Skip to main content

Human Relations Commission – May 18, 2023

May 18, 2023 at 5:59 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Mar 16 meetingNext: Jul 20 meeting
  • 1 h 49 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Human Relations Commission Meeting Recap: May 18, 2023

The Human Relations Commission of Asheville convened on May 18, 2023, to address a range of community issues, including a recent police incident, commission governance, and ongoing subcommittee work. The meeting was opened by staff liaison Elena, as the Chair was running late. A temporary chair was voted in to conduct business until the Chair arrived. The agenda included staff updates, public comment, a discussion on meeting formats, farewells to departing members, and the election of new officers.

Key Decisions and Votes The Commission took several formal actions during the meeting. First, Commissioner Harvey Dean Harrell moved to nominate Commissioner Alma Atkins to serve as temporary chair, a motion that was approved by a show of hands with no recorded nays or abstentions. The Commission then approved the minutes from the March 16, 2023 meeting, which was moved by Harvey Dean Harrell and seconded by Alma Atkins; the vote was all in favor. Regarding the format of future meetings, the Commission debated whether to move from in-person to virtual meetings to improve accessibility and address safety concerns. However, Daniel Young moved to table the vote on the meeting format to the next meeting, a motion that carried with all votes in favor.

The Commission also elected new officers. For the position of Vice Chair, Harvey Dean Harrell, Daniel Young, and Alma Atkins were nominated. The City Attorney noted that a majority of four out of seven present was required. The final result declared Daniel Young as the elected Vice Chair. Subsequently, Alma Atkins was nominated for Chair and was elected unanimously, with all votes in favor.

Discussion Highlights Staff reported that a recommendation from the Housing and Land Policy Advisory (HLPA) committee, made at the previous March meeting, is scheduled to go to the Equity and Engagement Committee on June 20th. The Commission also received updates from its subcommittees: the "Addressing Housing Issues" subcommittee discussed challenges with obtaining accurate homeless data, while the "Examining Systems" subcommittee provided updates on financial literacy and data analysis. Community announcements were made for the BIPOC Farmers Market, a Shiloh community storytelling event, and "The Grind" festival.

The Commission honored departing members Tanya Rodriguez, Dolores Venable, and Brandon Oliver. Outgoing Chair Tanya Rodriguez stated, "It has been one of the greatest honors of my life to serve in this capacity... I'm grateful that we've gotten recommendations to the table... to City Council." New Chair Alma Atkins expressed her commitment to equity, stating, "I firmly believe in equity for all men and women. I'm very much community minded and I believe that everyone in the community has a voice."

Community Input The majority of the public comment period focused on a recent police incident involving a Black man in the Lawton/Oakland Road area. A public commenter cited statistics on Black incarceration in Buncombe County, stating that no de-escalation tactics were used and requesting an independent investigation under public oversight, the release of body camera footage, and communication from the Chief of Police to the harmed community. In response, the City Attorney stated that the body camera footage had already been provided to the District Attorney’s office, which determined there was no probable cause to charge any officer. The City Attorney noted that his office was filing a request for a court order to release the footage publicly "tomorrow morning" to ensure transparency.

Another public commenter, who stated he was not speaking on behalf of the family, requested a meeting with city officials to discuss de-escalation training, the use of community health workers in police interactions, and accountability for young officers. The City Attorney responded by affirming that the City Council shared the sentiment that everyone in the community should feel safe and protected, and noted that he had sent more information to City Council that afternoon. A third public commenter expressed discomfort regarding the surprise presence of media, stating she felt "traumatized" and "ambushed." The City Attorney explained that public meetings are open to the media and that staff is not typically made aware of media attendance in advance.

Follow-Ups Staff liaison Elena agreed to follow up with the City Clerk’s office regarding the possibility of exit interviews for departing board members and to provide that information to the Commissioner who asked. Elena also agreed to follow up with a member referred to as "Don" to determine if he can attend the next meeting, and to follow up with Commissioner Dolores Venable to get more information on data tools (Urban Economic Fund) to provide to HRCA members. Additionally, Elena agreed to add Commissioner Crystal Michelle Reid to the "Improving HRCA" subcommittee, subject to the approval of other committee members. The City Attorney agreed to file a request with the Buncombe County Superior Court the next morning for an order to release the body camera footage and to keep the Human Relations Commission informed about the issue.

Impact This meeting marked a significant transition in the Commission’s leadership with the election of Alma Atkins as Chair and Daniel Young as Vice Chair. The decision to table the vote on virtual meetings indicates that the Commission will continue to deliberate on how to best balance accessibility with the dynamics of in-person gatherings, particularly in light of media presence. The focus on the police incident highlights the Commission’s role in addressing community trauma and advocating for transparency in law enforcement, with the City Attorney’s commitment to seeking a court order for body camera footage serving as a concrete next step in that process.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches