Skip to main content

Reparations Commission – April 24, 2023

April 24, 2023 at 5:52 PM

  • 2 h 15 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On April 24, 2023, the City of Asheville Reparations Commission convened to review updates from its Impact Focus Areas (IFAs), discuss the Request for Proposal (RFP) for a comprehensive audit, and receive data on racial disparities in the criminal justice system. The meeting concluded with a roundtable discussion among commission members regarding collaboration and accountability.

Key Decisions

The commission took two formal votes during the session. A motion was made and seconded to approve the agenda as presented; the motion passed unanimously. Additionally, a motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes from the March 20 meeting, which also passed unanimously. The meeting ended with a motion to adjourn.

Discussion Highlights

The Housing IFA presented recommendations to immediately return urban renewal land currently held in moratorium by the City of Asheville for reparations purposes. They also proposed exploring the acquisition of underutilized or vacant land and creating a land acquisition program that matches the acreage taken during urban renewal. The group discussed the need for a non-profit or land trust to hold this land and addressed questions regarding property tax relief for Black homeowners. Housing IFA facilitator Salamaniah Merritt emphasized the urgency of the work, stating, "We're always talking and tired of talking, let's do something. So if we want to see that the city and the county is serious about the work that we're doing in reparations, we're going to ask that they return that land immediately."

The Criminal Justice IFA shared a mission statement focused on eliminating harm perpetuated on Black people by the criminal justice system. Their recommendations included implementing culturally competent restorative justice for students, eliminating discretionary authority by School Resource Officers (SROs) for low-level offenses, and requiring parental presence during custodial interviews of minors. The group discussed the "school-to-prison pipeline" and the role of organizations like Black Man Monday in supporting students.

The Economic Development IFA presented a draft recommendation to establish a private, tax-exempt (501c3) fund for reparations to accept private funding that the city and county cannot. They discussed the need for a Minority Supplier Development Council and potential partnerships with professional sports leagues and minority credit unions. Member Dwayne Richardson noted, "We know that the city and county have put X number of dollars forward... it is a penny in the bucket of what we will need... We have to figure out a way to work it out and create an entity... that can serve as a fundraising wing." Member Bernard Oliphant added, "We as a body really need to dig into identifying ways that we can generate resources to make what we want to happen, happen. We cannot do it with the resources that would probably be provided to us... We need additional self-generated resources."

Staff presented the published Request for Proposal for a "Comprehensive Audit, Cease Harm, Impacting the African American Community." The proposal deadline is June 8, 2023, with the award expected by July 3, 2023. Additionally, the Director of Justice Services from Buncombe County presented data on racial disparities, highlighting that Black residents are disproportionately represented in the jail population and less likely to enroll in or complete diversion programs compared to white residents. The Director stated, "Black people are three times more likely than whites to appear on the calendar [for diversion], but they are more likely to be eligible, however they're less likely to enroll... We do have a lot of work to do."

During the commission roundtable, members discussed the need for a retreat to facilitate collaboration between IFAs and the importance of accountability mechanisms. The Chair stated, "We are halfway through and your conversation should be loaded and very fruitful with each other... We have another year to go. I'm looking at this time next year to have offered a final report to the County Commission and to the City Council, April 2024." Member Roy Harris asked that the group support the chairman and vice chairman, stating, "He's gonna need our support. He's gonna need our prayers, our concerns, and our support as he represents us on a national level."

Follow-ups

The Housing IFA facilitator agreed to put meetings with other legacy neighborhoods, specifically Northside, on their list to gather feedback and to continue conversations about property tax relief and land holding entities in future meetings. The Criminal Justice IFA facilitator agreed to look into the sealing of digitized juvenile records held by schools and courts, and to reach out to Captain Lamb with the Asheville Police Department (APD) for more information. The Economic Development IFA facilitator agreed to bring copies of the draft recommendations to commissioners. Staff member Christine Edwards agreed to put the idea of a summit convening minority economic development groups out there as a potential recommendation and confirmed that the project management team is working on planning a retreat for the commission to collaborate across IFAs. Additionally, the project manager confirmed that a data request regarding officer-specific arrest rates had been submitted to the data team.

Impact

This meeting advanced the Reparations Commission’s work by detailing specific recommendations for housing, criminal justice, and economic development, while also establishing a timeline for a comprehensive audit. The presentation of data on racial disparities in the criminal justice system provided context for the commission's ongoing analysis of systemic harm. The commission’s focus on generating additional self-generated resources and collaborating across impact areas underscores the scale of the work required to address historical and ongoing inequities in Asheville.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches