Environment & Safety Committee – April 25, 2023
April 25, 2023 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 47 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Environment and Safety Committee Meeting Recap: April 25, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Environment and Safety Committee convened on April 25, 2023, to review ongoing sustainability initiatives, emergency preparedness plans, and public safety programs. The committee addressed several agenda items, including updates on the Food Scraps Drop-Off Program, the development of citywide emergency operations plans, the upcoming launch of a Community Responder Program, and potential clean energy loan opportunities. The meeting concluded with the approval of recent minutes and a recommendation to advance the food scraps program to City Council.
Key Decisions The committee took two formal votes during the session. First, a motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes from the March 28, 2023 meeting; the motion passed unanimously with three ayes and zero nays. Second, the committee voted to recommend the approval of developing an interlocal agreement with Buncombe County for the co-management of the Food Scraps Drop-Off Program. This motion also passed unanimously with three ayes and zero nays. Following this vote, staff confirmed that the item is scheduled to go before City Council on May 9. The meeting was adjourned by motion.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on the development of the Citywide Emergency Operations Preparedness and Continuity of Operations Plan. Staff provided an update on the creation of two new plans, emphasizing the importance of community engagement and training. Jeremy Knighton, Division Chief, stressed that a plan is ineffective without a program to train and exercise it, noting that without these exercises, the plans will not be as "lively" as they should be. Councilwoman Shanika Smith expressed enthusiasm for the initiative and asked about the possibility of future training exercises to run through the final drafts.
The committee also reviewed the Community Responder Program, a pilot focused on health and safety needs in downtown Asheville, which is on track to launch on May 1, 2023. City Manager Deborah Campbell stated that the city intends to advance this initiative into a permanent process, potentially expanding beyond the downtown area. She emphasized that the city will use data from the pilot to truly understand resource needs and investment levels, describing the current moment as a "confluence of initiatives" that includes housing, community responders, and community paramedics.
Additionally, the committee received an update from the Buncombe County Energy and Environment Subcommittee regarding a potential pilot program for low-interest clean energy loans for low- and moderate-income residents, funded by federal Inflation Reduction Act dollars. Vice Mayor Sandra Kilgore raised concerns about whether the program would subsidize the higher costs of green energy products for clients. Councilwoman Shanika Smith noted a potential threat to renters, explaining that improvements to a home could raise its value and, consequently, increase rent.
Community Input During opening public comment, a resident spoke regarding ongoing court proceedings involving the Asheville Police Department and activists. The commenter described the arrests as "political" and criticized the department for "incompetence," "grossly mishandled evidence," and "falsifying charges." The commenter argued that resources were being wasted on a "supposed felony littering case" while the city faced other crises, such as high rent costs and the state’s deadliest jail. The commenter urged the council to address the "root causes of safety issues" rather than increasing policing, stating, "We cannot incarcerate our way out of the problems that we face." Members did not respond to this comment. No public comments were received at the end of the meeting.
Follow-ups Staff and members agreed to several specific next steps. Kira Boulon, Sustainability Program Manager, confirmed that the committee’s recommendation for the Food Scraps Program will be presented to City Council on May 9. Jeremy Knighton stated that the draft Continuity of Operations Plan will be completed by May 10, followed by a tabletop exercise on May 24, with final drafts of both plans expected in August. He also confirmed that staff will incorporate recommendations from the external review committee regarding the recent water outage as those recommendations are finalized. Patrick Crudup, Assistant Fire Chief, confirmed the Community Responder Program is on track for its May 1 launch. Finally, Vice Mayor Sandra Kilgore stated she would bring the concerns raised by council members regarding the impact on renters and the structure of the clean energy loan program back to the team to consider as the program moves forward.
Impact These decisions and updates reflect the city’s ongoing efforts to enhance environmental sustainability and public safety infrastructure. The move to formalize the Food Scraps Drop-Off Program through an interlocal agreement with Buncombe County aims to streamline waste management efforts. The development of comprehensive emergency operations and continuity plans, supported by planned training exercises, is intended to improve the city’s resilience against future crises. Furthermore, the expansion of the Community Responder Program and the exploration of clean energy loans highlight the city’s focus on addressing health, safety, and economic equity for its residents.
Meeting Video & Transcript