Skip to main content

Boards & Commissions Committee – June 13, 2023

June 13, 2023 at 9:28 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Apr 11 meetingNext: Aug 22 meeting
  • 1 hlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville’s Boards and Commissions Committee met virtually on June 13, 2023, to review applications for various city boards and commissions. The primary focus of the session was the summer board appointment cycle, during which the committee evaluated 29 potential appointments across multiple bodies, including the African American Heritage Commission, Airport Authority, and Planning and Zoning Commission. The discussion also addressed logistical challenges regarding meeting formats, attendance requirements, and strategies to increase diversity on city boards.

Key Decisions and Appointments

The committee voted on a series of appointments and administrative actions, with all decisions passing unanimously (3-0) unless otherwise noted. The committee appointed Shalinda Pruitt to the African American Heritage Commission and reappointed Susan Russo-Klein to the Airport Authority. For the Civic Center Commission, John Ellis and Chad Evans were reappointed. On the Historic Resources Commission, Will Hornaday was reappointed and Claire Thomas was appointed.

For the Human Relations Commission (HRCA), the committee appointed Kandice Blankert and Susan Ann Sacco. Notably, the committee chose not to reappoint four existing members who had attendance concerns, leaving those seats open for further discussion regarding meeting logistics. On the Multimodal Transportation Commission, Jack Igleman was reappointed, while Joseph Barker and Mike Zukoski were appointed. The Neighborhood Advisory Committee received new appointments for Sandra Fremphong (Area 28805), Joe Taylor (Area 28804), and Dane Barriger (At Large).

The committee reappointed Shirley Walker Whitesides, Pat Kappas, and Pete Perez to the Public Art and Cultural Commission, postponing other appointments to re-advertise for remaining seats. The Sustainability Advisory Committee was directed to re-advertise to recruit for specific expertise. The committee recommended Lucius Wilson for appointment to the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority (TDA) by the full Council. Finally, the Planning and Zoning Commission position was re-advertised through July 31, with all applicants to be interviewed in August. The committee also voted by consensus to cancel its July 11 meeting and reschedule its August meeting to August 22 at 1:00 PM to accommodate these interviews.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the HRCA, where the committee discussed low attendance rates, noting that two members had a 40% attendance rate. Concerns were raised that the board’s transition to in-person meetings created barriers for some members due to childcare and transportation issues. Council Member Kim Rooney stated, "I'm willing to consider appointment of the two recommendations and leave the others open to support the HRCA bringing on new members while also maintaining some of the conversation moving forward." She also noted, "I just wanted to say that we just had a number of founding members of our HRCA roll off... I am very glad that we have an applicant here who's working with the disabled community with Susan Ann Sacco."

Staff provided context on past practices, with a staff member explaining, "I can tell the council that in the past when the attendance records have not been up to the 75%, that council would reappoint and in the reappointment letter, they would specifically state... you have six months to bring it up to a hundred percent or 75% attendance. And if not, we will revisit your appointment." Regarding meeting formats, Deputy City Clerk Sarah Gross clarified, "Hybrid is definitely in discussion. And I believe at the June 20th... the CAPE team... will be given an update specific to hybrid meetings to that council committee." Staff also presented an update on outreach efforts to increase BIPOC representation, including targeted outreach to neighborhood organizations, partnerships with local media such as low-power FM stations and Spanish-language publications, and digital displays at the City Transit Center. Additionally, staff announced a new board member resource page and a dry run for a new member orientation, which includes racial equity training, scheduled for July.

During the Planning and Zoning discussion, Assistant City Clerk Jerry Goldberg flagged a potential behavioral concern regarding one applicant, stating, "I just want to call council's attention to one of the applicants, Paul Zay. He is the one that came to council with the... hat on and serve subpoenas on the city manager and the police chief during the meeting."

Follow-ups

Staff agreed to connect with the HRCA staff liaison to confirm the status of hybrid meetings and attendance issues. The Communication and Public Engagement (CAPE) team will reach out to low-power FM stations, specifically "Slay the Mic" and "STM Media," and Spanish-language publications, including Ola Carolina and La Noticia, to coordinate outreach once language access programs are ready. Staff will adjust the calendar invite for the August 22 meeting to allow for a two-hour buffer for interviews. Council Member Kim Rooney agreed to bring questions about HRCA attendance notification practices to the HRCA’s next meeting. Staff will provide an update on hybrid meeting policies to the Council Committee on June 20.

Impact

These decisions shape the composition of the city’s advisory bodies, directly influencing how the city addresses issues ranging from transportation and sustainability to cultural heritage and human relations. By holding seats on the HRCA open pending further discussion on meeting logistics, the committee is prioritizing the viability of the board’s operations alongside the inclusion of new members. The emphasis on hybrid meeting policies and targeted outreach reflects an ongoing effort to make city governance more accessible and representative of the diverse communities it serves.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches