Skip to main content

Downtown Commission – August 25, 2023

August 25, 2023 at 9:01 AM

  • 52 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Downtown Commission Meeting Recap: August 25, 2023

The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission met on August 25, 2023, to review the draft action minutes from its July 14, 2023 meeting, discuss the PAC Square Plaza Vision Plan, and receive updates on the outdoor dining program. The commission also addressed procedural concerns regarding a proposed hotel project and received reports on various downtown infrastructure and policy initiatives.

Key Decisions The commission approved the draft action minutes from the July 14, 2023 meeting, including a correction to a typo in a name. The commission voted to recommend that the City of Asheville adopt the PAC Square Plaza Visioning document. This recommendation will be forwarded to the Planning and Zoning Commission and City Council. No vote was taken on the proposed updates to the outdoor dining program, which was presented for discussion and feedback only.

Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on the PAC Square Plaza Vision Plan. Stephanie Monson-Dahl, Director of Planning & Urban Design, clarified that adopting the plan serves as a guiding document and historical record but does not commit the city to spending funds. She noted that having an adopted plan helps secure future grants. Regarding the outdoor dining program, staff presented proposed updates including new fee structures and expanded "streeterie" options. Dana Frankel of the Planning Department highlighted survey results indicating that residents value trees, shade, and unobstructed sidewalk space most highly. Chair Bryan Moffitt addressed concerns about interactions between buskers and outdoor dining spaces, stating that it is not an "either-or" situation as long as buskers follow noise ordinances and maintain required clear space.

The commission also discussed the procedural requirements for a proposed hotel project, specifically the timing of "community benefits" submissions. Members expressed concern that developers are not required to submit specific community benefits plans until the final Technical Review Committee or Certificate of Occupancy stage, rather than during the initial entitlement process. One member stated, "I'm actually having some heartburn over the fact that they don't even have to list their potential community benefits to get entitlement... I really think... that should be part of entitlement from P&Z." Staff explained that while benefits can shift throughout the process, it is beneficial to have an early idea. The group also reviewed the scoring matrix for entitlement, noting that displacing a business within the previous 24 months results in a negative score, and demolishing a historic structure results in a significant point deduction.

Community Input A public commenter, a resident near Patton Avenue, noted that living near the construction has been "tough" and that traffic has been "really hard." They expressed appreciation for the city’s adjustment of traffic lights at the Clingman-Patton Avenue intersection but highlighted the dysfunction of the Hilliard-Clingman Avenue intersection, requesting that it be prioritized. A staff member responded that the corridor study should be looking at that intersection. Another public commenter complimented the city’s online survey for the downtown public restroom, noting it was a "very low time commitment to fill out" compared to other lengthy surveys, and encouraged the city to continue using this approach. A staff member responded, "Great. Thank you."

Follow-ups Staff agreed to verify if the structure at the proposed hotel site is on the historic register or a local landmark to determine if the historic demolition penalty applies. A member stated they had made a note of the concern regarding the late submission of community benefits for future updates. Staff indicated they will return with updates on the downtown public restroom project in October, based on input and further site analysis. The Chair stated that the 22 Carter Street project is scheduled for a special meeting on the 31st, dependent on the applicant’s review of a two-story issue. A council member stated they would email the city attorney regarding an LLC and master concept and forward the response to the commission.

Impact The adoption of the PAC Square Plaza Vision Plan provides a guiding framework for the central public space, which may aid in securing future grant funding. The discussion on the hotel project highlights ongoing tensions regarding the timing of community benefits disclosures in the development approval process. Updates on the outdoor dining program and bike lanes reflect the city's ongoing efforts to balance commercial activity, pedestrian safety, and infrastructure improvements in the downtown core.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches