Reparations Commission – August 21, 2023
August 21, 2023 at 5:56 PM
- 2 h 27 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The City of Asheville Reparations Commission held a meeting on August 21, 2023. The primary focus of the evening was a series of presentations by representatives of legacy neighborhoods and community organizations, followed by a review of the project timeline, an introduction to the C-SOM audit firm, and a public comment period.
Key Decisions
The Commission took several procedural actions during the meeting. A motion was made to add a 15-minute open conversation period to the agenda, to be held after the legacy neighborhood presentations; the motion was seconded and passed unanimously. The Commission also approved the minutes from the June 12th meeting and the recent retreat unanimously. Additionally, the Chair asked if members were willing to extend the meeting by 15–20 minutes to accommodate the audit presentation; members raised their hands to indicate they could stay, and the meeting was extended. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn.
Discussion Highlights
Representatives from several legacy neighborhoods presented on their communities' histories and current needs. Renee White, President of the East End Valley Street Neighborhood Association, discussed efforts to combat gentrification and outlined a vision for reparative justice that includes black economic and generational wealth, affordable housing, and the preservation of historic sites. Sophie Dixon, President of the Shiloh Community Association, explained that the Legacy Neighborhood Coalition seeks to formalize a Legacy Neighborhood Commission to work with city and county governments to prevent displacement. Bernard Oliofant spoke on behalf of the Northside and Heart of Chestnut communities, noting that the Heart of Chestnut will partner with East End to develop an economic and training center. Roy Harris presented on the Southside, highlighting local assets and the area’s history of redlining and urban renewal. Representatives from Stumptown requested that the city pause the lease renewal for the Montfort Park Players/Robertson Amphitheater pending recommendations from the Commission and that 22 city-owned properties in Stumptown be included in the harm study. Monique Pierre, President and CEO of the Housing Authority of the City of Asheville, discussed plans to pursue Choice Neighborhoods grants, utilize housing vouchers for homeownership, and create a one-stop shop for economic advancement at the Eddington Center.
The project manager reviewed the updated timeline, noting that the final report is targeted for submission by April 2024, with a review period for recommendations from August 11 to September 15. Several Commission members expressed concern that this deadline is too rigid given the complexity of the work and the pending audit results. One member stated, "It feels like the timeline, somebody said, okay, you'll be finished at this date. That didn't take into consideration whether or not we would actually be at a point that we had accomplished what we believed to be a reasonable goal." Another member suggested that the timeline should be developed in collaboration with community members.
Dr. Adrian Carter of the Carter Development Group presented the methodology for the C-SOM audit, which will assess specific metrics in city and county government departments using both quantitative data and qualitative focus groups. The firm will use a harm scale to determine the level of disparity and provide recommendations, with the final report expected by February 2024. The Chair distributed the "Reparations Accountability Task Force Recommendation" and Housing IFA information, urging members to review these materials.
Community Input
Four residents provided comments during the public comment period. One resident expressed support for reparations, stating they are "due," and encouraged white residents to have intimate conversations with friends, family, and business associates to ensure they are comfortable with the idea before the Commission makes recommendations to City Council. Another resident discussed the "integrity of the reparations process," arguing that the community has been "destroyed" and trust eroded. This commenter advised the Commission to "choose your own attorney" rather than relying on the City’s attorney, suggesting the City might "dilute, manipulate, undermine, or circumvent" the laws the Commission seeks to change. A third resident presented a document from Judicial Watch regarding a federal civil rights lawsuit settled by the City of Asheville involving a scholarship program and asked how this prior lawsuit would impact the Commission’s current recommendations. This commenter also stated that the Commission should have hired its own attorney/consultant to ensure Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests were properly handled. Members did not respond to the specific content of these comments.
Follow-ups
The Chair stated that she would propose sending out draft agendas to the commission team as soon as they are available to allow for member input. The project manager stated she would speak with a member offline regarding the status of outstanding data requests. The project manager asked all presenters to share any slides or written materials with her to be entered into the meeting record. Members were asked to review the reparations accountability task force recommendation and the Housing IFA information in their packets and send comments, edits, or concerns to the Commission prior to the next meeting. Monique Pierre provided her email address and encouraged residents to reach out with concerns or questions.
Impact
This meeting advanced the Reparations Commission’s work by gathering direct input from legacy neighborhood leaders and introducing the methodology for the upcoming C-SOM audit. The discussions highlighted the urgency of addressing displacement and economic disparity in these communities, while the debate over the project timeline underscored the tension between rigid deadlines and the complex, community-driven nature of the reparations process. The Commission’s next steps involve reviewing the accountability task force recommendations and housing interim financial assistance information, as well as incorporating the findings of the C-SOM audit, which is expected in February 2024, into their final report targeted for April 2024.
Meeting Video & Transcript