the Downtown Commission have both voted unanimously to recommend adoption. The Planning and Zoning Commission is scheduled to review the plan on September 14. Council will hear a presentation on September 12 and consider adoption on September 26.
Project 8 Spire and Conditional Zoning A significant portion of the discussion centered on Project 8 Spire, a major mixed-use development proposal at 1 Oak Street (the former First Baptist Church site) totaling approximately 1.1 million square feet across two phases. City Attorney Brad Branham clarified that the Council’s vote on September 12 is strictly on the zoning entitlement, stating, "Your decision on this particular item on the agenda will be purely the zoning question... we're not taking into consideration any future requests for entitlement or the financing portion of this particular development, only the development land entitlement itself." Branham also noted that in North Carolina, Community Benefit Agreements cannot be imposed as conditions of rezoning and would likely be voluntary. The proposal includes a condition that a minimum of 20% of residential units in each phase be affordable to those earning at or below 80% of Area Median Income for 20 years. Council Member Sage Turner commented, "This is a fabulous project... I just really want us to make sure we're getting it right on the front end and for the community to understand, like, this is really going to take a long time."
Short-Term Shelter Funding The Council reviewed a request to fund interim housing beds using American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds. The Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee (HIAC) recommends adding 43 new beds and preserving 45 existing beds at the Salvation Army, with a total cost of $1.75 million. The City proposes using $875,000 of City ARPA funds, while the County Commission has already approved the other half using County ARPA funds. The funding is for 15 months, with beds available starting October 1. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated, "This is obviously very expensive just to bring online these additional shelter beds... the HIAC will be creating a task force... to identify more permanent solution... hopefully have something before you all in time for next year so that we're not looking again next year at this emergency funding need."
Multimodal Transportation and College Street Bike Lane Council members discussed the upcoming resolution to reaffirm commitment to multimodal transportation and authorize staff to begin vendor selection for the College Street Bike Lane project, scheduled for a vote on October 10. Several members expressed concerns about the timing and impact on downtown businesses. Council Member Kim Roney said, "I'm hearing from a large group of folks in downtown that... the timing of the spike lane just doesn't seem as important... it's really like, is this really what we're worried about right now?" Council Member Sandra Kilgore added, "I just want to see if someone could sort of lay out to me the actual benefits to moving forward on the bike lanes at this particular time... because I can't really see the benefits outweighing the needs of the community." Council Member Maggie Ullman responded, "I think it's also important not to conflate our economic and safety concerns with bike lanes because we run 20 different departments... I am sensitive to how hard it is for downtown businesses right now, but we run a complex organization with lots of different functions."
Follow-Up Actions Several staff members and council members agreed to specific follow-up actions during the briefing. Regarding the Pack Square Plan, staff will provide follow-up materials regarding sidewalk plans for the corner near the Emma Community/Chicken Hill area. For Project 8 Spire, City Attorney Brad Branham agreed to work with Council members and the developer’s counsel to formulate a list of legally enforceable conditions before the September 12 hearing. Council Member Sage Turner stated she will email staff her notes from conversations with the developer regarding transportation plans. Staff member Ben Woody agreed to review the video of the briefing to ensure all technical questions are captured. Regarding shelter funding, staff member Rachel Wood agreed to follow up with the ARPA contract administrator and Emily Ball to ensure written compliance with the non-discrimination ordinance. For the bike lane project, staff member Rachel Wood agreed to include detailed maps of the bicycle network and the 17 parking spaces to be removed in the next agenda briefing packet, and staff will provide an update to the Downtown Commission in September. Mayor Esther Manheimer offered to arrange detailed meetings between staff and Council members/business owners to review the plan if desired.
Meeting Video & Transcript