Skip to main content

Environment & Safety Committee – June 27, 2023

June 27, 2023 at 11:00 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: May 23 meetingNext: Jul 25 meeting
  • 1 h 4 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Environment and Safety Committee Recap: June 27, 2023

The City of Asheville’s Environment and Safety Committee held a remote meeting on June 27, 2023, chaired by Vice Mayor Maggie Ullman. The agenda focused on public safety initiatives, noise management, and waste handling in the downtown area. The committee reviewed the minutes from the previous meeting, heard recommendations from the Noise Advisory Board, and received an update on the 60-day Downtown Safety Initiative.

Key Decisions The only formal vote taken during the meeting was to approve the minutes from the May 23, 2023 meeting. A motion was made and seconded, and the motion passed with one "Aye" recorded and no "Nays." No formal votes were taken on the Noise Advisory Board recommendations or the Downtown Safety Initiative updates; these items were discussed and integrated into existing city plans rather than voted on as standalone resolutions.

Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Noise Advisory Board’s recommendations regarding vehicular noise and waste hauler timing. The Board’s Chair and Vice Chair presented their findings, noting that they were not requesting extensive new resources for law enforcement. In response, City Manager Deborah Campbell stated that the city is fortunate to have existing initiatives that can address these issues without creating separate programs. She confirmed that the vehicular noise recommendation would be folded into the implementation, education, and outreach efforts of the Downtown Safety Initiative. Additionally, Assistant City Manager Ben Woody confirmed that the City Council allocated $350,000 in the upcoming budget for a Solid Waste Master Plan. Solid Waste Division Manager Jess Foster explained that this master plan will examine downtown waste collection strategies, including franchise zones and compactor zones, to address noise and efficiency.

The committee also discussed the status of the Downtown Safety Initiative, which was on day 57 of its 60-day pilot period. Staff confirmed that services initiated during the pilot, including an increased public safety presence and cleanliness services, will continue beyond the 60-day mark, though specific frequencies may be adjusted. Vice Mayor Sandra Kilgore suggested a phased approach to enforcement, such as installing signs to test effectiveness, while Councilwoman Shanika Smith proposed an educational campaign using media and signage to align with the spirit of the community responder program.

Community Input Three residents provided public comment at the close of the agenda. One resident from South Market Street noted improvements in downtown cleanliness but expressed concern over excessive vehicle noise, such as illegal mufflers and revving, suggesting the use of "sound radar" for enforcement. A business owner and resident from West Asheville described serious issues with trash, vagrants, and public safety, stating that the focus on noise was like "talking about the colors of the curtains while the house is on fire." A third West Asheville resident expressed concern that the safety initiative was expanding into their neighborhood, arguing that safety should be achieved through community care rather than increased police presence. No member or staff member responded directly to these specific comments.

Follow-ups Several staff members agreed to specific next steps during the meeting. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody agreed to connect with the Director of Development Services and the Noise Advisory Board to determine how vehicular noise fits into the next steps of the downtown initiative. City Manager Deborah Campbell confirmed that the Equity and Engagement team is planning a public input survey on the noise ordinance, and the committee agreed to collaborate with the Noise Advisory Board to formulate prioritized questions for this survey. Staff stated that details on continued services beyond the 60-day period would be shared with City Council and posted on the project page by Friday, June 30, 2023. Additionally, City Attorney Brad Branham stated he was speaking with staff to review whether mandates for supervising minors at public events are authorized, following a request raised by Councilwoman Shanika Smith regarding a shooting at the Juneteenth celebration.

Impact This meeting clarifies how the city intends to address noise and waste issues by integrating them into existing major projects rather than creating new standalone programs. For residents, this means that noise enforcement and waste management improvements will be part of the broader Downtown Safety Initiative and the newly funded Solid Waste Master Plan. The continuation of safety and cleanliness services beyond the 60-day pilot indicates a sustained commitment to downtown conditions, while the upcoming public survey will provide a mechanism for residents to influence how noise ordinances are prioritized and enforced.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches