Skip to main content

Asheville Regional Housing Consortium – March 22, 2023

March 22, 2023 at 10:01 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Mar 17 meetingNext: Mar 29 meeting
  • 1 h 39 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Asheville Regional Housing Consortium Meeting Recap: March 22, 2023

The Asheville Regional Housing Consortium met on March 22, 2023, to review annual funding requests for the HOME (Housing Opportunities for Modernizing Energy) program. The body evaluated approximately $8 million in requests from regional partners against a revised eligible pool of approximately $5.6 million. The discussion centered on applying funding principles such as regional parity and prioritizing projects where HOME funds represent the "last dollar" needed to make a project feasible.

The board began by approving the minutes from previous meetings held on October 21, March 6, and March 17 via roll call votes, with all recorded votes being affirmative. Staff, assisted by consultants from TDA Consulting, presented the current funding landscape, noting that available funds consisted of approximately $2.4 million in non-CHODO (Community Housing Development Opportunity) funds and approximately $403,000 in CHODO funds. Staff clarified that the CHODO figure includes carry-forward funds from a previous Madison County reallocation and corrected a typo in the initial presentation slides regarding the total available funds.

A significant portion of the meeting focused on Tenant-Based Rental Assistance (TBRA). Staff presented data showing that while $2.7 million had been allocated for TBRA over the past six years, a significant portion remained unexpended due to slow starts and contracting delays. After discussing whether to allocate new funds to agencies with existing unexpended balances, the board decided to withhold the proposed $30,000 allocation for Homeward Bound’s TBRA request to allow them to spend down previous years' funds. Conversely, the board agreed to proceed with the allocation for HelpMate, as that agency had recently gone to contract and was beginning to spend funds.

The board also discussed the allocation of remaining funds, approximately $434,000 in non-CHODO funds, for multifamily housing and new construction projects seeking Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) awards. While one member expressed a preference for funding the Vanderbilt Apartments preservation project to prevent unit loss, other members and consultants noted that the project was largely funded and that HOME funds were not the "last dollar" required. In contrast, other projects were at risk of failing to secure tax credits without this funding. Consultant Peter Hughes of TDA Consulting noted regarding the Villas at Haywood project, "Just to kind of put it in context, it doesn’t mean it’s not a worthy project, but all things being equal, they’re getting the least amount of equity and asking for the largest per unit subsidy."

The board decided not to make a final allocation of the remaining $434,000 at this meeting. Instead, they agreed to continue the item to a future meeting to clarify the exact amount of available CHODO funds from prior years, which staff estimated could be an additional $200,000–$400,000. The board also aimed to determine the best use of the total available funds to ensure at least one or two LIHTC projects can secure their awards and to revisit the allocation for Henderson County’s Habitat for Humanity Down Payment Assistance, potentially scaling it back if funds are needed for new construction. Member Karen Keenan stated, "I just feel like we’re jumping ahead just because we’re out of time. We all know that this is too important to make that type of decision. And I think we’re all committed to devoting the time between now and the end of the month."

There were no public comments recorded during the meeting, as the chair noted there was no one in the queue. Regarding next steps, staff agreed to verify the exact amount of prior-year CHODO funds available for reallocation. The board agreed to reconvene before the end of the month, ideally in the first week of April, to finalize funding recommendations for the multifamily projects and the Habitat for Humanity down payment assistance program. This timeline is necessary to allow for the required 30-day public comment period before the annual action plan is submitted to City Council. Staff also agreed to send calendar invites for the follow-up meeting.

This meeting is significant for residents as it addresses the distribution of federal housing funds that support affordable housing options in the region. By deferring the final decision on new construction and tax credit projects, the board is ensuring that limited funds are directed toward projects that are most likely to succeed and provide the greatest benefit, rather than funding projects that are already largely financed. The upcoming follow-up meeting will determine how these funds are ultimately distributed to regional partners.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches