Downtown Commission – May 12, 2023
May 12, 2023 at 8:30 AM
- 2 h 52 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Downtown Commission Meeting Recap: May 12, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission convened on May 12, 2023, to address public safety initiatives, major redevelopment projects, and commission operations. The meeting began with the approval of the previous meeting’s action minutes, which passed unanimously. The agenda then moved to public comment, followed by detailed reviews of the Downtown Safety Initiative, emergency operations planning, and two significant development projects: Project Aspire and "The Duke."
Key Decisions and Votes The only formal vote taken at this meeting was the approval of the previous meeting’s minutes, which passed unanimously. No formal votes were taken on the other agenda items. For the Downtown Safety Initiative and Emergency Operations plans, the Commission received updates but did not vote on adoption. Regarding the potential change in meeting times, no formal vote was taken; instead, staff agreed to investigate the feasibility of moving meetings from the second Friday to the fourth Friday at 9:00 AM and will report back with options. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn, which was made, seconded, and passed.
Discussion Highlights: Safety and Emergency Planning A multi-departmental update on the Downtown Safety Initiative, a 60-day pilot program launched on May 1, was presented by representatives from the Police, Fire, Public Works, and Parks departments. Chief David Sack of the Asheville Police Department emphasized that the current effort focuses on "presence and education" rather than enforcement, noting that citations and arrests are often unnecessary when education is prioritized. Deborah Campbell from the City Manager’s Office highlighted the importance of ensuring residents feel comfortable interacting with downtown businesses. The Fire Department also presented the city’s Emergency Operations and Continuity of Operations Plans. Jeremy Knighton, Chief of Emergency Management, described the planning process as "iterative" and a "continual update," emphasizing that the department will return to the Commission to demonstrate how public feedback has been incorporated into the final plans.
Discussion Highlights: Project Reviews The Commission reviewed Project Aspire, a conceptual master plan for the redevelopment of the YMCA, State Employee Credit Union, and First Baptist Church properties. Discussions covered the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) application strategy, architectural design in relation to historic buildings, and caps on hotel rooms. Robert Poppleton of the Furman Company stated that the developer is "privileged to be working with the YMCA and the First Baptist Church of Asheville" and committed to pursuing green building technologies and sustainable stormwater management. Commissioner Andrew Fletcher described the resource investment as a "historic re-correction and re-engagement with downtown," while Commissioner Sage Turner expressed optimism about reinserting an "architectural jewel" into the urban fabric. The item will proceed to the Design Review Committee next week, followed by the Planning and Zoning Commission and City Council.
The Commission also reviewed a Level 2 application for "The Duke," a project involving the adaptive reuse of the historic Hayes and Lunsford Electric Company building at the corner of Ashland and Hilliard. Staff and members discussed site plan traffic management, pedestrian connections to South Grove Street, and stormwater management. Staff noted that placing stormwater storage systems underneath the building is "not the good long-term answer" for the client. One member expressed concern about the pedestrian experience along the parking deck, stating, "I just, I really don't like that pedestrian experience... See what you can do." Another member commented that the current scale of the project is appropriate compared to previous iterations that were too large for the residential portion.
Community Input During public comment, a resident expressed concern about the lack of representation from the Eagle Market Street area, initially asking the Commission to consider resigning a seat to allow for better diversity. Later in the meeting, the same commenter retracted the request for resignation and instead asked the Commission to specify the type of diversity sought for the new seat, suggesting recruitment from local businesses. Members responded by asking the commenter to clarify the specific realm of diversity desired and encouraged them to continue recruiting efforts, noting there are several months before the appointment deadline. Another public commenter representing the Downtown Area Residential Neighbors (DARN) board complimented the Asheville Police Department and specific officers for their transparent outreach and efforts to improve public safety.
Follow-Ups Staff committed to posting data on the Downtown Safety Initiative project page and reporting updates to City Council’s Environment and Safety Committee, with the first reports expected later in May. The Police Department’s Community Engagement Division is creating a document for businesses on utilizing online reporting tools and implementing crime prevention measures. The Fire Department confirmed the Community Responder Program is ongoing and is working to establish a direct phone line for urgent non-police matters. Staff are working with the Asheville Downtown Association to schedule three public safety walk-throughs in different areas of downtown.
For Project Aspire, staff (Will Pomplis) stated that comments from the Downtown Commission will be folded into the Design Review Committee staff report. The presenter agreed to speak with the housing chair regarding the LIHTC application timeline and percentage targets. For "The Duke," staff agreed to add a question to their list regarding whether the applicant is granting an ingress-egress easement for the pedestrian connection to the Grove neighborhood to ensure it cannot be closed off in the future. Staff also confirmed they would share the project plans with the Police Department’s Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) team to get feedback on safety and lighting.
Regarding commission operations, staff agreed to look into moving the commission meeting to the fourth Friday at 9:00 AM and would report back with options or a poll if that time did not work. Staff and members agreed to spread the word about the commission vacancy and encourage applications from diverse backgrounds and specific downtown areas.
Impact These discussions highlight the City’s ongoing efforts to balance development with public safety and community engagement. The multi-departmental approach to the Downtown Safety Initiative aims to create a more welcoming environment for residents and visitors, while the review of Project Aspire and "The Duke" addresses the integration of new housing and commercial spaces into the historic downtown fabric. The Commission’s focus on specific design details, such as pedestrian access and stormwater management, reflects a commitment to ensuring that new developments contribute positively to the neighborhood’s functionality and safety.
Meeting Video & Transcript