Skip to main content

Multimodal Transportation Commission – August 23, 2023

August 23, 2023 at 3:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Jun 28 meetingNext: Sep 12 meeting
  • 2 h 6 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Multimodal Transportation Commission Meeting Recap: August 23, 2023

The City of Asheville’s Multimodal Transportation Commission convened on August 23, 2023, to review right-of-way closures, update the outdoor dining program, and initiate a new corridor study. The meeting began with the unanimous approval of the previous meeting’s minutes and the current agenda. The commission also introduced new member Mike Zukoski, with Chair Jack Igelman noting, "It is amazing the level of skill on this commission. It is really great."

Key Decisions The commission voted on several significant items. They unanimously recommended that City Council approve the closure of a small triangle adjacent to 100 Craven Street. However, regarding a request to close an unopened right-of-way between Sulphur Springs Road and Lane Avenue near Lucy S. Herring Elementary School, the motion to recommend City Council deny the request until further information is provided passed 5-2. The ayes were Randy Warren, Joseph Chesler, Leanna Joyner, Mike Zukoski, and Jack Igelman; the nays were Kenny Armstrong and Elyse Marder. In response to concerns about the current process, the commission unanimously voted to instruct the city to perform a comprehensive study of underutilized rights-of-way to determine opportunities for enhanced connectivity. Additionally, the commission unanimously endorsed the continuation and further development of the outdoor dining program and unanimously appointed Joseph Chesler and Mike Zukoski to the Patton Avenue Corridor Study steering committee. Finally, the commission unanimously voted to thank and excuse Randy Warren as Vice Chair and appoint Kenny Armstrong as the new Vice Chair.

Discussion Highlights A major portion of the meeting focused on a presentation regarding updates to the outdoor dining ordinance, which included new fees, sidewalk clearance standards, and the transition of temporary "streeteries" to a permanent program. Member Randy Warren commented on the program's success, stating, "This is an example that if people just take a step back and look at how well a program like this works... we can change the infrastructure of downtown and it'll benefit people without having all the catastrophic... the world won't end."

During the review of the Sulphur Springs/Lane Avenue right-of-way closure, members raised concerns about a retaining wall built within the right-of-way and the potential for private benefit from public land. Joseph Chesler expressed concern that the Technical Review Committee’s analysis was "lackluster." Mike Zukoski asked if the city could charge fair market value for the land or assess it for taxes; staff responded that legal advises they cannot sell the land but that property owners will pay higher taxes on the increased parcel size. Staff Jessica Morris noted a procedural limitation, stating, "One of the other problems I guess here is that the applicant can proceed to council with or without positive recommendation from multimodal. So as an advisory body... if you make a recommendation not to approve... the applicant wishes to proceed, despite that negative recommendation... they can do so." Kenny Armstrong added, "I feel like this is such a reactive process. And these right of ways have been there for 100 plus years... if we can, you know, get this study kind of done... then they can be prioritized... that way, when somebody does start this process of relinquishing it, we kind of already have a background on it and a prioritization."

Regarding the Patton Avenue Corridor Study, Council Liaison Maggie Ullman emphasized the importance of the project, stating, "This is such a key corridor, especially as DOT is doing their work. We need really smart vision here... It is so easy for people to revert to scarcity mindset now. And we like, this is a real, real powerful potential."

Community Input A written public comment was submitted arguing that the 2014 traffic calming policy is outdated, the 11-step process is burdensome, options are limited to speed bumps and cushions, and there is a lack of transparency. In response, Randy Warren stated, "I think it raises great points... I don't think we do a good job of traffic calming and responding to requests and having creative solutions." Elyse Marder noted that the current policy’s limited options are often disqualified by Asheville’s topography and supported exploring a broader "toolbox." Leanna Joyner asked staff for their perspective on whether the current process is efficient and fair. Staff member Jessica Morris (Planning & Urban Design) responded, "We as staff really do want to update the policy and agree with much of what has been said. The current policy is, in our opinion, outdated, too limited in options. It's too onerous and time-consuming for residents and for staff." She noted that staff capacity is the primary challenge and that they have requested funding for three years to hire additional staff to handle the volume of complaints.

Follow-ups Several staff members and members agreed to specific follow-up actions. Jessica Morris agreed to provide a "brief situation analysis or briefing paper" for a future agenda item to help the commission understand the current state of the traffic calming process and resource gaps. She also stated she would "talk to DFB [Development Services] about what that looks like" regarding the retaining wall in the right-of-way and determine the city's authority to address it. Additionally, Jessica Morris agreed to "reach out to NEGL [Neighborhoods] again and ask them what their perspective is" on making existing public rights-of-way more visibly clear with signage. Dana Frankel stated she would "take that back to our design team as an idea" regarding requiring or recommending bicycle parking in buffer spaces adjacent to streetery establishments. Chair Jack Igelman stated he would "reach out to folks to see if we can look at scheduling a retreat sometime this fall."

Impact These decisions impact residents by establishing a more proactive approach to public land use and downtown infrastructure. The comprehensive study of underutilized rights-of-way aims to move away from a reactive process, ensuring that when land is relinquished, there is already a prioritized background for its use. The endorsement of the outdoor dining program signals a commitment to maintaining flexible downtown spaces, while the new Vice Chair appointment ensures continuity in the commission’s leadership. The upcoming briefing on traffic calming will help the commission address resident concerns about the efficiency and options available in the current policy.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches